Wedding Etiquette Forum

Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?

I haven't posted much here, but I've read alot.  Y'all usually give some good advice, so I'm hoping you can help me out.  It's a bit of a long story, so thanks in advance for sticking through to the end. Cliff notes at the bottom if you don't feel like reading the whole thing.

Background: I got engaged last November.  I have been living with my fiance for almost a year.  I had one best friend whom I had been friends with for almost 10 years.  A couple of months after I got engaged, we had a bit of a falling out.  We have remained friends, but not as close as before- all the issues haven't been quite worked out yet.  Said friend got engaged in March, four months after I got engaged.  She told me around then that her parents are paying for the wedding completely, and limiting the guest list to exactly 75 people.  Since they are paying, they are dictating that she invite all of her family, leaving not much room for friends.  As such, she told me back in March that I would be invited, but they would not have room for my fiance and he would not be invited.  I told her about the etiquette of the situation, and that I was not comfortable with it.  We did not talk about the situation for awhile.  She set her wedding date for October 20th 2012.

Fast forward to today.  I get a message on Facebook.  I'm copying and pasting it here so y'all can read her exact words and not my interpretation of them.  Any names are edited for privacy.

Message: "just wanted to let you know that invites are being sent out tomorrow. I lost the battle of the +1's with my mother (her version of mando +1's is outdated) and until we get some "no's" in from the required invitees (ugh) we won't officially be able to invite your fiance. Please don't get mad at me. It was not my decision and since I am not paying for the wedding this is one of the battles I had to lose temporarily. I hope you understand and that you don't get upset when you get the invite and it says "___ of 1" It shouldn't be a problem and there should be room but my mom wouldn't let me send out invites for more than 75 people. Either way I really would like you there and hope you don't get upset when you see the invite!"

So here's my reaction: I'm hurt that she only used facebook to get this point across to me.  She already knew how I felt about the situation.  In my mind, something this important and sensitive necesitates more personal contact than a Facebook message.  On top of that, I'm just plain offended that she would invite me without my fiance knowing how I feel about it. I almost feel like I'm being manipulated into RSVPing and going by myself.  She can't even promise me that there will be room for him, just that there "should" be. 

Anywho, I would like to respond to her Facebook message, letting her know how I feel without coming across as rude or offensive.  Any suggestions on how to word a reply? And what would y'all do in this situation: RSVP yes, go only if fiance can go, RSVP no out of principial, wait until word that fiance can come to RSVP, etc?

CN: Got engaged in November.  Close-ish friend got engaged the following March and immediately informed me that my fiance would not be invited due to budget, etc. Received message today (quoted above) reiterating this, also saying that if there's room and "there should be", fiance can come.  Wedding is October 20th of this year.  Want to know how y'all would reply to Facebook message and how you would handle the RSVP.

Thanks in advance for y'all's help! Sorry again it's so long.  Just wanted to make sure I included ample information.
Anniversary
«1

Re: Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?

  • If she is a really good friend, and you truly want to see her married, I would wait to RSVP to hear whether FI can go.

    If you really don't see her as a really close friend anymore, I would probably just rsvp no.
  • that's pretty sketchy of her.  You can't invite one 1/2 of a couple to a wedding..that's rude.  I would decline all together.

    If there's no room in the budjet for married or people in relationships - they should just exclude them..which is basically what she's saying. what is she only inviting single people?

    I'm not sure how to relay that across in a nice way back to her :)
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    image 223 invited
    image 139 are ready to party!
    image 87 have better things to do
    image 4 cannot find the mailbox

    RSVP Date: July 20
  • I'm honestly just wondering, but do you really like this friend? How do the two of you normally communicate?
  • I think she is being unbelievably rude, but there are many aspects to consider here: 

    1. What effect will declining have on your friendship? You say that you've been friends for 10 years. (But that you've had a falling out.) How important is it for you to attend her wedding vs. how important is it to go with your fiancé? Only you can answer that. 

    2. How does your fiancé feel about this situation? If he is feeling upset or angry, then his feelings trump hers.

    3. How far away is the RSVP date? Can you wait and see what happens? 


  • If this was truly a close friend and it really is her mom  not allowing the +1, honestly I would still attend the wedding. She has been honest about the situation from the beginning.  

