Cakes by Gina provided the cake for our wedding on 10/10/10 and it was worth every penny we spent. We picked them after tasting their cake at my sister-in-law's wedding and thinking how delicious it was and how amazing that they could make frosting that looks like fondant but isn't.
After a few initial issues getting things set up, our tasting went very smoothly and the only hard part was picking which flavors! The store has tons of sample cakes out to help you pick shape and design and can pretty much do anything you want. We picked lemon with lemon curd and carrot cake - both so delicious and not overly sweet. The consultant drew us a picture of the design and went over the total cake needed for our headcount.
The only negative was that the guy who delivered the cake (literally 30 minutes before the ceremony - eek!) seemed a bit confused and was calling on my bridesmaids to review and "approve" the cake instead of the venue coordinator. That caused some unnecessary confusion but it all worked out in the end. Our guests raved about the cake! It looked stunning, as expected, and was just as we had requested. We are loving eating the (very few) leftovers and have frozen our cake top to eat in a month or two (no way are we wasting this awesome cake by waiting a year!)