April 2012 Weddings

Issues with GL/FMIL-LONG

So back during the summer, my FMIL pitched an absolute fit about how we did not want kids at the wedding. The only kids who were to be invited were WP kids-totally etiquette acceptable, but she was pissed. Like threatening not to come pissed. 

So we compromised- after she calmed down, we added kids, but took off members of her/FI's church, as well as mine. We essentially swapped church people for kids. NBD. This wound up being less expensive, since our caterer charges less for kids. Ok cool. We thought everything was handled. 

Well then somewhat recently, she began mentioning church people again and whatnot, so I had FI call her to sort things out. He explained everything to her and reminded her about the compromise. I figured everything was taken care of. She did ask if some church people can be invited to the wedding (just the ceremony), as that is customary for their church. I thought it was weird/rude to only welcome people to one part, but whatever. I gave her an invitation with the bottom (it said "reception to follow") trimmed off.  FMIL even made sure to mention we'll need to tell the pastor not to welcome everyone to the reception at the conclusion of the ceremony. Ok, again, NBD. Clearly you would think she gets it! 

By some revelation, FMIL realizes today, that we are not inviting the church guests to the reception. I don't know how she "just now" got this, as we've been saying that for months. I think she just has selective hearing, or she keeps trying to push and push to get us to say ok fine. 

Anyway, she is offering to pay for their food, but doesn't realize a) Scott and I didn't want a big wedding and kids+church people= >100 guests which is more than we wanted, b) we already compromised and I refuse to keep letting her think if she whines enough, she can have her way, c) I have church people I would like to invite too but am not for the sake of the compromise, and d) I'd also have to order more invitiations and programs, as well as buy more centerpiece materials and make more favors. 

I get that the wedding is at their church, but no one ever told us we MUST invite the members of said church. That is not a rule for any church, as far as I know, and my grandma is paying for 90% of the wedding. We thought they just wanted to come see us be married and be done with it. 

So now all of this has me wanting to say F it, and look for somewhere else. I know it's super last minute, but we rented the country club all day (for the reception). I was thinking I'd call the manager tomorrow and ask her about how much it would be to do the wedding on the lawn or something (chairs+ a tent rental), or even just do the wedding ceremony in the country club. A cousin of a friend did this- people just sat at their dinner seats and watched the ceremony, then had light apps while the B&G took pics, and then dinner was served. 

The thing about the above idea is, I know it would cost possibly up to 1K more (probably more like $500) plus I feel like it might make FMIL even more mad. I thought she'd be touched and honored that I wanted to have the wedding in her town, not my own, but she has just taken the reigns about a lot of things and for some I am grateful, but this is too much. 

Please, all opinions welcome. 
April Siggy Challenge-Wedding Escape: Reading HG/dreaming about Peeta.... Image and video hosting by TinyPic Wedding Countdown Ticker Bio-Updated 4/22**

Re: Issues with GL/FMIL-LONG

  • ugh, I have a difficult FMIL too - I'm sorry. 

    I remember the original situation with her, and based on that I think she is likely not being forgetful but manipulative.  And I'd stand my ground and not give in here.

    Just make sure everything comes from your FI.  Have him calmly explain that a lot of the wants/needs associated with using the church made you both uncomfortable, and you wil lhave to move the ceremony as a result if the proposed compromise is still unacceptable.

    good luck.  FWIW, FMIL first told me she didnt want to invite any family friends, then THREE days before she knew we were addressing them, she gave me a list of 20 extra people for our 100 person wedding.  As if I have that many extra invitations.  FI tried to get her down to 10, and she hung up the phone on him and has not spoken with him in over a week.  yuck.
  • So sorry that this has come up last minute! Or re-appeared as the case may be. I agree that she probably has purposefully selective memory about this, but I just encourage you to wait until you calm down before you make any decisions. Moving your ceremony is going to cause a lot of extra stress an work in terms of invitations and planning. Perhaps more importantly, it could cause a major rupture with your fiance's family. I don't have an answer for you, but make sure you are both on board. If he agrees, you could answer with 'if you've changed your mind about them just coming to the wedding, then I guess we can't invite them.' FWIW, inviting them to just the wedding seems rude, but she's the one it will reflect on. It's her church.
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-club-boards_april-2012-weddings_issues-glfmil-long?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20Club%20BoardsForum:05427f07-4ba2-44d6-9271-99a7af1ee5c0Discussion:ba49c710-1eeb-4ee9-8e8f-4ce5b5bed39dPost:cc260167-a4d9-4c6f-ab22-5f48d768e919">Re: Issues with GL/FMIL-LONG</a>:
    [QUOTE] I just encourage you to wait until you calm down before you make any decisions. Moving your ceremony is going to cause a lot of extra stress an work in terms of invitations and planning.
    Posted by karenmruff[/QUOTE]

    ooh, good point.
  • I'm sorry! Why are fmils so difficult?? I hope all of our experiences make us behave when/if we become mils ourselves. I think changing it sounds like a lot of work that may cause major problems with fi family that may not be worth it as much as being able to say f you seems like it would feel great right now. I would have fi talk to her and be stern that these people can not come to the reception that you made a compromise and you have to stick to it. I also know from expierence it can be difficult for some guys to stand up to their mothers (maybe your fi is good with it but mine sucks) but hopefully she listens to him
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Thanks for the replies. My FI is definitely on board and held our ground. She actually called him before emailing me, so it was actually all settled so to speak, but she emailed me, saying she'll be sure to let the church people know we don't want them there-just to be snarky. Of course it's not that we don't want them there like it's something personal, but rather because of the compromise!

    Of course I'm not going to do anything too rash. I need to talk to the country club manager anyway because she is the caterer and I need to go over some details, so I just thought I'd ask about the cost and whatnot. My FI thinks she might be less mad about the ceremony being elsewhere, but really the issue is not so much the church, but the fact that everything is happening in FI's hometown/his parent's town, so she feels that her people should be invited. Again she offered to pay, but only for food, not all of the other expenses, and plus I just feel disrespected that she keeps ignoring our wishes. 

    Apparently she feels that if the wedding were in MY town, she wouldn't pipe up about stuff like this. Moving the ceremony to another location in the same town is one thing, but relocating the entire wedding when we have already paid a venue fee, caterer, florist, DJ, and baker deposits is just out of the question. 




    April Siggy Challenge-Wedding Escape: Reading HG/dreaming about Peeta.... Image and video hosting by TinyPic Wedding Countdown Ticker Bio-Updated 4/22**
  • Soooo sorry she is back to the drama. I agree with pp that she seems manipulative now. I also agree that moving the ceremony will be a big hassle, more money, and cause a family issue. I would just stand your ground and have the ceremony you and your fiance want. I would have him sit down and explain where you are coming from and what you want and dont want and just polietly tell her that this is the way it has to be. If there are still issues you can always use the excuse that its to last minute to make changes with your vendors. ;) Sorry girlie hope all gets better. Keep me posted and keep your head up.
    Photobucket
    April 2012 April siggy challenge: How I relax image
    My Barely There Bio updated 7/12!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards