Favors

thinking of doing something a bit outside of the box...what do you think?

Considering all the matches, wine keys, and candy in  the world, my FI and I are thinking about doing something a bit different with our favors.
We're both mountain people. We met in the mountains, fell in love in the mountains, grew together, he even proposed in the mountains (and I mean on the summit of several peaks in the rockies). We are out climbing nearly every weekend.
The idea was to write a short note (I am a poet/writer and know how to do calligraphy) stating how we have carried each other to this moment, how we found our spirit in the mountains, and how we carried the memory, love, and spirit of each of our guests back down the mountain with us - and then giving them a stone from the summit of one peaks my FI and I have climbed together.
The stones woudl correspond with the name of the tables (all named after peaks and mountain ranges). And we aren't talking about dirty little stones either - think polished pieces of granite (my FI used to offer these to me as a gift whenever we were separated for a weekend - said he had carried me with him all the way.) Good idea?

Re: thinking of doing something a bit outside of the box...what do you think?

  • edited December 2011
    It sounds amazing to me, but I can already hear the voices of the nay-sayers. I guess it all depends on your guests. I know this would be an amazing idea for my family... and a disaster waiting to happen with my ILs. They're very concerned about "what will people think" etc, so I know this wouldn't work for them (and probably not for their friends and family, either).
    We've translated our love for nature in our favors by giving our guests potted plants. They were ultra cheap favors that reflect what we like while still looking super fabulous for my mother in law after a bit of dressing them up. 

    Anyway, if you're not a chicken like me, go for it and don't worry about what others say/think. You're giving away something meaningful to you both, and your guests should appreciate it!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • melissamc2melissamc2 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    If you feel it's what YOU want, then I wouldn't try to talk you out of it at all.  You know your guests and families much better than anyone else. 

    Since you asked what WE think, however...I'm going to be honest.  Even if it were my best friend, I'd pick it up, read it, and roll my eyes wondering why on Earth she could possibly think I, the person who would be content if the world were astroturfed and each city were in a climate controlled bubble, would ever want a rock with a sappy note attached to it.  I'd toss a rock (and a potted plant, for the record - it's not rock specific!).

    I absolutely understand that it is meaningful to you and your fiance and I'm not mocking that or trying to diminish the feelings behind it.  We ALL have those special little things that connect us with our fiance.  I just don't really think they always need to be shared with everyone else...especially by calling it a gift to the guests.  It's a little awkward.

    With that said, I go back to the fact that you know your wedding guests and I do not.  Maybe they are all into rocks and love stories.

    Whatever you decide, good luck and congratulations!
    10-10-10
  • edited December 2011
    Maybe incorporate your love of rock climbing, nature, and mountains in another way at your wedding, because I think that as a favor it's dumb.  I understand it's meaningful to YOU, but remember that a favor isn't a gift to you, it's a gift/thanks to your guests.

    What if you use those rocks to hold your menu cards in place and at the bottom of the menu card explain why rocks like that mean something to you and FI?  That way guests can keep them if they like the way they look or throw them out, but you won't be pretending like that's an acceptable thank you to your guests.

    Other ways to incorporate rocks: Your table numbers could be pictures of you and FI on different peaks/mountains/cliffs with the number superimposed on top.  Also, you could write guest names and table #s on little rocks to be escort cards (in fact, I really like that idea because then the guest's name will be on the rock so it may be more meaningful to them which means they'd be more likely to keep it).  You could put the name on the top and the table number on the bottom.
    image 182 Invited
    image 0 Are ready to party!
    image 0 Will be missing the fun
    image 0 Can't find the mailbox...

    RSVP Deadline: June 15, 2011
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • MidgetthMidgetth member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    I'm sorry but I agree with Melissa & Peaches. It has meaning toYOU & your FI but that's it not to anyone else. Iknow I wouldn'twant a love story about someone and a rock. Think about it this way: What are the guests going to do with the rock & poem after the wedding? Read at the top of the favors Page first post about how gifts that are personalized to the bride & groom are the ones that are going to get left behind or thrown out. Sadly it's true. Why would you want something with someone else's name or face or other personal touch?  I'm sorry sweetie it does sound like a cute idea but I don't recommend it. I honestly think it will be a waste of your time.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • bbyckesbbyckes member
    First Comment Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    I think it sounds very sweet.  Chances are peeps are going to leave them, but I really, really like the sentiment.
  • trix1223trix1223 member
    5 Love Its Combo Breaker First Comment
    edited December 2011
    It's meaningful to you and your FI, but honestly, as a guest, I'd laugh at getting a rock as a favor,  and attaching your love story to it would just make it worse.

    How about you give rock candy~without the attached love story?  It would be a little inside joke to you and your FI.  You'd know what it means, but it wouldn't be so "in your face".

