The good news:
My MOH bought her dress and it's adorable (pic below)! Gilt was having a sale on TwoBirds infinity dresses, so she nabbed it, and I'm really happy it looks so great on her. I think it's a super gorgeous dress, and she looks especially good in it.
I know some folks have had questions about infinity dresses, and so far she loves hers. She feels it's completely bra friendly, but I could see how many of the suggested styles would not be. She's also obviously a specific body type between super skinny (so she doesn't feel weird without a pushup bra) and very curvy (so she can easily keep her boobs in check).
The not great news:
Even though I'm having my bridesmaids do mismatched dresses (matchy matchy feels like a Production of Our Wedding to me, yikes), it seems drama is going to happen no matter what.
First of all, I've told them a million times that there is no need to buy a dress this early; MOH simply did because she loved that dress, and it went on sale on Gilt. If you see a dress you like between now and the wedding that fits the color scheme, nab it like she did.
Second of all, the instructions they've been given are: neutral-toned, not satin and the same level of fancy. (My MOH is the exception to this, as she wanted to stand out and have a long dress, but everyone else said they preferred short.) So, I'm not even dictating a specific color. I had told them that I saw this going more of a light blue/grey/light purple thing or a nude/rose/blush/taupe thing.
If anyone is curious, I made a pinterest board of many, many dresses I like because A) I'm bored a lotttt these days, and
it's a cheat sheet:
http://pinterest.com/emeejeeayen/maids-in-neutrals/ (they don't have to pick one of these, just thought it would make things clearer.)
All the bridesmaids said explicitly they did not care which color side we went with. MOH purchased the above dress, and now one of the other girls is saying that "no color in that scheme works with [her] skin tone." Seriously? There is nothing in the rose, blush, taupe, nude, beige or pink color families that work with your skin tone?
But whatever, we have months, so who cares, right? Future Me will deal with this.
Just excited my MOH is happy and gorgeous (and wish my other friend weren't doing her best to stress me out about this so early in the game). Alas, can't win 'em all.
Edited to resize picture! Whoops!
whatshouldwecallweddings.tumblr.com