Wedding Woes

You need to decide if Cory is worth it.

Dear Prudence,

I moved in with my partner “Cory” and their other partner “Amy” in March. Amy has a lot of anxiety that’s been made worse by the pandemic (understandable). That anxiety manifests as a very volatile mood that from one hour to the next can go from upbeat and chipper to a giant dark cloud that sucks the energy from the whole house. She storms around, snaps at Cory when they try to talk to her, and complains bitterly and sarcastically to us about how stressful and unfair her life is. It’s really hard to watch her treat Cory so poorly, and it’s hard to keep my own even keel when the dynamic in the house is so unstable. The world is hard for all of us right now, yet in the years I’ve been with Cory I can’t recall Amy ever even asking me how my day was. I’m finding it hard to continue being sympathetic with someone who shows little to no interest in how the rest of us are doing. Cory agrees that the situation is not healthy for anyone involved.

When we’ve talked as a group about Amy’s stress and anxiety, she usually claims things will be better after she clears some upcoming hurdle in the career transition she is making. However, each time she clears one of these hurdles, something new causes her anxiety, and the situation continues. Cory and I pay for all of the household expenses, do most of the domestic labor, and support her in making whatever decisions will make her life and career what she wants them to be. But I do not think she has a realistic idea of what will make her happy, nor the ability to cope with unhappiness without taking it out on everyone around her. She is in therapy, but this pattern has not changed. Is there anything I or we can do to make the dynamic at home more stable?

Re: You need to decide if Cory is worth it.

  • IMO, Amy’s got to go.  I see NO value of her living there. If Cory doesn’t agree, LW, then YOU go.

  • Is this a thruple?

    Has Amy seen outside/medical help regarding things?

    Side note, I get vibes Amy might be a lawyer or something. They seem to have high stress while transitioning positions.
  • If Corey is unable to unwilling to try and change the situation with Amy you have to decide how much you’re willing to tolerate. You can’t force Amy to change and you can’t force Corey to leave or change the dynamic either. For your own health I’d say look at other housing options. 
  • You cannot change Amy's behavior or how Cory chooses to handle it. However, if you can afford and find a better living situation, I think you need to seriously consider it. I'm not familiar enough with poly relationships to say whether this means you need to end your relationship with Cory entirely, but I don't think it's healthy for you to live under the same roof as Amy. Obviously she needs more help than she is getting, but that doesn't mean you have to live with her behavior at the cost of your own mental health.
    image
  • Is this a thruple?

    Has Amy seen outside/medical help regarding things?

    Side note, I get vibes Amy might be a lawyer or something. They seem to have high stress while transitioning positions.
    No. LW has a relationship with Cory, not with Amy. 

    I agree with the others that it's time for LW to look for another living situation. Maybe there's an opportunity to split their home into separate spaces or LW just needs to live nearby. It's up to LW and Cory to figure out how their relationship will navigate that. I think LW wants to get Cory to end it with Amy, but that's probably not going to turn out well. 
  • Amy sounds like abject misery and will always be abject misery.  Either because she can't help herself or because she is sub-consciously happiest that way.  It sounds counter-intuitive, but some people are like that.

    I had a coworker at a different job like this.  The private joke I would tell my husband is, "She is the kind of person who could win $10M in the lottery and then be upset and complain about the amount of taxes she needs to pay."

    At any rate, the LW needs to decide if this is a dealbreaker.  It would be for me, all the day long.  If so, they'll need to take it from there and discuss options with Cory and possibly Amy.  Maybe Cory is ready to break it off with Amy also.  Maybe he isn't.  Maybe the LW needs to move back out and put the relationship back to the previous status quo, since that seemed to work before.  Or maybe that feels like going "backwards" and would result in Cory and the LW breaking up.

    However, it doesn't sound like the LW is there.  Yet.  In that case, the next best option would be to (hopefully) join forces with Cory in a roomie sit-down about responsibilities and expectations.  Perhaps a chart or a daily/weekly list about who is responsible for what.  Maybe doing chores with her will help motivate her and get her in better habits, like, "Let's do the dishes.  Amy, do you want to wash or dry?"  Coddling Amy is not helpful, for her own growth.  I wonder if it is possible to have a few joint therapy sessions with Amy's therapist, for the best guidance in handling her negative spirals and getting her to adult up.  While I've heard mental illness, especially depression, can knock someone down sometimes for a few days, it's still outrageous to me that Amy neither pays any bills nor even helps around the house.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards