Pumpkin pie lovers only

CMGragain

Having a "discussion" with DH.  He says pumpkin pie should be refrigerated until it is cold before eating because it has eggs and milk in it.  I say it is best served warm.  What do you think?

plainjane0415

Warm!

doeydo

Warm of course!

MairePoppy

I've never had warm pumpkin pie, but it's nice just thinking about it. We've always had it chilled and topped with whipped cream.

ShesSoCold

Cold!

hellohkb

I like it chilled.

lovegood90

Chilled!

KytchynWitche

Okay, so, being South African and therefore a non-Thanksgiving-er, I've never actually HAD pumpkin pie. Every year I say I'm going to make it, and I never do. BUT, I have to say that I don't think I see a wrong answer here.

beethery

Cold!!!!

holyguacamole79

Chilled

theartistformerlyknownas

I eat it room temperature. :-p

amelisha

Warm, definitely warm. Cold pumpkin pie tastes like sadness.

mschristie123

Cold!!

blabla89

Served for the first time, after Thanksgiving dinner, of course it should be warm. But then it should be kept refrigerated, and leftover pumpkin pie is still pretty darn tasty when it's chilled. That is my professional opinion.

levioosa

Um, I don't care, because it's pumpkin pie.

Bring it on.  

pinkcow13

Both! It's pumpkin pie after all!

manillabar

I like it warm, with ice cream!

Aray82

But it's cooked, right? I've only had it cold but warm sounds good too!

Blergbot

You should really just make two...everyone wins.

JennyColada

I like it chilled, but you certainly CAN serve it warm (just like cookies...and no one says that that can't be served warm just because it has eggs in it!). I mean, obviously you probably don't want to leave it sitting out in the DANGER ZONE, but aside from that it's safe served warm or chilled.

AddieCake

I like it both ways.

RebeccaFlower

Warm sounds icky to me. Cold is how I've always had it. 

STARMOON44

Warm

arrippa

Chilled for pumpkin pie.

SBmini

blabla89 said:

Served for the first time, after Thanksgiving dinner, of course it should be warm. But then it should be kept refrigerated, and leftover pumpkin pie is still pretty darn tasty when it's chilled. That is my professional opinion.

Cannot answer this any better. Spot on. 

AzAnnie

Cold with lots of whipped cream!!

RebeccaB88

Room temp.

jdluvr06

Cold

LabLove86

I like it both ways

theartistformerlyknownas

You guys I had TWO bad slices of pumpkin pie yesterday. TWO. The one at the club had too many cloves and the one H's aunt made was too eggy. I'll take properly made pie at any temperature right now. My holiday is not complete without it!

sarawifenow

I love taking a slice of pumpkin pie out of the fridge for breakfast the day after a holiday. That's actually what I am eating right now!