In the DW board we sometimes do a monthly gift exchange through an online site called Elfster. You basically sign up (like you would for an EVite, etc,) and post things on your wishlist. For the exchange, we'd choose a theme (picture frames, earrings, etc.) and you'd note details in your wishlist of your preferences. A "Draw" is done and you don't know who your Elf is until your gift arrives.
I'm waiting on my photo frame to come in the mail any day now! I made one for my Elfster and she's in California.
I know we all have tight wallets, but this might be fun to start in a few months leading up to May? (And I don't have to take the lead on this, if someone else wants to please VOLUNTEER
http://www.elfster.com