Ok I thought I'd XP this because I'm still a little unsure of what happened and I know some of you ladies are married so you might be more help to me!
Before my FI proposed he had my e-ring sized to a size 5. It fits perfectly. Well we bought our wedding bands a few weeks ago and I just picked mine up from being resized (both my e-ring and band are Leo diamond rings, both from Kay Jewelers, bought and sized by the same store) and I swear that my wedding band is smaller. But when I put them together ( not on my finger) they appear to be the same size. But my wedding band literally hurts to get on and to take off. Sometimes when my fingers are swollen I have a semi-difficult time taking off my e-ring but it never hurts. Does anyone know why they seem to be different sizes?
Its even still too tight if I wear it alone and not with my e-ring. I am definitely going to have to take it back and have it resized again. I just don't understand why it is seems to be so much tighter.
Oh and my ring is just a white gold band with diamonds half way around the band.