Wedding Etiquette Forum

Guest List Help

Hey all - I could use some advice on the proper etiquette for our situation. Neither FI nor I know anyone who's situation has been similar to ours, and we just want to make sure that we're doing right by our guests.

FI and I are from different parts of the country (I'm from Maine and he's from Illinois). I moved to IL over a year ago, and we currently live in his hometown, but pretty much all of my family and friends are back in New England. Because his parents are quite a bit older and his dad's health isn't great, we chose to get married in IL, near St. Louis, so they could be there (also, most of his family and friends are here in IL). We are also planning to have a casual reception back in Maine a month or so after the wedding (we are thinking of doing a brief vow renewal ceremony at our Maine reception too, but it's not set in stone yet).

Right now, our guest list for the actual wedding (in IL) includes all of his family and friends that he wants to invite, my family and my closest friends. Our guest list for the ME reception right now is my family, my closest friends, and about 35 of my family and old work friends (plus their kids) that are not on the actual wedding guest list currently. We've also told a couple of FI's best friends that we'd love to have them come to Maine for the party, and are thinking about extending the same invitation to his closest family and friends, but...we're a little confused right now about who to invite to what.

So, here are my questions:
  - do we make one guest list and send invitations to everyone for both events?
  - or, is it ok to make two guest lists (one for each event), and invite the people closest to us to both?
  - and, in a slightly separate vein, at my last job before I moved to IL, I worked on a fairly large team (about 20 people). While some are still on that team, many of those people have since moved into other departments or left the company. Most of them still keep in touch with each other. At this point, I've only included the ones with whom I spent time with outside of work and still keep in touch with. Do I need to invite everyone that was on our team when I was there to be fair? It's only a few extra people, but it's been over a year since I worked there.

Our biggest hang-up in all of this are asking people to shell out a lot of money for travel expenses (especially if they have kids), NOT whether or not we want to celebrate with them. We have not sent out any save the dates or put out a website yet (we just got engaged over the holidays). We just want to make sure that we do the right thing by everyone so that no one's offended or hurt. Sorry for the lengthy post, and thanks for any help you all can offer!

Re: Guest List Help

  • I don't understand why you would need two separate receptions.  People travel for weddings.  People traveled from Arizona and Georgia to Michigan for my wedding.  No questions asked.  Save yourself the headache and extra expense and just invite them to the wedding.  They'll survive.

    And no, no vow renewal. 
  • Yep, invite everyone that you want to be there. If they can't come, it will be sad, but that's life sometimes. There is no reason for 2 parties. That is just gift-grabby.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • I personally thing you should do one... or invite everyone.
     but off the topic- what area in Maine?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I wrote out a long response and then the Knot ate it.

    I agree with the others that the best thing to do is just to have one ceremony and reception and invite everyone to it.  People do travel for weddings.  We had people come to IN from FL and NY for our wedding. 

    As for your old co-workers, you should only invite the ones you stay in contact with and see socially.  You don't have any obligation to the others who have moved on and who you don't even talk to anymore.

    If you really feel like you have to have two receptions, invite everyone to both.  Have an insert that lists the info for both receptions and have a spot on the rsvp card for people to respond to which one they'll attend.  Our friends that got married in SC and had a reception back home in IN did that and it worked out well.  We traveled from IN to SC for the wedding and also attended the one in IN too.
    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Thanks for the advice everyone - I appreciate it. We were originally only going to have one party and invite everyone, but then a large number of peeps from my side said they weren't going to be able to come due to finances and asked if we might have another party/reception in ME so they could see us too. Because so many people asked about it, and we were planning a trip to ME sometime this year anyway, we decided to go ahead and have another party there (and it really is going to be more casual - probably just finger foods, drinks, and a small cake or dessert in a nice park by the lake or in someone's backyard during the afternoon). And just to clarify (I went back and reread my original post, and it was confusing - sorry about that!), we are not planning to invite anyone extra to the second party just because we're having a second party - everyone that's on either guest list was on the original wedding guest list anyway.

    Based on everyone's feedback, I think we'll go ahead and just invite everyone to both. Neither of us know anyone who's had to even consider two parties, so we didn't know if it was ok to do this or not. And thanks for the advice on the co-workers too - that's what I thought, but wanted to make sure. Thanks again everyone!

    And kkchisholm - I'm most recently from the Belgrade Lakes area, but worked in the Portland area for a long time, and went to school near Bangor. Nice to see a fellow Mainer on here!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards