Okay so I am at a loss. I love having this mantle... in theory. I just can't seem to make it look put together and elegant. Not matter what I put on it it looks jumbled and like I threw a ton of things up there just for the sake of doing so.
So after looking at it, what would you do (on the cheap) if this were your mantle?
(This is a picture from before we bought the house a few years ago. The front wall is now a dark gray and the other walls are a lighter shade of gray. In the cut-out next to the fireplace we have a tv.)