So, I thought we had it all figured out but now FI says that he really wants to go to South America because he's not feeling the really long flights/travel time to other destinations we were talking about (Bora Bora, Moorea, Fiji). OY! I've looked at Costa Rica and, so far, the ones that seemed cool were the Paradisus (I think, something like that) and the Four Seasons. I REALLY liked the private island one in Belize, but it's 4k for 3 nights so we'd want to combine it with another hotel, too, and I'm having trouble finding anything. We really like non-cookie cutter hotels, 4-5 stars, cabanas/villas if possible, plunge pools if possible, beach front, good food. Any recs?