Wedding Woes

I've found family secrets that people don't want to discuss.

Dear Prudence,
My high school requires a senior project to graduate, and I choose to do one on genealogy. In my research I discovered that the woman who I always thought was my grandmother was in fact my stepgrandmother. She married my granddad when my mom was 6 years old and raised my mom as her own. The project required I trace all four of my biological grandparents. When I spoke to my grandfather about this, he requested that I drop that project and do something else. I did, but I love research and kept digging. I was able to find that my biological grandmother is on the list of names of the dead from a mass suicide cult. It turns out I have aunts, uncles, and a great-grandmother. My grandfather begged me to let it go and never tell my mom. He had told her years ago that her mother left because of a drinking and drug problem. I asked my mother if she ever thinks about her real mom and she smiled and said, “My real mom raised me, she loves me, you, and your brother. The women who left a 5-year-old is not a real mom, and I don’t think about her at all.” Should I tell her there is living family while she still has time to meet them? The mystery of these other relatives is killing me.

—The Curious Cat

Re: I've found family secrets that people don't want to discuss.

  • How is a drug and drinking problem any better than mass suicide? He should have used car accident or something.
    image
  • If she wants to go meet those family members, she should.

    But her mother realizes that bio mom didn't exist in a vacuum.  If she had any interest in tracking down and sharing her life with bio mom's family, she would've by now.
  • How is a drug and drinking problem any better than mass suicide? He should have used car accident or something.

    I wonder if the way the story was concocted was to somewhat closely mirror what actually happened...thus any feelings of "I could have saved her from that cult if only........." guilt are truthful and similar in both instances.

    Or, the cult has other active splinters, Gpa wants to be sure nobody he loves associates with them, even in any spirit of "fact finding"

    Easier to maintain the story when it doesn't deviate too far from the truth. Or it just hinges primarily on some substantial omissions and a heap of "I don't want to talk about it"
    imageAlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • I think it depends on your relationship with your mom, personally. My mom and I e-snoop and talk about random things like that all the time, so I would be okay with a simple "Well, have you ever wondered about her extended family?" and if the answer is "Not really", then I'd drop it. If that's not your relationship with your mother, I'd probably honor your grandfather's request to drop it. 

    I will say, though, that as the kid in a situation similar to this, not knowing these old family secrets (because people don't want my dad to find out "The Truth", whatever that is) is SO frustrating. So frankly good on you for finding out the truth. Posterity will appreciate it, even if it's still a touchy subject today.
  • yesssssssssssssssssssssssssss
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards