Okay, so Craigslist is awesome for finding things. I was browsing around there yesterday and I came across an ad that said "Beautiful Wedding Chapel" (here's the exact ad, actually:
http://grandrapids.craigslist.org/evs/1238520966.html). So I e-mailed the lady and she gave me the link to her webpage:
http://www.pointofgracechapel.com/services . How cute! And only $495 for a wedding and $995 for the reception, or $1,195 for both! That got me pumped.
This might be a good option for you knotties that need an affordable, non-denominational church.