Thanks for all of the help on here over the last month or so... Fiji came in a close 2nd for us, but we ended up choosing the "Villas Hermosas" Resort in Santa Teresa, Costa Rica
(
http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g635538-d944571-Reviews-Villas_Hermosas-Santa_Teresa_Province_of_Puntarenas.html)!
My fiance and I can't wait for surfing lessons and the chance to surf every morning on our "own" beach (there are only 4 villas at the entire resort and it's so secluded that no outsiders come there). The flights, rooms, and excursions are very cheap and affordable. And one day after we booked, TravelAdvisor.com announced them as the #5 resort for Top Service in Central/South America -- which is always awesome to hear!
I do want to mention that we almost booked a resort in Fiji, and if you are thinking of booking there, be sure to call our travel agent -- Renee or Annie Marie at
www.unforgettablehoneymoons.com . They were super helpful and found some amazing deals to Fiji. We just stumbled onto this place in Costa Rica a few days ago and were blown away (since the flights are cheaper with CR being closer, we will have a little extra $$ for excursions and food), so we just worked with them directly instead. BUT we are looking to work with UH again for maybe a couples trip to Fiji in the next few years. That would be sweet
!
Best of luck to everyone doing their honeymoon research... If anyone has any questions about Fiji resorts (I researched them for about a month and there are some really cool ones) or this Villas Hermosas that we chose, feel free to ask.