    I'm going to be honest:  I'd leave a rock behind.
    "Trix, it's what they/our parents wanted. Why so judgemental? And why is your wedding date over a year and a half ago? And why do you not have a groom's name? And why have you posted over 12,000 posts? And why do you always say mean things to brides?" palegirl146
  • edited December 2011
    Thanks ladies...to be honest, myself, I'd leave a box of matches, a lighter, a wine key? behind. Many favors are, in all honesty, little trinkets, and I've been to many weddings where many of the more expensive "favors" are left scattered across the floor. Why not do something meaningful? Give your guests a piece of the mountains they'll see in the distance? The reception site faces Longs Peak in Colorado- and then make a donation on behalf of everyone to the Conservation Society? Thank you all for your opinions, but I suppose that's what makes all people different. I believe that the sentiment and meaning behind a gift is much more important than the gift itself. Just me though...
  • trix1223trix1223 member
    5 Love Its Combo Breaker First Comment
    edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/special-topic-wedding-boards_favors_thinking-of-doing-something-bit-outside-of-boxwhat-think?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Special%20Topic%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:27Discussion:e2dae0ad-5659-4b7c-9990-67475c78defbPost:6723480e-03dd-433a-aa2a-d32bb536e5c2">Re: thinking of doing something a bit outside of the box...what do you think?</a>:
    [QUOTE]Thanks ladies...to be honest, myself, I'd leave a box of matches, a lighter, a wine key? behind. Many favors are, in all honesty, little trinkets, and I've been to many weddings where many of the more expensive "favors" are left scattered across the floor. Why not do something meaningful? Give your guests a piece of the mountains they'll see in the distance? The reception site faces Longs Peak in Colorado- <strong>and then make a donation on behalf of everyone to the Conservation Society? </strong>Thank you all for your opinions, but I suppose that's what makes all people different. I believe that the sentiment and meaning behind a gift is much more important than the gift itself. Just me though...
    Posted by kristi-ji[/QUOTE]

    The donation to the conservation society is a lovely thought, because it's important to you.  Just don't call it a favor to your guests. Because it's not.  It's a favor to the conservation society (and to yourself if it's a 501c-3 organization).

    I'm not saying don't make the donation.  I think you should make the donation.  But a favor for your guests is something that they take with them.  A donation to your charity, however worthy, is not a favor.

    GL
    "Trix, it's what they/our parents wanted. Why so judgemental? And why is your wedding date over a year and a half ago? And why do you not have a groom's name? And why have you posted over 12,000 posts? And why do you always say mean things to brides?" palegirl146
  • edited December 2011
    Most people who care about you and your relationship will appreciate both the favor of the stones and the story behind them. They'll take them with them and keep them safe. My mom still has the bookmark, favor, and wedding program from my Aunt's wedding. Some might get left behind, but that's ok.
  • wicked_faerywicked_faery member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    my suggestion would be to paint or crave a design onto the stones if possible...or put them in sachets that have something on them.

    otherwise that's such an amazing & unique idea ^_^. i'm sure ur guests will understand the significance of it all!
    ~~~~June 15th 2011~~~~ Photobucket Wedding Countdown Ticker Image and video hosting by TinyPic My Planning Bio - Updated Nov 2nd
  • jamjar11jamjar11 member
    First Anniversary First Comment
    edited December 2011
    That's what I was thinking, wicked, maybe you could put the rock in an organza bag or paint something on it? Something to make it special, otherwise its just a rock. And to be honest, no matter what you do I would probably be like, "dude, did you just give me a rock? wtf?" But like PPs said, the sentiment is amazing. People who really care about you will appreciate it, but no matter how you break it down, its a rock.
    April 2011 November Siggy: Venue Photobucket Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • lisaD26lisaD26 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    What about some trail mix in a cute little bag? I'm sure you take trail mix with you on a hike? I'd keep with my rock theme tho, just not as the favors.
  • lisaD26lisaD26 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011

    "Happy trails to you from the Bride and Groom"


    haha.

    :)

  • tana1983tana1983 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    I guess you just can't please everyone.  I have gone to many weddings.  Until last year, I would just pile the favors into a box in my closet.  I just don't get them.  Then, I finally decided to donate them.  The last wedding I went to they had candy.  I tasted a few pieces when I was driving home and they gave me a tooth ache!!!  I originally wanted to make a donation, but I got the same shpeal about how some people would be insulted without a gift... Personally, if I had gotten the gift you mentioned, I would of thought it lovely, and would have actually kept it as piece of art.  I think you will never satisfy all guests.  

    Hopefully, this will be the only time you get a chance to show thanks and thoughtfulness in this sort of way.  You know your guests.  My cousin mentioned that if more people gave gifts like contributions or your lovely poem and polished rock, then more guests will eventually get used to it and it will become common place.

    Finally, how is a keychain, candy or cookies more thoughtful than your idea?  Really? If I want candy or cookies, I'll go to the corner store. Come on, candy? really?  But, at the end of the day, it's the intention behind it. And that's why anything will work for those that care about the married couple(Do you care about those that don't--they shouldn't be at the wedding!)-- candy or a polished rock with a meaningful poem.  Do what your heart desires and wants to give.   You won't go wrong.  Otherwise, you'll regret it!
  • tana1983tana1983 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    I guess you just can't please everyone.  I have gone to many weddings.  Until last year, I would just pile the favors into a box in my closet.  I just don't get them.  Then, I finally decided to donate them.  The last wedding I went to they had candy.  I tasted a few pieces when I was driving home and they gave me a tooth ache!!!  I originally wanted to make a donation, but I got the same shpeal about how some people would be insulted without a gift... Personally, if I had gotten the gift you mentioned, I would of thought it lovely, and would have actually kept it as piece of art.  I think you will never satisfy all guests.  

    Hopefully, this will be the only time you get a chance to show thanks and thoughtfulness in this sort of way.  You know your guests.  My cousin mentioned that if more people gave gifts like contributions or your lovely poem and polished rock, then more guests will eventually get used to it and it will become common place.

    Finally, how is a keychain, candy or cookies more thoughtful than your idea?  Really? If I want candy or cookies, I'll go to the corner store. Come on, candy? really?  But, at the end of the day, it's the intention behind it. And that's why anything will work for those that care about the married couple(Do you care about those that don't--they shouldn't be at the wedding!)-- candy or a polished rock with a meaningful poem.  Do what your heart desires and wants to give.   You won't go wrong.  Otherwise, you'll regret it!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards