I've lurked here for... probably a year... I bet you feel like fish in a bowl

At any rate, we ended up postponing our wedding due to pregnancy, but would like to get married soon. I'm having a lot of trouble picking a destination. We know we'd like to get married on a beach. We'll either "elope" or have under 10 people with us. I figured most of you had probably looked at tons of places before deciding on your destinations. Where do you get the most bang for your buck? We don't really have a budget, per se, but if we end up paying for 10-12 people to travel/eat/stay somewhere, obviously, I would like to get a good deal and even if it's just us, I'd rather spend money on things to do rather than astronomical airfare. We would be going in November/December. I know we want to get married on a beach. It just seems like the more I look, the more gorgeous destinations I find... then I get more overwhelmed and less decisive. Just kind of looking for suggestions. Or maybe even. .. if you had just eloped, where would you have gone? I realize resorts are probably more conducive to larger DWs, so didn't know if that swayed you. Okay, I'm blathering. Sorry

Thanks in advance!