this is the code for the render ad
Moms and Maids

Choosing my final Bridesmaids-Help!

Hey all!

I have been engaged for about 3 months, and am new to the wedding scene. I have never even attended a wedding before. Here is my dilemma:
My fi's brother is also engaged, and his bride, who I hardly knew, made me a bridesmaid. I was honored, because I knew they were trying to include me in their wedding, since my fi is obviously the best man. They have a small bridal party, 3 bm's and 2 gm.

Fast forward to my engagement, and now I feel that I have to have FSIL in my wedding. I want a small bridal party, and already have 4 very close friends who I can't imagine my wedding without. Also, if I add FSIL, I feel obligated to also add my own sister. My sister and I have never had a strong relationship, and she has told me that she is totally fine not being a part of the wedding party, but still be included. I feel obligated to have both because sometimes I feel that my family is jealous of my fi's, and if I only include one "sister", I know there will be problems.

I was just going to politely talk to the FSIL to ask if she wanted to be a reader during the ceremony (she is a wonderful public speaker), to keep her involved in a personal way. The Kicker is that apparently she was talking to my FMIL about being my bridesmaid, even though I haven't asked her yet! I think she assumes, since I will be hers.

Should I just have 6, and deal with it (my fi is going to have 3 gm)? Or should I still try to politely talk to future sis? I really wanted a small wedding party with my closest friends. FSIL lives across the country, so wouldn't be involved in much of the planning anyway. I don't know what to do! I don't want to cause rifts in my new family, especially my fi's brother, who he is very close to! I just need some outside opinions.
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Choosing my final Bridesmaids-Help!

  • bethsmilesbethsmiles member
    10000 Comments Sixth Anniversary 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited December 2011
    I don't think you should feel obligated to have anyone in your WP. I think asking her to do a reading would be a nice way to have her involved in the wedding without her being a BM. Don't explain to her that she isn't a BM just ask her to do a reading, she will get that she isn't in the WP and if she is an mature, adult that will be the end of that.


  • edited December 2011
    I absolutely know that. It has nothing to do with matching sides. If I have what I want, I would have 4 and he would have 3, so either way we're not matching. I just want the girls who mean the most to me and I have known for a long time. Girls that I know would have fun together with me. I know if I added the sisters, I would feel obligated to make sure they are feeling included, I really don't want that role. I want to be able to just have fun, and not worry about the dynamics. Plus our wedding isn't going to be that large, and I don't want a big bridesmaid count for a small wedding.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Stina51286Stina51286 member
    2500 Comments 100 Love Its Second Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited December 2011
    Your Bio says you have 626 days, WTH are you asking anyone now anyway? You are way too far out to ask anyone so if she brings it up just tell her you haven't made any decisions its too far away to make any right now. Thats all.

     

  • edited December 2011
    That was my initial thought too! But if she is assuming she will be one, I need to figure it out as soon as possible before she really believes she is a bridesmaid. She hasn't talked to me about it, and I was hoping if I didn't talk about maids, noone would assume. Unfortunately I was wrong with that assumption. I guess I will just have to talk to her and figure it out.

    Plus I am a planner. I have heard way too many bad stories of brides staying up almost all night the eve of their wedding with last minute details. I know I have plenty of time, but I like it that way. I'd rather do things a little too early, then too late.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Stina51286Stina51286 member
    2500 Comments 100 Love Its Second Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited December 2011
    Im the same way! lol Im not getting married til 2013 either and I have so much figured out. Even potential BMs but NO ONE has been asked yet.

     

  • em01092em01092 member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Don't ask anyone to be in your WP until at least under a year out, and really you can wait until about 9 months.

    I would not ask your FSIL if you are not close with her. But for the record, if you did ask her, she would not be required to help plan or attend any parties, so don't let distance be the main issue. Her only duty would be to show up in the dress you guys agreed upon and smile for pictures.
    April Siggy Challenge-Wedding Escape: Reading HG/dreaming about Peeta.... Image and video hosting by TinyPic Wedding Countdown Ticker Bio-Updated 4/22**
  • edited December 2011
    You don't have to ask her to be in your wedding.  My cousin tried to do that to me saying "You can be a BM in my wedding and I can be one in yours!!!!!!!" (I was like 16 at the time)   Yeah, don't do that to yourself.  Have who you feel closest to and that's it.  

    Also, as PP have said, you have TONS of time.  Relax, don't stress about it and figure out what details you want to now, but don't get hung up on it.  Enjoy this time :) GL!
  • edited December 2011
    Ask FSIL to be a reader, don't ask your sister to be a BM but some other task, and if FSIL asks tell her that it is nothing against her you are just trying to keep the party small. She should understand since she is also having a small wedding party as well it sounds like.
  • janeneojaneneo member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I agree with PPs that you don't have to, but a girl on either side of each GM would be pretty cute! 

    It would  help me in that she was marrying my FBIL, and not just dating.  You two will be around each other for a very long time.
  • Kate61487Kate61487 member
    2500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2011

    #1 - don't actually ask your BMs until much closer.  You can be mentally planning with them in mind, but DON"T actually ask.  Who knows, you might feel much closer to FSIL by the time your 9 months out; or you could have a huge fight with a BFF.  If anyone asks / mentions shopping for dresses just say "oh we haven't even begun to think about the bridal party - it's still more than a year away!"

    #2 - If you don't want FSIL DON"T ask her.  My mom had her FSIL in her BP (my dad's brother got engaged and married during my parent's engagement - so it's the same conneciton as yours); she and SIL never really became friends and 5 years later they were divorced (aunt and uncle, not my parents).  My mom hates that she has this woman she didn't even really like and now has no connection to in her pictures.

  • edited December 2011
    Thank you all for the wonderful advice. I just wanted some outside perspective on it all, and you provided that! I totally agree with the not asking right away, but I felt I should address this since she seems to think she's a maid. Thank you again!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards