Chocolate or Vanilla - can't choose

ldawngirl · January 2011

It's like choosing between children! It can't be done!

We're having three tiers in total. Our top tier will be for our 1-year anniversary, and we're having coconut cake with key lime frosting. Another tier will be pumpkin spice with cream cheese icing (we're getting married in the fall and we wanted a fall-themed flavour).

But for the last option, we can't decide between vanilla and chocolate. I love cake and I'm happy with both. Vanilla seems more traditional, but chocolate is chocolate! We'll have cherry icing with either one.

On a related note, do we have the chocolate/vanilla layer or the pumpkin layer as the bottom (and biggest) tier?

kaesha · January 2011

I'm a huge sucker for the cherry-chocolate combination.

PsyDet 2155 · January 2011

I think vanilla and cherry would be a delicious combo!

sb9411 · January 2011

They'd both be good, but I'd love chocolate because I'm a chocolholic ;-)

SSaltzman87 · January 2011

Either combination would be yummy! But to keep with the richer flavors you have, I'd be inclined to say chocolate.

snowflake350 · January 2011

I'm a chocoholic also, so I had to vote for chocolate. You already have an option for non chocolate lovers.

mstar284 · January 2011

Aw, I'm so boring because I voted for Vanilla. But I love love love it!! And about the pumpkin tier. I love pumpkin, too, but maybe the biggest layer should be the most common/popular flavor so more people can have it.

RoyalSpoiledOne · January 2011

I was voting vanilla until I read the part about the cherry frosting. I say chocolate!

kerrib11 · January 2011

I voted for Chocolate!

doeie04 · January 2011

I say vanilla. Only because you have two flavored layers, one should be plain for the other people that might not like the specialty flavors. Not that chocolate is specialty. But that is just my opinion!

mandi921vh · January 2011

In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/special-topic-wedding-boards_food-cakes_chocolate-vanilla-cant-choose?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Special%20Topic%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:23Discussion:b5283785-b28d-4796-beb4-a50ac6445092Post:19a1b8a2-0e93-4d9f-8fea-6dfe77a0c32a">Re: Chocolate or Vanilla - can't choose</a>:
[QUOTE]They'd both be good, but I'd love chocolate because I'm a chocolholic ;-)
Posted by sb9411[/QUOTE]

<div>Ditto.</div>