Wedding Party

very hurt - advice appreciated

so i'm not a bride, but my future sister in law keeps talking about her "local knottys" and from lurking around this forum you do seem to be quite helpful.  i'd like some advice.

my younger brother is getting married in january and we've always been very close.  we are only a year and a half apart and we have been through so much together in our lives.  we also have another brother who is two years older than me.  the woman he's marrying has two older sisters. 

i feel very, very hurt that i am the only sibling who has not been asked to be in the wedding party.  younger brother obviously asked older brother to be best man, and bride asked one sister to be maid of honor and one to be a bridesmaid.  i cannot help feeling extremely snubbed.  it's not as though money is an issue with asking me to be a bridesmaid, her family is splashing out a ridiculous amount of money on this wedding (and yes, i do know what weddings cost having worked in the industry, so it is legitimately an expensive wedding and not just sticker shock).  the readings have already been assigned, so i know i'm not going to be doing that, either, and even if i were it would feel like a consolation prize.

i don't care about the dress or the flowers or the bridesmaid present or feeling special, what i care about is getting to be part of my brother's wedding day in the same capacity as every other sibling there.  i know it's the bride's day but it's my brother's day too and he is just as upset that i'm not included as i am.  is there anything i can say or do?

Re: very hurt - advice appreciated

  • There's really nothing you can say.  Often, the bride picks her side and the groom picks his.  If you're close with your brother, you can say, "I totally understand that I'm not a BM.  I'm just not as close to the bride as I am to you.  If you ever wanted me to be in the wedding, I'd be honored to be on your side but I also understand if you'd prefer all men too."

    But beyond that you need to let this go.  You may be the only sister not a BM, but it doesn't sound like the BMs are YOUR sisters.  They're the bride's sisters.  It's understandable to be hurt, but you need to move on.

  • AdeleDazeemAdeleDazeem member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited June 2010
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_wedding-party_very-hurt-advice-appreciated?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:37Discussion:acbb6691-4296-4c92-8e71-dd6b7e2834adPost:6ece6a5d-8e7a-4400-964b-009575c0296c">very hurt - advice appreciated</a>:
    [QUOTE].  i know it's the bride's day but it's my brother's day too and he is just as upset that i'm not included as i am.  is there anything i can say or do?
    Posted by meggybee[/QUOTE]

    It's NOT the bride's day.  Holy crap.  It is a day to celebrate the marrige between TWO people.  This includes your future sister in law AND your brother.

    If you brother is upset by this arrangement and has told you so, then he has a right to say "I want meggy in the wedding."  If the bride doesn't want you on her side (sorry, that sounds so mean), then he can put you on his side.  Groomswomen are common these days.

    EDIT:  oh yes, but you can't demanding to be put in the wedding.  I just meant if your brother says to you "I wish you were in the wedding, how can we fix this?" then you have an answer.  But you can't go running up to him and say "put me on your side!"  If it isn't brought up again, then you have to let it go.
  • You're right, it isn't just her day.  But usually the bride and groom each pick their own side.  I only have 1 brother, and FI has 2 brothers and a half sister who is 10 whom I've never even met.  When it came down to choosing our wedding party, I had always thought my brother would be in my wedding.  But we only did 5 on each side, so FI picked his 2 brothers and 3 good friends.  We discussed for quite a bit having my brother in it, but when it came down to it, Fi and my brother have only actually met twice (we live in different cities), so its kind of like asking a stranger.  And I could never ask him to take out one of his good friends to put my brother who he barely knows.  So my brother is doing a reading and walking my mom down the aisle. 

    I totally understand that you're hurt by this, but there really is nothing you can do.  It might be a sore situation between your brother and his FI, but either way you can't say anything.  Even if money is not an issue, some people truly just don't want big wedding parties.  And I know its more common now for mixed gender sides, but its not something I particularly like or would have done with my brother.

    As hard as it is i think you need to just try and get over it and just enjoy your brothers wedding.  The only way I think you could every say somthing is if he asked you if you are upset by it, but even then I don't think you should make a big deal about it. 

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • I'm sorry that you're hurt, and it's totally understandable. I would not say anything, though, and I would try to let it go.

    Maybe they were hung up on even sides? Or maybe your brother didn't realize that groomswomen are an O.K. thing?
    image
  • just because you're his sister doesn't make you automatically a BM. the bride's bridal party is HER family and close friends. if your brother wanted to he could have asked you to stand on his side, but you can't assume that just because you're his sister that you should be a BM. 
  • I agree w/ Banana.  Your FSIL is under no obligation to include you in her wedding party - she has the people that are close to her - her sisters on her side, which is how it should be.  Have a talk with your brother; maybe he didn't realize that it's ok if you stand on his side. 

    Aside from that, keep in mind that being a guest at a wedding is still an honor - you are there to support the bride and groom, just as much as someone in the wedding party.  Enjoy the day, and try not to get too hung up on hurt feelings.
    Holy Crap. We survived the first year!
    http://tidetravel.weebly.com/index.html
    image
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • like PP said the groom picks his side and the bride her side. though i understand you being hurt. if your brother is upset about this too then he should have mentioned to her that he wants you to be in the WP. i don't see her saying no. at this point either let it go or your brother can say something to her about it. she may have not known how important this was for you. anyways even if your not part of the WP you of course play a very important part in your brother's wedding by being there and supporting him on their day.
  • Are you close with the bride?  Do you ever talk or hang out?  If not that might be why she didn't--she doesn't know you very well.  Even though I typically advocate asking FSsIL to be BMs to avoid hurt feelings just like this, there's no rule that says she has to ask you.  

