• The Knot
  • The Nest
  • The Bump
  • The Blush
Wedding Boards
Cat:Wedding Boards
What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?
Wedding Party
What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?
Are uneven sides okay? (Yes!) Can you kick out a pregnant bridesmaid? (No!) Ask the toughest wedding party questions here.
Hello! I have been lurking for a few weeks now, and I feel like I have a good grasp on what does NOT count as a legitimate difficulty. This includes pregnant bridesmaids, Maid of Honor who won't throw
0
False
Wedding Party
What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?
Are uneven sides okay? (Yes!) Can you kick out a pregnant bridesmaid? (No!) Ask the toughest wedding party questions here.
Hello! I have been lurking for a few weeks now, and I feel like I have a good grasp on what does NOT count as a legitimate difficulty. This includes pregnant bridesmaids, Maid of Honor who won't throw
0
Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:37
Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:37Discussion:df21398e-dbe3-4d39-8e3e-efd196515b9a
Forums  >  Wedding Boards  >  Wedding Party  >  What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?
You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 

What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 2:34 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-03-2012
PORTLAND
4683611838769227
Posts: 78
First: 1/10/2012

Last: 3/6/2012


Hello!

I have been lurking for a few weeks now, and I feel like I have a good grasp on what does NOT count as a legitimate difficulty. This includes pregnant bridesmaids, Maid of Honor who won't throw three parties, and the proper number of attendants.

My question is: What would be a real problem with a party member that would potentially destroy the day we all look forward to?

Thank you!
Melody

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 2:40 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
06-18-2005
LOS ANGELES
301767437501027
Posts: 7664
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


Sleeping with your FI, them trashing you or your relationship.

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 2:58 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
06-17-2010
PHOENIX
7606123823916571
Posts: 9219
First: 6/24/2010

Last: 5/23/2012


Physical violence towards you or your loved ones, trying to sabbotage your marriage, doing anything non-WR that you find to be a deal breaker for a friendship, etc.

Basically, if it's bad enough that you no longer want to be friends with the person or ever speak to them again, then it's bad enough to not include them in your wedding.  But you can't say...oh, well I still want to be friends, but she's just uninvolved in my wedding.

Remember, your BMs were your FRIENDS before you asked them to be a part of your wedding, and that friendship should always trump any issues you have in regards to your wedding.
Anniversary
Photobucket

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 3:14 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-06-2010
UPSTATE NEW YORK
7926272197539879
Posts: 1070
First: 2/20/2011

Last: 5/10/2012


The bestman confesses his love to the groom and his "speech" is a love song he wrote to him. Didn't ruin my wedding though, just made for some akward conversations after.
Photobucket

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 3:22 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-27-2012
MILWAUKEE
4410632666220652
Posts: 214
First: 1/27/2012

Last: 3/23/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
The bestman confesses his love to the groom and his "speech" is a love song he wrote to him. Didn't ruin my wedding though, just made for some akward conversations after.
Posted by raes19


Wait... what?!

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 3:27 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
02-21-2010
MINNEAPOLIS-ST. PAUL
8007023759143191
Posts: 7928
First: 4/6/2010

Last: 5/10/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
Physical violence towards you or your loved ones, trying to sabbotage your marriage, doing anything non-WR that you find to be a deal breaker for a friendship, etc. Basically, if it's bad enough that you no longer want to be friends with the person or ever speak to them again, then it's bad enough to not include them in your wedding.  But you can't say...oh, well I still want to be friends, but she's just uninvolved in my wedding . Remember, your BMs were your FRIENDS before you asked them to be a part of your wedding, and that friendship should always trump any issues you have in regards to your wedding.
Posted by jemmini6



100% agree. If a friend does something to you that is so horrible that you can't stand to be in a relationship any longer, then that is a huge problem. What that "something" would be is left to each individual. It could be stealing or other criminal activity, hitting on your man, being unsupportive of your relationship, whatever.

