I have yet another Etsy seller to promote to you all! I just received my 100% custom-made garter from Lollie Couture today (http://www.etsy.com/shop/lolliecouture
). I sent her a picture of a garter I found online and loved and she was able to replicate it with a few minor tweaks. Her customer service was phenomenal throughout both the ordering and shipping processes and the quality of her work is fantastic. Definitely check out her shop or contact her if you have something in mind and want an awesome garter for a great price (mine was $21 and that included shipping).
My garter has the colors of the Ecuadorian flag (red, blue, and yellow) with a soccer ball charm... all for FI! :-)
The Ecuadorian flag:
The original inspiration picture I sent:
The garter I received from the Etsy seller (obviously the picture looks crappy, but if it was set up and staged like the picture above I promise you'd be more impressed, haha):