this is the code for the render ad
Moms and Maids

Help chosing my maid of honor.

he I only plan to have four girls stand up with me. I'm having trouble deciding on who to pick as my maid of honor, and thought maybe somone on here might be able to give me a little help.

In no particular order....the first person I'm considerirng is a long time friend. I've known her since grade school. She had picked me to be her MOH for her wedding which should have happened earlier this summer. Unfortunately, her and her fiance broke up last winter. She still seems to be in the healing process, and I'm not sure how she feel about the wedding. We've only been able to talk a little bit since the engagement, and she seems a little excited, but I'm not entirely sure yet.

The second person is a friend I've known since high school. She's very dear to me, and just recently tied the knot on her second marriage. I was lucky enough to be a part of her special day as her MOH. She is more than excied about my day, and even tried to help me plan before her wedding even took place (I got engaged two weeks before her wedding), but I managed to change the subject to her wedding until after it was over. She has already told me she doesn't care who I pick to be my MOH, and that even if she isn't picked she still plans to do everything the MOH is supposed to do (especially if it doesn't get done by the MOH).

The third is my sister. My only sister. I know she would be the right person to ask, but I'm not sure how I feel about it. My sister and I have never been very close, nor do we tend to like the same things. We are polar opposites on just about every level there is. She also has a dislike for my fiance, and she hasn't spent more than  an hour with him total. Which with the history I have with my sister, I'm ok with.

I know it "should" be her, and it would hurt less peoples feelings since they would just figure "ok, it's her sister, that makes sense", but I want the person who is my "right hand man" to be happy for this. I just want to limit the amount of negativity around me on my special day.

Any suggestions?
Follow Me on Pinterest
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Help chosing my maid of honor.

  • edited December 2011
    I'm just going to lay it out.  We cannot help you choose, we do not know you, it's not our wedding, etc.  However, I can say... go with your gut.  I can also say, you don't even have to have a MOH.  These are your nearest and dearest and if you can't decide between them then it is no biggie!

    Gooooood luck!
  • edited December 2011
    Your wedding isn't until March 2013. So much could change between now and then. Do yourself a favor. Do not ask anyone to be in your wedding party until 6 -12 months before the wedding date. In the meantime, check out the Wedding Party Board. You will find many posts on the Wedding Party board from brides who chose too early and lived to regret it.
                       
  • steffenfamsteffenfam member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I agree with PP.   Wait.  Your decision will be much clearer if you wait until NEXT FALL.

    And even next fall, if you are still undecided about the MOH, you could ask them all to be bridesmaids, and then as you get closer, you can ask one of them to be MOH.
  • kaitlyn&henrykaitlyn&henry member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I didnt even bother reading the details about each girl...dont take that the wrong way...i simply mean that you know your relationships better than we ever could no matter how well you can decribe them. Choose the girl you feel the closest to. The one you called first when you got engaged, can rely on the most, or would call first in a time of need.

    I also agree with other pp...wait until closer to your date to choose a MOH. Relationships change over time so who you feel closest with now may not be as close to you down the road. Wait until a year or under to ask anyone.
  • Kate61487Kate61487 member
    2500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2011
    ditto PPs; if you haven't already asked them - wait! 

    Based on your descriptions it sounds like you WANT to ask #2 and feel like you're supposed to ask #1 or #3 b/c she's your sister and bc you were her MOH.  MOH (and any BP position) is not tit for tat.  You don't have to return the favor.  Pick the girl you want there the most, the one you can't imagine not being there.  If you still can't choose then just don't have one.
  • Maggie0829Maggie0829 member
    Eighth Anniversary 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 25 Answers
    edited December 2011
    I didn't read each description of the girl either.  You know your relationships better then strangers on the internet.  If you are really confused and unsure of who to pick then don't have a MOH...not having a MOH is perfectly fine...this way no one's feelings will get hurt and you won't have to make a really difficult decision.

    Like a PP said, your wedding isn't for a long time so I really wouldn't worry about this until you are about a year out.  Relationships change and people change.

  • aliciamarieeealiciamarieee member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Thanks you guys. I guess I just needed someone elses thoughts on this other than my mothers (who also says to wait, with the undertones of "....then choose your sister").
    Follow Me on Pinterest
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    I had the same problem, I have 3 girls in my BP and am extremely close with 2 of them. Having to chose a MOH made me feel like I was picking who I should give the other half of my 'Best Friends' necklace to.

    The only reason you really need to pick one is to sign the marriage certificate.
  • KaroPatKaroPat member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I agree that if your wedding is in 2013, SO much could change, so you should wait.

    The only thing I´d like to say is that you don´t HAVE to pick your sister.  Also, I´m not fond of picking someone by what they´re expecting or what other people expect when they perhaps are not the 100% supporters of your relationship or your fiancé.  Maybe your sister will develop a great relationship with him by that time!  But, just don´t feel pressured until you feel like you´re making the right decision.

    I found it really interesting how the announcement of our engagement brought some people closer to us and had some people drift away.  This happened to me with my friends and to him with his friends, and to both of us with family as well.

    His supposed ¨best friend¨ always made him feel crappy for getting married, as if it was a mistake, and got into his head so much that he would wake up at night in panics.  We both decided that he wasn´t the right person to be standing beside us.

    The same thing happened with a close friend of mine who was supposed to be MOH who said ¨what´s the point¨ of coming to my wedding if it wasn´t conveniently located for her.

    The people we have standing by our sides now are people that we love, that love us, and that generate an ambience of love due to how they treat their own families and friends - something we would like to emulate.  We couldn´t be more satisfied with our choices.

    Something I keep telling my fiancé - your best friend should not be the most important person just because you have known him/her the longest.  It should be the person who loves you unconditionally and makes you feel great about yourself. 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards