Which Dress? PIP

alygoo615 · August 2009

Sorry for the DD's- the links weren't working!Ok... dilemna... two dresses I'm deciding between. The PICTURE of dress 2 is nicer than dress 1, so try to keep that in mind the best you can... Also, the second dress sample size fit a lot nicer... first dress was too bigFirst are the links to the model pics (the pics don't give them justice...)Next are the pics of me... First two pics are dress 1, third pic is Dress 2.. TIA!Dress One:. [url]http://tinyurl.com/obh9hl[/url] .Dress Two:. [url]http://tinyurl.com/qo8yua[/url] .Pics of me.... [img]http://lh4.ggpht.com/_kR-DyzRPmxA/SoskcnHShGI/AAAAAAAAAXE/nIsuqtwsJwk/s400/IMG_2022.JPG[/img] .. [img]http://lh5.ggpht.com/_kR-DyzRPmxA/SoskdDkpY8I/AAAAAAAAAXI/2v43YMl4MOc/s400/IMG_2035.JPG[/img] .. [img]http://lh4.ggpht.com/_kR-DyzRPmxA/SoskdZ7rXwI/AAAAAAAAAXM/srVa0SJRf3w/s400/downsized_0620091458a_0001.jpg[/img] .

steffenfam · August 2009

I prefer dress #1, the mori lee. I thought dress #2 is too clumpy.

cvl105 · August 2009

neither are my taste, but if I had to pick, I guess I'd say #2. I really hate the look of the one big pickup like in #1, where it looks like you're showing the under layer of the dress.

alygoo615 · August 2009

CVL- To be honest- when I was looking at pictures, neither of the dresses were my style. Once I started trying on, the ones with pickups seemed to flatter my body the best. I decided it's how I look in the dress, not how the dress looks. I want to go on one more shopping trip to see if I can find another style the I like ON me.

bridesrighthand · August 2009

I like 1 better...I don't like the marshmallow-y look of 2. I also think 1 looks better on YOU.

angeliza · August 2009

Wow at first I was sure they were both the same dress. Looking again, I definitely like #1 better. I personally love the pickups on the skirt and think it looks very elegant. The pickups on #2 look really messy to me.

a2crane · August 2009

I am one that REALLY loves the style of pick-ups AND I think that it is a very flattering style on you

Both of the dreses look great on you and are gorgeous. I prefer the second one because it gives you the perfect hour-glass shape and I love the train with all of the pick-ups. I like that it gives a cleaner line in front. It is very elegant!!! Good luck!

nrskrs · August 2009

IMHO I think dress number 2 is much more flattering on you...I think it's the bodice on it. Personally, I think dresses with uneven rouching (sp?) at the side will look really grea ton you (the bodice on #2 looks like kind of what I'm describing).

Lindze75 · August 2009

I'm all for #2!!

kpeteley · August 2009

Definately #1

Bellabride2B · August 2009

Looks like you are going to have a tough choice, the vote looks pretty even!I like dress#1, I think the pick ups are really nice and flattering. I think the pick ups in #2 look kinda wierd.

kristinanddan · August 2009

I like the bodice of #2 better, but I do not like how the skirt sits on you. I like #1 a lot!

Voltinxi · August 2009

Maybe it is an amazing angle but #2 makes your body look great!!!!

khouse01 · August 2009

I love the understated elegance of number one, and fabric and texture of it is gorgeous as well! My vote is for number one!

alygoo615 · August 2009

Haha- I think comment about my body looking great in Dress 2- (it's obviously the same body in both dresses) but Dress 1 is too big so didn't sinch me as much.I agree with pretty much all the comments- that's the problem! So split! I like the dropped waist and bodice on the second dress- I love my hourglass figure

But I definitely like the skirt better on the first one. I think if I had the first one altered to my body a bit more, it could work?I liked the experience of the first dress more too though... still undecided!

Brie2010 · August 2009

1. I really hate 2.Also, consider the fact that if you have to ask, it's probably not the dress. I asked tons of people about assorted dresses on here...but when it came down to it, I bought a dress without showing anyone but the salesperson at the store and don't regret the decision for a minute.

Laurms15 · August 2009

#1 gets my vote

clseale13 · August 2009

#1

SarahSmile23 · August 2009

definitely #1

kristinjustus · August 2009

If I had to choose (none of these are my style either), #1 is the best out of the 3.This is just my honest opinion, but the pickups are a trend that is fading quickly. I initially really liked them and don't like them at all now. Even when I liked them, I wouldn't order because I knew that 10 years from now, I'd look back and think WTF was I thinking?