Who knew this would be so difficult? I've contacted Sam Riccobene per recommendations from this board, but I can't get him to respond to my emails. We had an appointment lined up with Larry Todd (and were really excited about it) but he realized he was double booked when we were driving to the appointment.
Any other recommendations? Looking for cheap, laid back, nonjudgemental (we live together...shocker!) and able to perform a Methodist wedding. Emphasis on the cheap.

Thanks ladies! Y'all are always a huge help!