Wedding Boards
Cat:Wedding Boards
Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
Registering and Gifts
Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
Should you register? (The answer is a collective “YES!”) Chat about when, where, and what to register for here.
I'm just affraid that we will get too much of the same thing, also, I am hispanic and most of my people (hispanics) never even look at the registry most of the times and just buy random presents. But
0
False
Registering and Gifts
Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
Should you register? (The answer is a collective “YES!”) Chat about when, where, and what to register for here.
I'm just affraid that we will get too much of the same thing, also, I am hispanic and most of my people (hispanics) never even look at the registry most of the times and just buy random presents. But
0
Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:34
Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:34Discussion:7c20cbe7-1c5a-4a8e-ae15-9f4c5305cce0
1
|
Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 11:00 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
10-24-2011
DALLAS-FORT WORTH 7358550541430156
Posts: 7
First: 2/3/2012
Last: 3/21/2012
|
I'm just affraid that we will get too much of the same thing, also, I am hispanic and most of my people (hispanics) never even look at the registry most of the times and just buy random presents. But then again I definitely do not want to come off as bossy/demanding or just too high maintenance. What do you suggest?
|
2
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 11:10 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
11-07-2011
MINNEAPOLIS-ST. PAUL 7379562558699909
Posts: 1674
First: 12/23/2011
Last: 5/9/2012
|
Yes, it is too demanding. It is also very rude.
You should not mention gifts to your guests at all.
|
3
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 11:16 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
03-04-2011
Chicago Suburbs 9969348363816636
Posts: 1265
First: 3/16/2011
Last: 5/10/2012
|
In Response to Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
I'm just affraid that we will get too much of the same thing, also, I am hispanic and most of my people (hispanics) never even look at the registry most of the times and just buy random presents. But then again I definitely do not want to come off as bossy/demanding or just too high maintenance. What do you suggest?
Posted by Eli Rangel
Gifts are never to be expected or demanded in ANY form.
|
"TK = shove ideas down your throat and Wedding Bee is for sunshine up the a$$." - sparent2010
4
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 11:28 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
07-06-2010
NEW JERSEY 8667140365315198
Posts: 2935
First: 8/6/2010
Last: 5/24/2012
|
In Response to Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
I'm just affraid that we will get too much of the same thing, also, I am hispanic and most of my people (hispanics) never even look at the registry most of the times and just buy random presents. But then again I definitely do not want to come off as bossy/demanding or just too high maintenance. What do you suggest?
Posted by Eli Rangel
Well, that's an incorrect generalization. I'm Cuban, live in a densely Hispanic neighborhood and have been to numerous showers for women of different Hispanic backgrounds. They've always received their registry items. There will always be a few who go off registry. That has nothing to do with your background or even region of the country. Some just want to give something they feel is more 'personal.' I've already received a few registry items & haven't even had my shower yet.
Just make sure that the registry cards are included in the shower invite (NOT the wedding invite). Whenever someone brings up your shower, say how much you are looking forward to using some of the items on your registry. Ask your mom/sisters/family to spread the word that you're excited about your registry.
|
5
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 12:19 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
08-26-2010
NEW ORLEANS 7932184487188907
Posts: 2448
First: 8/29/2010
Last: 5/21/2012
|
Yes unfortunately all you can do is to spread word of mouth that you are registered at X store if someone asks what you would like or where you are registered. Especially if people in your circle have a tendency to give boxed gifts instead of cash/gift cards I would make sure you register for things you would actually want. Perhaps people who don't consider your registry will get you similar items you can still use, or things you could exchange or re-gift.
|
Anticipation...Anticipa-a-tion...
6
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 1:14 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
05-19-2010
NEW JERSEY 4221098962444643
Posts: 4975
First: 5/24/2010
Last: 5/25/2012
|
It's rude and tacky. End of story. And buy the way your description of Hispanics is offensive.
|
7
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 4:56 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
12-28-2010
MAINE 7455291438582201
Posts: 3990
First: 1/27/2011
Last: 5/25/2012
|
Yes, it is bossy, demanding, and maybe some other things to tell people "I don't want whatever you might pick out on your own, and I don't trust you to look at my registry or get something nice, just get me a gift card."
