• The Knot
  • The Nest
  • The Bump
  • The Blush
Special Topic Wedding Boards
Cat:Special Topic Wedding Boards
Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??
Moms and Maids
Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??
Is a family member or your BFF getting married? Get and give advice here.
Of the 5 girls in my bridal party, 3 are my sisters. I went with them to order their dresses this past Sunday. (One is out of state, so she is ordering separately). I gave them MONTHS notice to save
0
False
Moms and Maids
Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??
Is a family member or your BFF getting married? Get and give advice here.
Of the 5 girls in my bridal party, 3 are my sisters. I went with them to order their dresses this past Sunday. (One is out of state, so she is ordering separately). I gave them MONTHS notice to save
0
Cat:Special Topic Wedding BoardsForum:357
Cat:Special Topic Wedding BoardsForum:357Discussion:16690d59-b51d-4635-8878-4f5687800777
Forums  >  Special Topic Wedding Boards  >  Moms and Maids  >  Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??
You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:06 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA
210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Warts can be removed.

Friends and family can't, unless you want to "remove" all semblance of a relationship with them.  It's a very public slight.
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:26 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
04-21-2009
BOSTON
4331759186211146
Posts: 968
First: 5/2/2011

Last: 3/29/2012


Retread, I love it.
Photobucket

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:37 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
08-25-2004
LANSING
120571125008576
Posts: 3354
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Stupid knot - where is the rest of this thread?

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:41 PM EST on weddings.com
Joined on
10-03-2010
PHOENIX
4039216651991551
Posts: 8798
First: 10/22/2010

Last: 5/24/2012


I went into my posts to see if it would still take me to the original thread and this is where it took me -



Good grief. 


Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:44 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
06-17-2010
PHOENIX
7606123823916571
Posts: 9219
First: 6/24/2010

Last: 5/23/2012


I can't see the OP, but just the title is enough to answer.

YES, YOU ARE WRONG.
Anniversary
Photobucket

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:45 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
04-21-2009
BOSTON
4331759186211146
Posts: 968
First: 5/2/2011

Last: 3/29/2012


Huh, I thought it was a DD.
Photobucket

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:48 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
02-25-2007
BOSTON
6080079946532612
Posts: 141
First: 9/25/2011

Last: 5/23/2012


Jemmini6, you need to read the original post before making a statement like that. Until then, you really shouldn't be so harsh & you have no grounds to make such a statement.

I def think something is wrong w/the message boards today as I have been having issues seeing everyone's posts! :(

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:51 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
05-17-2011
PITTSBURGH
8060412467088156
Posts: 1335
First: 9/19/2011

Last: 4/29/2012


OP, I can't see your original post.  Removing a friend from the wedding party can often damage a relationship beyond repair.  It gets doubly dangerous when the bridesmaid in question is a sister.

If you do this, you can expect massive family drama, and not just with sis.  At best, you will be hearing about it years later.  At worst, it could cause an estrangement that lasts years, or is even permanent.  You need to weigh that against whatever you are trying to avoid or punish by kicking her out.

Sometimes, that price is worth it.  I am estranged from my sister, who is not even invited to my wedding.  But it isn't something to be done lightly, and very few wedding-related hassles would deserve that extreme response.  If all she did was ordinary BM stuff like missing a dress trip, or not having the time to go to every vendor, let it go. 
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:52 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
10-03-2010
PHOENIX
4039216651991551
Posts: 8798
First: 10/22/2010

Last: 5/24/2012


cvmami, actually, Jemmini is completely right.  Unless your sister slept with your fiance or physically attacked you (which she didn't, I read the OP), then kicking her out of your BP is wrong. 

Give her a deadline to order her dress and go from there. 

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 12:56 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
02-25-2007
BOSTON
6080079946532612
Posts: 141
First: 9/25/2011

Last: 5/23/2012


@retreadbride, my sister is a very unemotional detached person. She is very odd. She doesn't care about things you'd expect people to care about. She wont care either way. (That actually makes me sad to say, but it's true.)

I don't want to remove anyone. I love everyone I chose. But at the same time, this is my wedding day. Why would anyone want anyone to cause drama & ruin the day for everyone else??

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 1:00 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
06-30-2009
DC AREA
5325819182205934
Posts: 8369
First: 9/26/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


OP -- Your original post is gone. I would suggest reposting it.

But if it says, "My sister isn't as excited for my wedding as she should be," then the responses will be the same. Don't kick her out.


Photobucket

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 1:10 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-06-2009
CONNECTICUT
8505957128339998
Posts: 2744
First: 12/7/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Are you able to repost your OP?

If your sister has committed a crime against you or your loved ones (including pets), tried to seduce your fi or is actively trying to prevent the marriage, you may kick her out of the wedding party. Odd behaviour does not qualify as a reason to ditch her.

All your sister has to do is buy the agreed upon dress, show up on time for the ceremony. You don't have to involve her in any of the planning.

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 1:38 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
02-25-2007
BOSTON
6080079946532612
Posts: 141
First: 9/25/2011

Last: 5/23/2012


I can't repost it! Ahhhh! Lol. Idk what is going on with this site today. :(

I haven't asked her to do anything other than buy her dress. She hasn't done that & that is the MAJOR issue!
I haven't asked her to go anywhere with me, etc. All I asked was that she order her dress. I'd think that's an important part of being a BM, no?
So let's just be hypothetical. Let's say she never orders her dress (with her this is a VERY possible scenario), I should still have her in the wedding & let her wear anything she finds?? Sorry, not happening. I am so willing to work with people & compromise & I have worked around their schedules & made many decisions based upon my bridesmaids because I want them all to be happy. But I will NOT be compromising on ordering & wearing a bridesmaid dress.