I think that the only other problem would be not getting her dress. That removes the girl from the WP. I do think that friends should be able to talk through those things, but the other items, like not throwing parties, not coming to bridal shows, etc. should not be that big of a deal.
Photobucket

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 3:30 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-03-2012
PORTLAND
4683611838769227
Posts: 78
First: 1/10/2012

Last: 3/6/2012


The bestman confesses his love to the groom and his "speech" is a love song he wrote to him. Didn't ruin my wedding though, just made for some akward conversations after.
Posted by raes19


Wow...I can picture it, but only as if it were in a movie.

I am impressed with your grace under fire!

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 3:43 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-06-2010
UPSTATE NEW YORK
7926272197539879
Posts: 1070
First: 2/20/2011

Last: 5/10/2012


I had told H for a long time that I thought his bestman had feelings for him. He thought I was nuts, but turns out I was right and there was no way he could ignore it after that.
Photobucket

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 4:42 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-27-2012
MILWAUKEE
4410632666220652
Posts: 214
First: 1/27/2012

Last: 3/23/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
I had told H for a long time that I thought his bestman had feelings for him. He thought I was nuts, but turns out I was right and there was no way he could ignore it after that.
Posted by raes19


do you remember any of the lyrics??
And, if you don't mind sharing, what happened to their friendship?

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 6:13 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
08-11-2011
BALTIMORE
6360486966543243
Posts: 568
First: 9/1/2011

Last: 5/23/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
I had told H for a long time that I thought his bestman had feelings for him. He thought I was nuts, but turns out I was right and there was no way he could ignore it after that.
Posted by raes19


Wow, just wow.

And back to OP, what exactly is entailed with "ruining how we all will look"?  Is she threatening to douse you all with battery acid, or did she get a mohawk?  I need more details.

edit:  she could potentially destroy the day you're looking forward to, not the way you look.  Sorry, it's been a long week.  What do you think she might do?
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 6:29 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
10-24-2009
ATLANTA
4122920063164338
Posts: 4399
First: 12/3/2010

Last: 4/30/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member? : 100% agree. If a friend does something to you that is so horrible that you can't stand to be in a relationship any longer, then that is a huge problem. What that "something" would be is left to each individual. It could be stealing or other criminal activity, hitting on your man, being unsupportive of your relationship, whatever. I think that the only other problem would be not getting her dress. That removes the girl from the WP. I do think that friends should be able to talk through those things, but the other items, like not throwing parties, not coming to bridal shows, etc. should not be that big of a deal.
Posted by graysquirrel


Totally agree, but what about a BM who waits to the last minute and technically does order the dress, but it is due to come in the week of the wedding? What if it doesn't fit or doesn't even come in on time?

This was a debate on my month board earlier this week. Several people attacked the OP for being a brat, and I do think it's the nice thing to do to let her go get another dress in a neutral color just in case, but I kind of get why she is upset. 

It seemed (from OP) that the BM simply got lazy and put off ordering the dress. She had no hardship or budget issues. My own MOH was somewhat like this and I wound up ordering the dress for her so it would get done (she reimbursed me 4 days later and no she was not waiting on a paycheck, so clearly money wasn't the issue there either). 

I told those jumping all over her that getting the dress is the one major obligation besides showing up, so I get why OP felt like BM put her obligation/OPs wedding on the backburner. Obviously if she had been biitching about the BMs not ordering 11 months out or something, different story. 
April Siggy Challenge-Wedding Escape: Reading HG/dreaming about Peeta.... Image and video hosting by TinyPic Wedding Countdown Ticker Bio-Updated 4/22**

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 7:34 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-03-2012
PORTLAND
4683611838769227
Posts: 78
First: 1/10/2012

Last: 3/6/2012


Wow, just wow. And back to OP, what exactly is entailed with "ruining how we all will look"?  Is she threatening to douse you all with battery acid, or did she get a mohawk?  I need more details. edit:  she could potentially destroy the day you're looking forward to, not the way you look.  Sorry, it's been a long week.  What do you think she might do?
Posted by Meghannsix


I am not personally anticipating any difficulties with the wedding I am helping to plan. I was simply curious if people have come accross many legitimate complaints that do not fall under the "OMG My MOH wont learn the dance Can I FIRE HER??" umbrella.