|
8
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 10:18 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
07-29-2009
SANTA BARBARA/VENTURA 9935844266298883
Posts: 1245
First: 10/25/2009
Last: 5/18/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
Wow snarky brides, give Eli Rangel a break!! Let's be honest, we all dread those 'grandma gifts' or the gifts people bring just for the sake of not showing up empty handed. I know a lot of people who have stressed over this topic. I have seen the best way to handle this--- On the invitations to the bridal shower (or if you include the registry list in your save-the-dates or wedding invite), it is usually indicated where you are registered. List the store(s) you are registered at and write in that you and your fiance' also enjoy shopping at ___. Or write "Our favorite place to shop is____". Lots of people write-in places like Lowes or Home Depot when they are doing home renovations. It's important to remember that (let's face it) this is just one of thoise things that people do. You are not MAKING anyone show up with gifts- it is a tradition. Some people won't bring a gift, and that's ok too. Anyone who tells you that you are a jerk for thinking like this is wrong, you're just the one to voice your concern. Ash
Posted by crashwee
1. Nothing about registries should go in wedding invitations or on STDs, period.
2. The bride and groom should not be writing anything on the shower invitation, as they are not the hosts and are not the ones sending out the invitations.
|
9
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/3/2012 10:34 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
04-18-2011
UPSTATE NEW YORK 9010387469159879
Posts: 17
First: 1/23/2012
Last: 5/9/2012
|
OK, so tell your MOH to write it on your bridal shower invites.
Regardless- you have to take the initiative to register (AKA- tag things you and your fiance' want/need), so by adding the "you and your fiance' also enjoy shopping at ___." or "Our favorite place to shop is____", you are just adding another option.
I guess you can't please everyone. Also, be careful what you post- as you may have noticed, this is a popular forum for bridezillas to over-analyze and judge every word you type.
Hopefully I have given you a helpful suggestion.
Happy planning ;)
|
10
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/4/2012 12:48 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA 210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009
Last: 5/24/2012
|
Crashwee, nobody here was rude except you. We have moderators here to prevent that. Bridezillas, by the way, are selfish, demanding brides who run over their friends in the name of "my day." The brides who advise you to observe etiquette are NOT bridezilllas. Your post contains namecalling, and is a personal attack. I think you should re-read The Knot's rules.
Moving right along.
Asking for cash is a faux pas. Asking for gift cards is the same as asking for cash.
Registry information doesn't belong in wedding invitations.
It's okay to include registry information in shower invitations, but write it on the invitation. Those tacky little store cards turn an invitation into a commercial for the store.
|
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."
11
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/4/2012 11:01 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
10-23-2011
NORTH CAROLINA 7567549559957205
Posts: 124
First: 12/27/2011
Last: 5/25/2012
|
I see absolutely no problem with asking for gift cards, especially if your circumstances demand some creative gifting.
Our friends got married last year and I was more than happy to give the bride a big fat gift card to the store of her choice. I knew that like my FI and I, her and her husband were going through lots of housing changes and a gift card would be much more helpful than an actual present (which would have to be moved cross-country to their new home). Many people followed suit and she was thrilled. I personally added a few little extras (like a notepad personalized with their last name, ect in order to add a more personality and thoughtfulness to the gift of the card)
In my upcoming shower, I would be more than happy to accept gift cards.
|
12
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/4/2012 4:05 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
03-04-2011
Chicago Suburbs 9969348363816636
Posts: 1265
First: 3/16/2011
Last: 5/10/2012
|
Showers are to "shower" the bride with physical gifts. It is inappropriate to have a shower without having a physical registry...
|
"TK = shove ideas down your throat and Wedding Bee is for sunshine up the a$$." - sparent2010
13
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/4/2012 6:07 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
08-03-2011
CONNECTICUT 9882479812583126
Posts: 668
First: 8/14/2011
Last: 5/23/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
I see absolutely no problem with asking for gift cards, especially if your circumstances demand some creative gifting. Our friends got married last year and I was more than happy to give the bride a big fat gift card to the store of her choice. I knew that like my FI and I, her and her husband were going through lots of housing changes and a gift card would be much more helpful than an actual present (which would have to be moved cross-country to their new home). Many people followed suit and she was thrilled. I personally added a few little extras (like a notepad personalized with their last name, ect in order to add a more personality and thoughtfulness to the gift of the card) In my upcoming shower, I would be more than happy to accept gift cards.
Posted by becky659
Her "circumstances" are that she is afraid her Hispanic friends and family are not going to pick out gifts that she likes.
You can never demand gift cards because you can never demand gifts of any kind. Besides, if they aren't likely to buy from your registry, what makes you think they will listen to your wishes for gift cards?
Don't be rude and bossy and just be grateful for anything you receive.
About half of my guests are Mexican, and my FI already told me that in his hometown/region, people bring physical gifts to the wedding, and brides do not register. It's old-school tradition that the guests actually carry their gifts to the bride and groom's new home after the wedding. We will not be surprised if some of our friends bring appliances or even furniture to our wedding as gifts.
Some of those things may not be our taste or our style. We may not need some of them. But we will be grateful for anything we receive and are not worried about what people will choose to give us as a gift.
|
14
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/5/2012 12:45 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA 210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009
Last: 5/24/2012
|
God has provided a wonderful resource for brides who get gifts that aren't to their taste. It's called eBay.
|
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."
