Thank you all so much for your input and suggestions in my original post!! It really helped us make our decision. We're going to do a week in Maui and a week in Kauai...so excited!
Any suggestions on hotels (right now we're leaning towards the Ritz on Maui and the Grand Hyatt on Kauai), restaurants, "must see" sites, excursions, etc, would be fabulous! Some of the things I know I would like to do are the Road to Hana, zip line, attend a luau (I've some are great and others are a waste of money), relax on the best beaches, and eat lots of good food!
Also, has anyone done, or is anyone planning on doing a helicopter tour? FI loves helicopters (I've gotten him flying lessons as presents a few times) and I would love to surprise him. I have a feeling it could cost an arm and a leg, and I really don't want to spend a small fortune.
Thanks in advance!