Photog #1 we loved his work and clicked with him. He had traditional but also edgy. His photos really captures you. He is expensive, like over 25% more, if we want some of the items in other packages (album, parent books). Neither of us liked his album (the product, not the design). He does include 250 proof prints and the CD. If we go with no prints/album, the price is about the same as #2.
Photog #2 we were happy with but not really "wow-ed" by them. They are less edgy and seem slightly less skilled. Their package costs less than photog #1 and includes album, parent books, proof book, guest book, enlargement, slide show, and more hours.
So...would you go with #1 or #2?