15
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/6/2012 1:02 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
09-05-2005
PITTSBURGH 969750437509409
Posts: 179
First: 1/13/2012
Last: 5/16/2012
|
Wow, really. Just a friendly FYI, the "don't put registry info on the wedding invites" is NOT a universal thing. My FI was baffled that I didn't want to include this in ours, as it was perfect custom in his circles growing up (mostly Mormons in UT) to see a minor registry note at the bottom of the wedding invitation.
A deviation, but I do agree that some on the registry/etiquette boards are too uptight. Traditions change, etiquette changes. It's perfectly acceptable for brides to wear short dresses, no sleeves, flip flops, not have a wedding cake, not include "obey" in their vows, have a "man of honor" or walk with someone other than their father down the aisle. There's really no one-size-fits-all approach to anything, even etiquette rules.
|
16
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/6/2012 6:52 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
12-28-2010
MAINE 7455291438582201
Posts: 3990
First: 1/27/2011
Last: 5/25/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?: Wow, really. Just a friendly FYI, the "don't put registry info on the wedding invites" is NOT a universal thing. My FI was baffled that I didn't want to include this in ours, as it was perfect custom in his circles growing up (mostly Mormons in UT) to see a minor registry note at the bottom of the wedding invitation. A deviation, but I do agree that some on the registry/etiquette boards are too uptight. Traditions change, etiquette changes. It's perfectly acceptable for brides to wear short dresses, no sleeves, flip flops, not have a wedding cake, not include "obey" in their vows, have a "man of honor" or walk with someone other than their father down the aisle. There's really no one-size-fits-all approach to anything, even etiquette rules.
Posted by Tandra&Devin All the things you listed at the end are not etiquette issues, they're traditions (for some, not even universal traditions). Etiquette is about making your guests feel comfortable. While some of my guests might have been disappointed that we didn't have a giant wedding cake, we had plenty of good desserts and there was no problem, etiquette-wise.
And yes, people come on here and say that they've seen registry info on a wedding invitation. That doesn't make it proper etiquette. I wouldn't go up to a friend and say, "I have a birthday coming up next week, here's a list of things I would like in case you want to get me something." |
17
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/6/2012 2:38 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
09-05-2005
PITTSBURGH 969750437509409
Posts: 179
First: 1/13/2012
Last: 5/16/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts? : All the things you listed at the end are not etiquette issues, they're traditions (for some, not even universal traditions). Etiquette is about making your guests feel comfortable. While some of my guests might have been disappointed that we didn't have a giant wedding cake, we had plenty of good desserts and there was no problem, etiquette-wise. And yes, people come on here and say that they've seen registry info on a wedding invitation. That doesn't make it proper etiquette. I wouldn't go up to a friend and say, "I have a birthday coming up next week, here's a list of things I would like in case you want to get me something."
Posted by jessicabessica
Etiquette, like everything else, is a matter of pure opinion. My FI comes from a culture where it is completely unheard of to have a wedding ceremony in public, and not properly dressed, i.e., shoulders and bust completely covered. The culture I grew up in is quite different. Modesty and such ARE matters of etiquette, and like I said, it's completely all opinion. As you stated, what is comfortable for you and your guests is appropriate. It's definitely a fine line to tread, but we live and learn.
As long as things are done honestly, and the OP is open and communicative with people, I really don't think any blood feuds are going to be started over a request for cash/cash substitutes. If someone does get offended, it's a simple matter of going to them and apologizing and restating that your intentions were not to offend. After that, it's in the hands of the guest.
|
18
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/6/2012 6:30 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
11-01-2010
CENTRAL ILLINOIS 8608242495908998
Posts: 6322
First: 11/4/2010
Last: 5/25/2012
|
OP: Do not ask for gift cards, or any gifts, as a matter of fact. We received plenty of gift cards to the stores where we registered without specifically asking for them. Many guests will just take it upon themselves to buy those in lieu of physical gifts.
If you choose not to register for physical gifts though, you should forego all showers.
And etiquette and tradition are not the same thing. Etiquette is like good manners. It is poor etiquette to ask guests to pay for their own meal at your wedding or ask for gifts. Traditions are things like how to dress, where you to hold ceremonies, the vows you say, etc. None of those things impact the manners and politeness I show my guests. Asking them for gift cards, however, does. They are two totally different things.
|
19
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/6/2012 10:10 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
04-21-2009
BOSTON 4331759186211146
Posts: 968
First: 5/2/2011
Last: 3/29/2012
|
OP, one other great thing about registering? Some ppl see where you are registered, realize it is a store you like, and get you a gift card from that store on their own. People are smart and know what will be useful to set up a household.
|
20
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/7/2012 1:22 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
01-23-2012
NEW YORK 7296629519848702
Posts: 6
First: 1/23/2012
Last: 2/7/2012
|
Ettiquette is a little like tradition, though, in that it is relative. What is good manners and what isn't depends on the culture or tradition.