    You certain don't have to, but that's what I would do under this circumstance.   Other situations I can't say I would say the same.







    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
  • I don't know about everyone else...but I think that I would probably be understanding. It sounds like her hands are tied by those that hold the purse strings. I'm not an RSVP no out of principle kind of person... so if I were you I would think about how important my relationship with my friend is, and if at the end of the day I really want to be present for her wedding. If yes, I would RSVP yes. However, if you are considering rsvping no out of principle it sounds like you probably don't actually care about participating in her wedding day...so you should probably RSVP no?
    photo JamieMasonWedding-8992-S.jpg
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:aea1ca00-a9b6-4c27-9fb1-6a22f9f228d6">Re: Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]If she is a really good friend, and you truly want to see her married, I would wait to RSVP to hear whether FI can go. If you really don't see her as a really close friend anymore, I would probably just rsvp no.
    Posted by HockeyFan4[/QUOTE]

    <div>Ditto this. It all depends on the closeness of the relationship on if you ask or not. Either way - if FI isn't invited then I would RSVP no. </div>
  • Look, here's the thing.  You're right.  You should have been invited with him or not at all.  But it sounds like she really wants you there, and her parents are being a-holes.  That's not really her fault, KWIM?  And at least she said something to you at all, instead of just letting you get the invite and think she totally disregarded your feelings on it. 

    If it were me, and I wanted to go, and would have gone if my SO had been invited, and you'll know other people there, I'd go ahead and RSVP yes, and hopefully you'll be able to bring your FI.

    But it's a personal decision.  If you're really that upset about it, then just don't go.  And that's fine.  You have every reason to be upset, but I think your anger is a bit misdirected in this case.

    image
    Everything the light touches is my kingdom.
  • edited July 2012
    It honestly sounds like there's not a damn thing she can do about it.  It sounds like she's tried really hard, but has been honest with you from day 1.  If it was me I would go, but depending on how many other people I knew at the wedding probably leave pretty early.    

    ETA: It also sounds like she's really upset about these constraints put upon her.  If you respond chewing her out again I think it would just be rubbing salt in the wound.  
  • Oh, yeah, I definitely wouldn't respond chewing her out.  It sounds like she genuinely feels bad. 

    image
    Everything the light touches is my kingdom.
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:a7288d09-3da6-4742-b817-fc9a2e2aeea0">Re: Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]If this was truly a close friend and it really is her mom  not allowing the +1, honestly I would still attend the wedding. She has been honest about the situation from the beginning.   You certain don't have to, but that's what I would do under this circumstance.   Other situations I can't say I would say the same.
    Posted by lyndausvi[/QUOTE]

    <div>Yep. It's super unfortunate that he's not invited, but if you really would like to go, then go.</div>
    image
  • I'm sorry, but if she cared that much about having you there and knowing how you felt about it, she could have ponied up the cash for the 76th person.  Blaming it on her mom is a cop out and BS.  

    I would consider being a b!tch and saying something in response about how I had to pay for things that my parents didn't think were necessary in my own planning.  But really, I would just respond that I understand that she has decided not to invite my FI, that I am uncomfortable attending a wedding where he is not welcome, and that I would therefore be RSVPing no.  
  • I'm not sure what kind of conversation you're thinking about having with her?
    She knows you want your fiance invited. She knows it's rude not to invite him. You know she can only invite 75 people.

    Is it just that she told you all of thise [for the second time] on FB that you're even more upset? I wouldn't focus too much on that, especially since she's discussed this with you before and if you communicate via FB a lot.

    So before you decide to have a talk with her about how all this makes you feel... really decide what you hope to accomplish with this conversation.

    As you already know your fiance can't come to the wedding and as she already knows it's rude of her not to invite him... I just forsee no positive outcome.
    But maybe that's just me being a wuss.


    As to whether you should go or not...
    Firstly I gotta wonder how many of the 75 aren't family. If there are only 20 family members and 55 friends, and there's not a single person she was willing to purge out of those 55 friends for you to be comfortable and have your future husband there... then I'd be pretty POd. I'd decline the invite. A gift/card or presence at shower would depend on if I wanted to salvage the friendship or not. That would be up to you.

