Thank you for the feedback! I definitely want to register at Macy's but am not sure where else. I was thinking Kohl's and Amazon. My mother said she was not sure people would know what to do for an Amazon registry.
We registered at Macy's, Target and Menards.
We liked Macy's because when you register there they give you a coupon code for a free photo book from Shutterfly. We also did Target because they give you 15% off of anything that wasn't purchased from your registry after the wedding which is awesome!! We registered in person and then I've been getting online and adding things to it.
Menards seems like a weird place to register but they actually have a lot of household things that I know my family will like to get us. We didn't have to make an appointment they just had little scanners and you take them and turn them in when you're done! It seemed fairly simple to us but I'm not sure about other places.
We did two. One at Macy's and then one on Blueprintregistry.com. On Blueprint you can add from their collection of things plus off of any site you want. It also lets you put on there group gifts, experiences, honeymoon funds, and cash funds. Its really pretty awesome!