I certainly see enough of those posts...

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/10/2012 10:30 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
11-05-2010
MILWAUKEE
8950245492479676
Posts: 4003
First: 12/15/2010

Last: 5/11/2012


I agree with PPs, anything that would end the friendship otherwise.  

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/11/2012 12:15 AM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
01-03-2012
HOUSTON
4791612101457601
Posts: 536
First: 1/19/2012

Last: 5/17/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
The bestman confesses his love to the groom and his "speech" is a love song he wrote to him. Didn't ruin my wedding though, just made for some akward conversations after.
Posted by raes19


Woah. You win.

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/11/2012 10:11 AM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-19-2005
NORTH CAROLINA
210124875002240
Posts: 12573
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 5/24/2012


I think I dislocated my jaw reading the Best Man story.  I congratulate the bride for her composure.

Sleeping with the fiance....well, that's a FIANCE problem, too, and there shouldn't be a wedding at all after that.

1.  Advances towards the fiance.
2. Unwanted advances towards the bride.
3. Stealing from the bride, groom, or their family.
4. Violence.
"I'm not crazy. I've just been in a very bad mood for 40 years."

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/11/2012 3:05 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
08-15-2011
VIRGINIA
9804490489234338
Posts: 660
First: 11/1/2011

Last: 5/19/2012


1.  Advances towards the fiance.
2. Unwanted advances towards the bride.
3. Stealing from the bride, groom, or their family.
4. Violence.

This!!!

Almost anything else is just BS he said she crap that won't matter the day after it happened let along the day of your wedding!
Wedding Countdown Ticker "A wedding is a day, a marriage is a lifetime"

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/12/2012 10:32 AM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
12-06-2010
UPSTATE NEW YORK
7926272197539879
Posts: 1070
First: 2/20/2011

Last: 5/10/2012


In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?:
In Response to Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member? : do you remember any of the lyrics?? And, if you don't mind sharing, what happened to their friendship?
Posted by soontobemrsep


I don't remember the lyrics, sorry. It was actually a pretty song though.

As for their friendship, they still talk occasionally, but it definately changed things. Mostly because H doesn't want to lead him on and make him think there is a potential for their relationship to be more.
Photobucket

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/12/2012 6:48 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
05-23-2011
4891417479216113
Posts: 511
First: 6/13/2011

Last: 5/17/2012


lol he's married.. how could he lead him on? It makes sense to distance though, that would be kind of awkward, probably:S  I have never actually heard of someone declaring their love for the bride/groom the day of the wedding... but i guess it happens! kinda weird that he chose to do it after the groom was married though :S
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

posted at 2/16/2012 3:38 PM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
09-27-2010
MINNEAPOLIS-ST. PAUL
7777212123999640
Posts: 83
First: 9/15/2011

Last: 5/8/2012


The bestman confesses his love to the groom and his "speech" is a love song he wrote to him. Didn't ruin my wedding though, just made for some akward conversations after.
Posted by raes19


   THIS,  I swear this is going to happen at my wedding!  If you hadn't told your story I would swear I was crazy but Andrew's best man could SO end up doing this.  I don't know how many drinking/COD nights I've had to give him the eye for crossing the "are you sure you like girls" line. (No homophobia intended my very openly gay friend David has called him out numerous times)

  I showed Andrew your post also and he laughed.. got really quiet and then said "Well... maybe Drew shouldn't get a speech now that I think about it"
Follow Me on Pinterest

Forums > Wedding Boards > Wedding Party > What constitutes a real problem with a Party Member?

My Viewing Preferences

Show user signatures

new! vendor reviews


Review your vendors
(the great and not-so-great) here!



WATCH! Great gifts for your bridal party

personalized gifts
they will love

Shop Now
The Knot Wedding Shop