Thanks to everyone who helped with my additional venue recommendations! We've been to a couple of places since, and I did A LOT more research on locations in our area. We seem to have narrowed our choices down to three: Greentree, Beckwith Pointe and Kittle House.
What we both really like is the old mansion kinda feel. Something a little less typical and a bit more personal than the big wedding halls. The Kittle House really fits that description. The other two a bit less so, but they are much less expensive and offer MUCH more food.
Does anyone have anything good, bad or otherwise to say about any one of these places? I'd appreciate it. Thanks!