I've been to weddings where I got a gift off the really small registry, only to discover that I was supposed to give a check due to the bride and groom's culture; the registry was just there to "appease Americans".
I've been to other weddings where the registry info was included with the invitation, and everyone was fine with it b/c the couple really needed the items.
I'm sorry, maybe I'm gauche, but I think that to some degree, ettiquette is hogwash. I know manners and social norms have to exist, but it's silly to have to create a small registry of household items you don't need, just because that's the polite thing to do. True, on your birthday, you don't tell people what to get you. But weddings are completely abnormal, extraordinary events. It's already strange that you're making a list of stuff for your home.
Yet I'm probably going to end up doing that b/c now you've all given me a complex that signing up for a honeymoon registry might be rude!
|
21
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/8/2012 7:58 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA 210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009
Last: 5/24/2012
|
Etiquette and tradition are two entirely different things.
Etiquette is NOT about opinions. It's about good behavior and respecting the rights of others.
Tradition is a set of customs.
It's not polite to ask other people to give you their money - and that's not "an opinion." It's a fact accepted by society.
|
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."
22
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/8/2012 9:18 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
12-30-2010
NEW YORK 6726293256655633
Posts: 3
First: 2/7/2012
Last: 2/8/2012
|
I think what Aku is saying that it depends what "society", though. Etiquette is dependent on culture. Something that's good etiquette in the U.S. is rude in Japan, something that's rude in Japan is fine in Kenya, and so forth. For example, in some cultures, it's bad etiquette to eat all the food off your plate, while in others, if you don't eat the food you're given, you seem ungrateful.
Back to wedding gifts, I know that my Bengali friend said it's bad manners to give rounded number cash gifts (as in, don't give $100 dollars, give $101). In my culture, it's bad manners to even give money (it's like you're insulting the bride's family by implying that they couldn't afford the bride price), you give food instead. Can you imagine how rude you'd be considered if you gave food at the average American wedding??
My point is just that to me, I think it's okay if Eli Rangel says to her parents and bridal party, hey, please spread the word that we prefer gift cards. Just the same as how Emily Post says that you can have your parents and bridal party spread the word if a couple prefers cash. Ultimately, the people at your wedding want to get you what you want. There are ways to subtly imply it without sounding ill-mannered or demandin.
|
23
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/10/2012 7:02 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
Joined on
01-01-2012 7917610349933906
Posts: 46
First: 1/27/2012
Last: 5/11/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
. If you choose not to register for physical gifts though, you should forego all showers.
Posted by Summer2011Bride
What? Why? Are people incapable of choosing gifts without a registry?!
|
24
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/10/2012 9:59 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA 210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009
Last: 5/24/2012
|
It's not necessary to have a registry. Lots of brides have showers with no registry. They should be prepared to get a pile of picture frames and random gifts, though.
CASH showers are rude.
|
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."
25
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/11/2012 10:47 AM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
01-01-2012 7917610349933906
Posts: 46
First: 1/27/2012
Last: 5/11/2012
|
In Response to Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?:
It's not necessary to have a registry. Lots of brides have showers with no registry. They should be prepared to get a pile of picture frames and random gifts, though. CASH showers are rude.
Posted by RetreadBride
I didn't realise there was such a thing as a cash shower!
We don't do registries where I'm from, random gifts all the way :) That said, I'm not having a shower so it's not really an issue for me.
|
26
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/12/2012 2:58 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA 210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009
Last: 5/24/2012
|
Oh, yes.....there are some brides who think it's just fine to have a "money tree shower." (Sigh). I wonder what the heck they do at such "showers" (even ignoring the fact that it's rude). Open up each card and say, "Oh, Sue thanks for the twenty bucks. Oh, Jill, thanks for the hundred dollar bill," and so forth.
|
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."
27
|
|
Re: Is it too bossy (demanding) to ask for gift cards instead of actual gifts?
posted at 2/13/2012 11:50 PM EST
on theknot.com
|
|
|
Joined on
09-05-2005
PITTSBURGH 969750437509409
Posts: 179
First: 1/13/2012
Last: 5/16/2012
|
Retread Bride -- I've been to a shower where the bride didn't have a registry, so most everyone gave cash. The bride wasn't daft enough to shout out numbers like that. Hell, when I got bills inside my birthday cards as a *kid* I knew not to make a big deal like you suggest people will do. You open the card, read the sentiment and thank the person for their gift, then move on to the next one. You don't even need to pull the check/bill out of the card for everyone to see.
And I agree with Ebediako. It's really a matter of culture, whether you want to say it's etiquette or tradition.
|