    If she's only got like... 5 friends she can invite, then I'd be a little more understanding. Yes she is being rude. But I'd be a little more understanding that she'd want to surround herself with people she's close to, and she's just really wants me there and hopes I'm willing to forgive the slight. If that's the case, assuming I knew at least some of the people who were going to be at the wedding, I'd probably still go. And if my fiance got to come in the end (I don't think we'd be offended about B-listing at that point since his not being invited in the first place was bad enough...), all the better.

    So if you really want to see your friend get married, forgive the slight and go.
    If you don't care or you're that angry at her... don't.
  • leah51leah51 member
    First Comment

    I agree with most here. Much of your choice I think comes down to how close you two are are.  A 10 year freindship depsite a falling out would be worth your going (especially since your friend is reaching out it seems important to her).  It does seem like she is not in control of her invite list and 75 people is not a lot.  After I was engaged I was invited to a few weddings and my FI was not.  My attendance at those weddings came down to my supporting the friendships of the those getting married.  When it came my turn to do my invites I too upset people about who was and was not getting invited but money was tight and I had a guest list of 135 that much more than your friend.  I did not invite my cousins FI to my wedding nor did I a few family member/friends BF.  One thing you can try to do is tell her that you are willing to pay for your FI plate if you can afford it that is.   (That was one option a gave a few people they did not find it rude and anyone who did had to understand that wedding cost money and as much as we would like to invite everyone we really can't.  And a few actually took me up on the offer). 

    You really have to give your friend credit for telling you well in advanced.  I too am not a fan of the whole FB communication and since that's not your style you should respond to you in person or over the phone. 

  • I would just decline, maybe send a small gift and say, "best wishes!" on your RSVP.

    If her mom won't let her invite more than 75 people, she needs to either pay for SOs herself (because he's your fiance, not your "plus one"), or she needs to cut her list - which, honestly, might have meant cutting you completely if she was only having a family wedding, for the most part. I'm someone who would be much happier at being cut from the list than being put in this awkward situation.

    So yeah, she's blaming her mom, but she's not completely without blame in this situation, herself. If there was literally NOTHING she could do about it, I'd be more understanding, but that's BS. I only had 68 people at my wedding and I could accomodate SOs (and, in fact, guests for everyone).
    my read shelf:
    Meredith's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
    40/112

    Photobucket
  • Thanks everyone for your advice! Great as always, and some points that I hadn't thought of. 

    For those of you who wondered about how my fiance feels: he's hurt as well.  It makes him feel like he's not wanted.  He doesn't really want to go to the wedding, but he would go to support me if there ends up being room for him.

    I will not know many other people there- I've only met her fiance once.  The only other people I'd know are her parents, siblings, and one of the bridesmaids.  Other than that, I don't know any of her family, her friends, or his friends.  She's also only inviting most of her family because her parents are requiring it- she doesn't even want some of them there and is hoping they won't come.

