We used McGinn Bus Co.... we needed a bus for the whole night (to take guests from hotel to venue and then back to the hotel at the end of the night) and they were the best priced for a 6 hour block that we were able to find.
We are using Black Tie for our transportation too. In addition to our limos, we got the 2 hr shuttle for transport from the reception to hotel. $249 for ours too (tax, tip, and gratuities included), we shopped around but they were by far the cheapest.
Re: Shuttle Recommendations
Thanks!!!