ETA: Sorry guys, I was extra wordy and very unclear haha. I don't care what the "rules" are for day and evening weddings so this isn't a question about what I should do. I was only curious to see if anyone finds this important or is following the day and evening guidelines ;-)Just a question for the day

Lately I've been searching for makeup inspiration like a mad woman!! FI also has lots of opinions on bridal makeup, don't know how he notices this stuff but he's pointed out that the majority of brides (specifically here, I'm not sure he means in general) always get makeup done that makes them look much older than they really are. Maybe it's the natural, brown or grayish tones but from the last couple of weddings we went to, I see what he means. Anyway besides the hassle of finding something that will fit my skin tone, I'm having trouble finding something I love. I kind of don't want my makeup to be
too natural looking.. I do want to look special and stand out just a bit.
Anyway that got me thinking.. my wedding is at 11am. Meaning I'm supposed to go for the less dramatic looks for my day wedding. At first I was going to ask about this in terms of makeup, but I realize this can easily apply to your whole wedding look. Like when you're shopping for your wedding dress and the first thing they ask is "What time of day is your wedding?"
Are you following the "day" and "evening" wedding looks? Do you think this is something important to follow in terms of dress, makeup, accessories, hair etc.? Would you say it's "tacky" if the look is out of place with the time of day?