You might want to check out Alioto's in Tosa (north of Mayfair Mall).
My reception is at The Preserve at Deer Creek Golf course in New Berlin. The rental for me is $325. I believe it has since went up like $325 for 4 hrs & $100 each hour thereafter. They just require you use their bar which means paying for barrels of beer. I am using Bunzel's catering which has rave reviews in the community and I've had before and it's coming out to about $10 person for Italian fare. Other options - Venue: Milwaukee Sailing Club, Crystal Ridge ski lodge, Trimborn Farms in Greendale. PM if you want details or contacts for either of my vendors.Posted by rungirl12