The Perfect Dress: Help Me Pick (with Pics!)

16maybeless

I hope I'm doing this right! 

I am torn between two dresses. I love them both. They're both comfortable and I like the way they fit; both look good with the belt I want to wear, both match the overall "feel" of the wedding. Every single friend and family member I've asked has said "I love them both!" which is lovely to hear but not helpful when I need to pick one soon! :-) So help me? Pics below:

[pics deleted]

Edit: Thanks all! Looks like #2 is the winner. Deleted pics just in case.

itzMS

I like #2.

The first one is a little too "busy" for my taste.

Maggie0829

Love the #2.  The top of the first one just seems messy.  I also like the skirt of second one better as well.  It just overall seems more flattering on you.

16maybeless

Thanks, all! My reservation with this one was that the neckline is a bit high. Do you think it's OK or alterable?

itzMS

16maybeless said:

Thanks, all! My reservation with this one was that the neckline is a bit high. Do you think it's OK or alterable?

I think it's perfect. I was thinking the neckline on the first dress was actually too low...

Maggie0829

I agree with @itzMS.  I think the neckline in the second one is perfect and definitely not too high.  I thought the dip of the first was a bit much which is part of the reason why I wasn't a fan.

jenn5628

Agreed #2.  # 1 had some odd things going on between the bust and the waist.

cwaggoner07

Another vote for #2. It falls better on your hips, and the top is much cleaner.

twotimemob

One of the things I did NOT like on #1 was the low dip in the cleavage.  I didn't like the dress with the belt or the belt with the dress.

Dress #2 sweetheart neckline is higher (better!) and the belt you want goes much better.

SBmini

The second one is way more figure flattering. It gets my vote!

cmalork

Agreed with the PP! Dress #2 is very pretty on you and flatters you well.

winelover123

#2

QueerFemme

Another vote for #2.  The neckline on the first one is way to plunging, and doesn't go with that feather belt at all. 

mlg78

I agree that the belt looks better with #2 and the neckline is fine.  It's not even remotely high. Your guests don't want to see your girls on your wedding day.

manateehugger

Number two for sure. It's appropriate while still allowing a good hint of sexy. Very pretty!

misssunshine17

Another vote for #2. Lovely! I'm obsessed with your belt, too. 

KerisaHarman21

#2

stephie0612

#2 is gorgeous!