    Thanks again for the advice.  I think I will just end up holding onto the RSVP until I know for sure if my fiance is invited.  If he isn't invited, I won't go.  As much as our friendship means to me, my fiance means more, and I won't do something that hurts his feelings. 
    Anniversary
  • I guess if your FI is hurt that changes things a little. My FI wouldn't give a flying fuuck...he'd actually probably appreciate it! Haha
    photo JamieMasonWedding-8992-S.jpg
  • Sorry, but there's no way I'd go. 75 people is a pretty good sized wedding in my book. Also, it seems to me like she knows darn well this is rude and wrong but is doing it anyway, either by not standing up to her mom or by blaming her mother for this choice. The begging for understanding on Facebook seems pretty manipulative to me (as in, "I know this is totally wrong but my wedding is a special situation, I have to make tough choices different from any other wedding, so your fiancé didn't make the cut but don't be mad"). If you think size and budget make this different from any other wedding guest list choice then I'm missing something. Bottom line, I don't think she truly cares whether or not you go, or she wouldn't put you in this position. The Facebook message seems like a lame attempt to keep you from ending the friendship over her snub.
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:7a8bdb75-d4e0-4e85-82f6-d6a31de607d6">Re: Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]<strong>'m sorry, but if she cared that much about having you there and knowing how you felt about it, she could have ponied up the cash for the 76th person.  Blaming it on her mom is a cop out and BS.  </strong>II would consider being a b!tch and saying something in response about how I had to pay for things that my parents didn't think were necessary in my own planning.  But really, I would just respond that I understand that she has decided not to invite my FI, that I am uncomfortable attending a wedding where he is not welcome, and that I would therefore be RSVPing no.  
    Posted by MyNameIsNot[/QUOTE]
    <div>
    </div><div>THIS!  I am not giving that girl a free pass just because her parents are paying. She had a choice: accept their money and cut friends or pay for the wedding herself. Or accept their money AND pay for the extras herself. We consistently tell brides on this board that their ideas are rude despite who is paying. </div><div>
    </div><div>I wouldn't go. Or I would just RSVP using the same logic she did. "Sorry! I reallllllly can't go unless my FI can go! I hope you understand! If a space opens up let me know and I would love to come!" </div>
  • On the bright side, I bet there will DEFINITELY be room for your fiance once your friend's guests all RSVP "no" due to the rudeness!
  • edited July 2012
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:2e803fef-0646-4fde-b85b-3a3fee6e16a0">Re: Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding- WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]<strong>Also, it seems to me like she knows darn well this is rude and wrong but is doing it anyway, either by not standing up to her mom or by blaming her mother for this choice</strong>.
    Posted by lahlah12bk[/QUOTE]


    I have to agree.  Coupled with the fact that your FI is hurt.  I truly believe that if someone is adult enough to get married, they should be adult enough in handling hard details about the wedding, such as making the decision to not accept your parent's money if they insist on being rude.  At that point, I feel she should pay the extra money to do the right thing or decline their help.  She's putting her parent's rudeness on you, and that's totally not cool. 
  • If it were me, I wouldn't go...first of all, he is your FIANCE..not a boyfriend, not someone you've been seeing for 3 weeks. I could MAYBE see her say no to +1 if the couple wasn't in a serious relationship...would she invite him if her were your husband? I'm working on my guest list right now, and we can only have 150 guests, which sounds like a lot but we both come from large families....so i understand the +1 thing, but I'll be dammed if I invite only half of a soon to be married couple. it's just rude.
  • I must be doing this backwards, because I was counting all of my friends I wanted to invite as two people and was going to consider it a bonus if I saved money if they didn't bring their SO/a friend.  :)
     
    I get she's in a tough spot because of her mom but I also think she needs to take some of the responsiblity.  You told her you thought it was rude and she still chose other guests over your FH and now she's making excuses.  B-listing your FH doesn't magically make it any better.  Two rudes don't make a right.  
    Formerly known as flutterbride2b
    image
  • I always thought cost per plate and the space excuse was why you did your guestlist first. Anywho, I agree with PP about deciding if this is a relationship you want to keep or not. I think it is childish that she is putting this all on her mom, she should have invited some whole couples and not just half of a couple. Also, doing it through facebook is annoying too. I am more thinking she shouldn't have told you any of this and especially not through facebook. This goes back to the childish part where she is using her mom's supposed bad behaviour to make herself look better.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Y'all are so super supportive, it's amazing.  I feel less like I'm over-reacting now.  Given our recent falling out, I feel like I'm walking on egg shells whenever I talk to her.  I wanted to make sure I was having a reasonable reaction to her message before responding.  I think it will respond, but not via Facebook.  I figure since I'll be telling her I wish she had told me over the phone/text, the least I can do is respond in the manner I would prefer.  So I think I'll text her, either tonight or early tomorrow.  I'll politely let her know that I will not go if my fiance is not invited.  I think I'll also let her know how this has made him feel- he deserves to have his voice heard too. 

