Illinois-Chicago

Need Advice re. Walking Down the Aisle Situation

Hi, everyone.

I need some advice with a sticky personal situation. I've always thought that both my parents would walk me down the aisle. My father has been very abusive and controlling to my mother, sisters, and me. I know this sounds overdramatic and cliche, but he really does view us, at worst, as his property and, at best, as his trophies. So, the idea of walking down the aisle alone with him makes me feel incredibly sad. However, I do want to show him and my mother love and appreciation on my wedding day, so I felt like having both my parents walk me down the aisle would both honor them and make me more comfortable.

However, my wedding gown is quite poofy. Plus, I never realized how narrow the aisle at our church is. My mother, my fiance, and I took a little practice walk down the aisle a few weeks ago and, even without the poofy dress, it was quite clumsy. My fiance kept hitting his knee on the pews on his side. Realistically, walking three across is not going to work.

I really don't kow what to do. I've pitched several options to my parents:

-They could walk right behind me. This could symbolize that they're behind me every step of the way and they could also then have the honor of "giving me away."

-They could procede down the aisle in front of me and wait at the altar with the pastor, my fiance, and our attendants. This way, they would be able to see my joy as I walked down the aisle and still have the honor of "giving me away." (This is my favorite option.)

-I've even considered not wearing the somewhat poofy crinoline that I bought to go under the skirt of my dress. My dress would still be a ballgown shape, but not quite so poofy. However, I've already had my first two fittings with the crinoline. I could have the seamstress redo the dress, but would this really help much? We found it clunky to walk down the aisle in jeans.

My father hates both options. My mother is pressuring me to just let Dad have his way and walk me down the aisle by himself. This makes me so uncomfortable. (I'm not using the words "abusive" and "controlling" lightly here.) As far as I'm concerned, him walking me alone is NOT an option. Period.

Does anyone have any ideas for me? I'm so upset about this, I've been sick to my stomach the past few days. I've cried about it. I've been angry. But I just don't see a solution.

I just wish my Dad could find his joy on my wedding day from knowing that I'm happy and in love and not from showing me off like something he's accomplished (when everyone tells me I've succeeded in life despite him, not because of him). And I wish my mother would stop trying to appease him and "keep him happy" and stand up for me.

Okay, sorry for the novel. But really any advice on configurations and set-ups that might work as we walk down the aisle would be much appreciated.

Thank you,
Stacy

Re: Need Advice re. Walking Down the Aisle Situation

  • edited December 2011
    yikes, you are in a tough situation!  Im sorry to hear about the situation with your dad, and believe me -- no one here takes "abusive" and "controlling" lightly so we def dont doubt its as serious as you make it sound!  *hugs to you* for sharing that, it must be tough sharing that :(

    With that being said, have you thought about having your dad walk you down part way through the aisle and your mom picking up the other half?  Other than that, id say to not let anyone walk you down the aisle and go solo (which is pretty common these days!).  Either way, you def need to make the decision and dont let the pressure of your mom or dad sway your decision.  Ultimately you will feel uncomfortable and thinking about it up until the day of the wedding, so make sure you stick to your guns about what you want!

    Best of luck, keep us posted!
  • MrsPapsMrsPaps member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I love your idea of your parents walking ahead of you and still giving you away.
  • edited December 2011
    Is walking down the aisle on your own an option? It might not be ideal but would  remove  a lot of issues out of the mix.
    Last Post 7/8 Leave for Paradise 7/9 Our Beach Wedding 7/13
    image


    Planning Bio
  • edited December 2011
    I absolutely feel your frustration and dilemma, I am dealing with a similar situation, not as severe as yours, but dramatic.  I do pray that all works in your favor and you have a beautiful wedding day.

    I like the option of your parents walking in front of you, however, I know how hard it can be trying to get a stubborn parent to understand it's about you and your fiance and all differences shoulld be put to the side.

    If that option does not work, how about your mom walk you down the aisle halfway and then your dad walks you to the alter?  That may be a good compromise.

    I pray all gets better for you.  Sending you hugs along the way
  • jsquared62009jsquared62009 member
    Fourth Anniversary 100 Comments 5 Love Its First Answer
    edited December 2011
    I'm really sorry that you are in such a tough spot! I think you just need to say "These are the options, pick the one you want." Eventhough it might not be what they want, ultimately you have to feel comfortable on your wedding day. If you don't want your dad to walk you down the aisle alone just don't give it as an option. Let them know that you're not doing it to hurt anyone's feelings, you're just doing what's best for you. And if they really cannot suck it up and agree to one of your options (all which seem to be great compromises!) then tell them you'll walk down alone. If you really don't want to walk down alone and you have a brother you could maybe have him do it. That way you're at least having someone from your family walk you down.

    It's a tough spot, and I hope it all works out for you! Hopefully if you give them the choices and say those are the only options for you then can have enough respect to pick one. Give it some time, and hopefully that will help too!
    Vacation
  • edited December 2011

    I have always hated the "giving the daughter away" thing-no woman should be even remotely compared to property to be given away!

    I think you should have them walk in together in front of you, then you follow on your own.  You are not property.  If he protests, gently remind him you're old enough to get married, so you're old enough to walk 100 feet on your own :)

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    If it makes you feel any better, I am having my father and step father walk me down the aisle. Should be quite amusing though for some of our relatives.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    I totally feel for you. I am in somewhat of a similar situation...I chose to have just my momm walk me down the aisle because she has been my biggest support my entire life....As for you situation, I like the idea of them walking in front of you, maybe they can stop a few feet from the altar where you will meet them and then they can walk you to your FI. I hope everything works out for you and that no matter what you decide, you and your FI should be the most happy people on your wedding day.
  • edited December 2011
    I'm also having both parents walk. I really like the idea of them coming out either right in front of, or right behind you, if you don't all 3 fit.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    I know this situation well: My parents are both abusive. I am walking down the aisle on my own. They will walk down first (although I almost didn't invite either of them at various times) and will wait for me off to the right. I've allowed them  "Give me away" if they want -- even thought I paid for this all myself.

    I agree that having them walk ahead of you is a nice way not to punish yourself, or your mother, further.

    Plus, your poofy gown should shine, lady!!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker LilySlim Weight loss tickers
  • edited December 2011
    Follow your heart. Which I think is having them walk down ahead of you. I think your mind is made up. :) You will regret not doing it your way, if you end up appeasing them. And ellentravis is right... your gown should shine! Good point!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards