I'm wondering if I'm not saying the "magic words" to get a block of hotel rooms reserved for our wedding. I've called four hotels that are close to our church and the reception, every time saying "I'm getting married November 3, and I was wondering what your policies were on reserving a room block. I'm looking to reserve about 10 rooms, but it might be more. What would the price per night look like if we blocked for both Friday and Saturday nights?"
Every hotel I talked to just quoted me their regular weekend rate, and said they could block off rooms and told me when they would release them, but there was no sort of deal on the price to be worked out. To me, it's silly to block off hotel rooms at specific hotels if there's not going to be some sort of discount for my guests. There are quite a few hotels in the metro area, so I'm not too worried about people not finding one.
Most hotels that are farther out from where our ceremony is (either in the 'burbs, about 10 minutes on the interstate, or the ones closer to the airport) are going to be cheaper anyway. So are the slightly less nice ones that are located closer to the church, but I wouldn't recommend that neighborhood.
My FI and I are putting together the accommodations page of our website, and I'm wondering if I can just put three or four hotels on there that are reasonably close to the wedding stuff and might be fun for out-of-towners to stay at? Should I put any that are farther out? I'm figuring some people have hotel chain loyalty, and some might find a good deal on one of the travel package sites.