    Honestly, this whole thing in conjuction with our falling out earlier this year has shown me a side of my friend I hadn't seen before.  So maybe this is all for the best, and I'll be able to move on from a friendship that maybe wasn't meant to last forever. Frown
    Anniversary
  • lyndausvilyndausvi mod
    First Anniversary First Answer 5 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited July 2012
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:fec3269f-cba5-4286-bb89-bbc71905fd51">Re:Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re:Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding WWYD?: This. If a bride comes on here and tells us her parents are paying for the wedding and are not allowing SOs, we tell them to offer to pay the dofference or to decline the money and pay for their own wedding, so I'm really confused as to why OP's friend gets a pass? Either we think "mommy made me do it" is a valid excuse or we don't, and I for one don't. DH has skipped family weddings when I wasn't invited before we were married and I'd do the same for him. It's about putting your relationship first. Honestly, I'd reply to her message and tell her that you are sorry her parents have put her in this situation, but you and FI are a social unit and do not attend social functions where the other is not welcome/invited.
    Posted by StageManager14[/QUOTE]<div>
    </div><div>I look at it this way.  I would never split up social units.   I more than likely be offended if I got an invite that didn't include my DH.</div><div>
    </div><div>I will always tell brides they must invite social units regardless of who is paying.  "my mommy made me do it" excuse would not fly.</div><div>
    </div><div>That said, even though I preach and follow good etiquette personally I'm willing to "look the other way" to people I'm close to.  Especially when I know the circumstances like a crazy controlling mom or something.</div><div>
    </div><div>I will admit that it's a case-by-case for me.  Heck, I'm flying to Austria in August for a "fake wedding" that I had to RSVP back in FEBRUARY and have to pay for my own plate at the rehearsal dinner.   In that case my DH not being invited would have been a dealbreaker<span style="font-size:9.16667px;" class="Apple-style-span"><img src="http://cdn.cl9.vanillaforums.com/downloaded/ver1.0/content/scripts/tinymce/plugins/emotions/images/smiley-tongue-out.gif" border="0" alt="Tongue Out" title="Tongue Out" /></span></div><div>

    </div>






    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
  • I wouldn't go, especially if FI is hurt by it too. She absolutely could have done something about it. If she couldn't afford to pay herself or to pay for some extra seats, she should've just not invited you at all. That honestly would have been a lot less rude, and people understand that not every signle person can make the guest list for a wedding all the time. I do feel like her FB message was manipulative in trying to get you to go and overlook the etiquette faux pas that she knew darn well about. Passing the blame on her mom was not necessary; she is to blame as well. She did have options, and just chose to overlook them, hoping you would overlook them too.


    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Vacation
  • JMO, but I don't see how a text message is any better for this kind of conversation than a facebook message. 
    photo JamieMasonWedding-8992-S.jpg
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:877001c2-2ca0-478a-8277-2f61c6053075">Re:Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re:Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding WWYD? : I look at it this way.  I would never split up social units.   I more than likely be offended if I got an invite that didn't include my DH. I will always tell brides they must invite social units regardless of who is paying.  "my mommy made me do it" excuse would not fly. That said, even though I preach and follow good etiquette personally I'm willing to "look the other way" to people I'm close to.  Especially when I know the circumstances like a crazy controlling mom or something. I will admit that it's a case-by-case for me.  Heck, I'm flying to Austria in August for a "fake wedding" that I had to RSVP back in FEBRUARY and have to pay for my own plate at the rehearsal dinner.   In that case my DH not being invited would have been a dealbreaker
    Posted by lyndausvi[/QUOTE]

    <div>This is what I was thinking, we're of one mind tonight lynda! </div><div>
    </div><div>If this was a close friend, and I knew her parents were crazy enough to literally only let her have 75 people, and for whatever reason could not afford to chip in more money for more people, I would let it slide. </div><div>
    </div><div>I'm not saying it's right, and I'm not saying I would tell anyone to do this, because it's still not right. But if I wanted to keep up being friends with the bride, and it really didn't bug me to go alone, like it was a close wedding or if I was going to know other people, I would go.</div>
    image
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_fiance-not-invited-to-a-friends-wedding-wwyd?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:e9b1c36a-32ff-46b0-990c-cf5049ab9b10Post:02f508ff-4fdd-4e19-8f29-41bdfe3da52f">Re:Fiance Not Invited to a friend's wedding WWYD?</a>:
    [QUOTE]Lynda, I guess for me, I will overlook a cash bar, dollar dance, etc for a close friend. But if we're not close enough to invite DH too, then we're apparently not that close, ya know?
    Posted by StageManager14[/QUOTE]<div>
    </div><div>and that is perfectly fine.  It's really what you are comfortable with.  </div><div>
    </div>






    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards