Not that FI and I have any set plans for our new elopement, but Jackson Hole is not off the table even though we cancelled our full wedding there back in March.
I thought of getting married at the Wedding Tree or Schwabachers, then having a lovely, fancy dinner and then stay at a nice lodging for a couple nights. We like maybe rustic over modern, something that isn't full of tourists, personalized service would be nice since our wedding, etc.
I've usually camped when I've gone to JH!
I think Teton Village is out. We didn't like it there. Too many big hotels.
So Amangani is obviously the fancy place, but I think it's too fancy/modern for us.
Jenny Lake Lodge seems great - intimate, personal experience, rustic and tucked away - but it is pricey. Includes your 5 star dinners and breakfasts though. Plus free bikes, canoe rentals. Hot tubs at the suite cabins.
Jackson Lake Lodge just seems too big and I read not very personal. Like big bus tours some there. Plus far away from town if we want to eat elsewhere.
Rustic Inn and Spa and the Rusty Parrot seem nice, but you're not looking at the Tetons.
Spring Creek Ranch? I haven't visited up there yet. Seems like a huge complex?
Dornans - well I had 6 cabins purchased for my actual wedding. Not sure I'd try for them for our wedding trip. I want to be spoiled a little more, not cook all our own meals. Plus you have to clean up your own room and take out the trash I read.