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 1:39 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
10-30-2011
4065556074933139
Posts: 1449
First: 10/30/2011

Last: 5/24/2012


Doesn't really matter cvmami78, as Maire said, unless your sister tried to kill you or sleep with your fiance, it's wrong to remove her.  Haven't read your OP, but I have yet to read one where I agree with a WP member being kicked out.

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 1:44 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-06-2009
CONNECTICUT
8505957128339998
Posts: 2744
First: 12/7/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Getting the dress is just about her only duty. If she doesn't get it, then she will be removing herself from the wedding party. You don't have to let her wear whatever she wants.

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 3:19 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
06-17-2010
PHOENIX
7606123823916571
Posts: 9219
First: 6/24/2010

Last: 5/23/2012


In Response to Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??:
Jemmini6, you need to read the original post before making a statement like that. Until then, you really shouldn't be so harsh & you have no grounds to make such a statement. I def think something is wrong w/the message boards today as I have been having issues seeing everyone's posts! :(
Posted by cvmami78



Kicking anyone out of your WP for any reason other than them physically attacking you or trying to sleep with your FI is wrong.  Since those are extremely rare circumstances and almost never come up on TK, I was pretty confident in my answer.

If this is just over her getting a dress, give her the deadline to order it and then let her be an adult.  Don't micromanage.  If she gets the dress, great.  If not, then she has removed herself from the WP, no need for you to do it preemptively.

Although I must say, if it's you sister, I'd hope that her presence would mean more to you than what she's wearing, but regardless, etiquette-wise, you do not need to allow her to stand up with you if she does not have the designated dress.
Anniversary
Photobucket

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 3:30 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
05-17-2011
PITTSBURGH
8060412467088156
Posts: 1335
First: 9/19/2011

Last: 4/29/2012


All I asked was that she order her dress. I'd think that's an important part of being a BM, no? So let's just be hypothetical. Let's say she never orders her dress (with her this is a VERY possible scenario), I should still have her in the wedding & let her wear anything she finds?? Sorry, not happening.... I will NOT be compromising on ordering & wearing a bridesmaid dress.
Posted by cvmami78

It is not only important, it's one of the very few actual "duties" a bridesmaid has.  Forgive the obvious question, but you did ask her what her budget was, and choose a dress within that budget, yes?  I will assume that you did.

In that case, find out the actual last date to order the dress and have it guaranteed arrive on time.  The bridal shop will almost certainly try to bump back this date for the sake of the commission, so you'll have to be firm about what you need.

Give your sister the date.  Let her know that if she doesn't order by this date, you can't promise the dress will arrive in time, in which case, she will of course be welcome to attend as a guest.  Then let the topic go.  If she doesn't order the dress, she will have taken herself out of the wedding party.  

It sounds like essentially the same thing, but there is a big difference between kicking her out and her dropping out on her own.
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 7:45 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA
210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Your wedding isn't until August. She's got plenty of time to get a dress before the wedding, unless it's an exclusive designer line.

If the salon is pushing you, be aware that they work on commission, and have to meet sales quotas or they lose their jobs. They'll pressure you with all sorts of tactics in order to get your order in their hot little hands. David's Bridal is especially bad about this.

You give her the ordering info.

THEN LEAVE IT ALONE.

She either gets the dress, or she doesn't. If she doesn't, then she's taken herself out of the wedding party, and you proceed as planned. 

You can't kick her out yourself, though.  It's a very public slight to her, and tends to carry on for YEARS past the wedding. It also has a way of sucking other family members into the feud.  You don't want this.

All she has to do is get her dress and show up.  That's it. Let her do that.  It's nice if other people are eager to hear your wedding details, especially family, but lots of people are bored silly by wedding talk.

If you want to talk wedding, come here. We love it, and our eyes don't glaze over  when someone starts gushing about their favors and cakes.
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 1/31/2012 8:28 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
07-29-2009
SANTA BARBARA/VENTURA
9935844266298883
Posts: 1245
First: 10/25/2009

Last: 5/18/2012


In Response to Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??:
Jemmini6, you need to read the original post before making a statement like that. Until then, you really shouldn't be so harsh & you have no grounds to make such a statement. I def think something is wrong w/the message boards today as I have been having issues seeing everyone's posts! :(
Posted by cvmami78

Unless OP's sister tried to murder her or slept with the groom (in which case the wedding should be off altogether anyway), Jemmini was correct.  In the absence of issues as serious as that, the details of the situation don't matter.

Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 2/1/2012 3:29 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
10-30-2011
4065556074933139
Posts: 1449
First: 10/30/2011

Last: 5/24/2012


In Response to Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??:
Definitely don't judge just on the fact that it's her sister. I've known people with pretty dysfunctional families. Though, just based on what I did see in the remnants of this thread, perhaps the OP's sister has Asperger's?
Posted by AFP07


Say what now?


Re: Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

posted at 2/6/2012 4:55 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
05-08-2011
ARKANSAS
8717404672771408
Posts: 102
First: 8/16/2011

Last: 3/26/2012


These "Can I kick someone out of the wedding" threads are like car wrecks. I really don't want to know, but somehow I can't quit looking at them...

Forums > Special Topic Wedding Boards > Moms and Maids > Removing sister as Bridesmaid. Am I wrong??

My Viewing Preferences

Show user signatures

new! vendor reviews


Review your vendors
(the great and not-so-great) here!



WATCH! Fun ideas for bridal showers, bachelorette parties and more

shop personalized
favors, gifts & more

Shop Now
The Knot Wedding Shop