Let me just preface this by saying, we will only be doing favors if our budget allows.
So, FI and I are getting married in TX. I am from OH. The wedding will be small-ish (around 50 people excluding vendors). 80% of the guests are from TX.
There is a small, mom and pop chocolate and ice cream shop in my hometown (consistently voted one of the best in the nation....check out Dietsch's Brothers if you're ever in Findlay, OH, you won't regret it). I was thinking of getting boxes of 4 buckeyes (aka chocolate dipped peanut butter balls) and having the store wrap them in white gift paper. Then I would stamp "Thank You" and a heart on each one and place them on the tables. I'd really like to incorporate something from back home since I'm a bit disappointed we are not getting married there.
FYI: there are no peanut allergies to watch out for