So, FI finally decided on Dante Zeller for the tuxes. We went to the Linden location today. They were very friendly and helpful, and patient, while he took forever picking out exactly what he wanted. In the end, I think we are both very happy with the selections, and we definitely feel comfortable ordering the tuxes from them - they seemed like they knew what they were doing, unlike the people at Men's Warehouse in Union.
He ended up choosing the 2 button notch Joseph Abboud tux jacket, solid satin vest in Dusty Petwer, white wingtip shirt, and a silver/white striped tie. He'll be wearing the same color vest as the groomsmen, but will have a slightly different color tie.
One more thing to check off the list!!