    Beyond that there's nothing more I can say that wouldn't just repeat what others have said.  You can't force your way into the WP.  And you are still very much a part of the day--you'll be at all the pre-wedding events, in all the family photos, sitting at the family table at the reception and in the front row at the ceremony.  You'll get to eat drink and dance.  You get to wear whatever you want.  Sounds like a pretty sweet deal to me!
    Courtesy of megk8oz
    image
    "I think bablingbrooke is the 13 yr old marring her cousin at the town hall. Lets all give her a big hand. And hope her inbred children can live normal lives." -tabs.

    A word of warning from your friends at Cracked.com: Remember that text is going to be how you make your first impression over the internet; if every third word you type is misspelled, people will automatically assume that you're a moron.
  • It's okay to be disappointed, but each of them gets to pick their own wedding party.  If you're not one of your FSIL's very closest friends, that's probably why you're not a bridesmaid.  Your brother did and still does have the option of asking you to be a groomswoman, but that has to be his decision.
  • I couldn't agree more with Banana.  Having that conversation with your brother is the best you can do.  Other than that, be a guest and have a great time celebrating your brothers marriage.
    Ignorance is a poor defense. Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • I think everyone's given really good advice - don't take it personally, try to let it go.  It sucks, but that's the way it is.

    Also, remember this when it comes time for you to get married.  Remember for every bridesmaid you invite or don't invite, someone's going to get hurt.

    I refuse to get into this drama - BF has 3 sisters, and I have a ton of close friends from a variety of points in my life.  It would be so hurtful to so many people for me to pick a few people to stand up with me.

    It's not about equal sides, it's not about who will look best in the dress, it's not about who will plan the best bachelorette party or bridal shower.  It's about picking people who you want to stand up next to you on the first day of the rest of your life as a married couple.

    I'm going to just have my brother - that's it.  His sisters might be insulted, but we've talked about including them doing a reading or something.  But they can wear whatever dresses they want!!!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • tldhtldh member
    2500 Comments
    I can sympathize with you.  I was the only sibling left out of my younger brother's wedding.  It hurts, but you have to be the bigger person and let it go.
    image
    AKA GoodLuckBear14
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_wedding-party_very-hurt-advice-appreciated?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:37Discussion:acbb6691-4296-4c92-8e71-dd6b7e2834adPost:6cd9f4a2-e3b4-4ebe-99b3-bcef1ecd6cea">Re: very hurt - advice appreciated</a>:
    [QUOTE] When it came down to choosing our wedding party, I had always thought my brother would be in my wedding.  But we only did 5 on each side, so FI picked his 2 brothers and 3 good friends.  We discussed for quite a bit having my brother in it, but when it came down to it, Fi and my brother have only actually met twice (we live in different cities), so its kind of like asking a stranger.  And I could never ask him to take out one of his good friends to put my brother who he barely knows.  So my brother is doing a reading and walking my mom down the aisle.  
    Posted by dnbeach12[/QUOTE]

    <div>It's nice you're having your brother do a reading, but was 5 really an essential number for BOTH sides?</div>
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_wedding-party_very-hurt-advice-appreciated?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:37Discussion:acbb6691-4296-4c92-8e71-dd6b7e2834adPost:7131707d-051b-4042-ab30-409498b0e16d">Re: very hurt - advice appreciated</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re: very hurt - advice appreciated : So, your brother was excluded from your WP because you aren't comfortable with the fact that he has a penis? Honestly, I get it if mixed gender wedding parties aren't your 'preference'.  But to talk about how you'd always dreamed of your brother being a part of the WP, but then to say that it wasn't as important as having a "traditional" photo op is kind of hypocritical.  Your post makes it sound like you still sort of blame your FI for not asking your brother, even though HIS reason for not asking him is much better than YOUR reason for not asking him.
    Posted by StageManager14[/QUOTE]

    I didn't mean for my post to come across that way at all.  I wouldn't say that I always dreamed of having my brother in my wedding.  Just knew he would always be a part of it somehow.  My brother and FI aren't close at all since we all live about 8 hours apart and they have only met twice.  Which is totally fine with me, and I understood why FI didn't have him on his side.  Before coming on the knot and reading everyone's posts I had never heard of or seen mixed gender sides, or really even uneven sides.  So its not at all that I wanted perfect pictures or anything, I just truly never even thought about it or had seen it to even have the idea of it.  I'm the first one to admit that things are totally different in different regions of the country, and until reading about it on here I was ignorant to the fact that it is common now, or even that its being done at all. 
    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • All I can say is that I wish my future sister in laws wanted to be a part of the day as much as you want to be a part of your brothers. 
  • I know that it seem like the ultimate betryal right now do not let nothing like that
    not being in the wedding come between you and your brother. Blood is thicker than water. Just congratulate him and his wife on this new chapter in their lives. Let him know you love him and will always be there for him. Stay encouraged
  • Hi, this is my first post even though we got married last August! ...our wedding was a little particular, as I'm Irish, my husband is Italian and we live in France..tho we got married in Italy, so maybe that informed our choices. He has one younger sister, I have 3 younger brothers. So, I had one friend and his sister, he had one friend and the oldest of the 3 brothers. There was never any question of us not having each others siblings with us...in Ireland we have girls with girls and boys with boys, so that's why his sis was with me and my bro with him. His sister and my first bro read the readings,my second bro played the guitar and read a prayer, and my youngest brother too. Our number of siblings were uneven but there's always a way to include everyone, prayers, ring carriers, songs...maybe suggest that you could do something in the service that would be special...I'm sure it does not mean he loves you any less, wedding are prickly and messy, don't take it to heart..easier said than done I know. Good luck and enjoy the day :-)
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards