Engagement Ring cookies - which do you like best?

misschristinec · June 2010

I've made lots of cookies in the past and since my FMIL & FFIL are throwing us a backyard BBQ Engagement Party (umm 6 months late, but that's what happens when you get engagement on Hanukkah and have a huge family).

So I am making my dough and the cookies tonight. I'll decorate then throughout the week. Which design (selected from a google image search do you like best?)

1. (Design from cakeheaven.net)

2. (design from thewelldressedcookie.com)

3. (design from ETSY seller Sugar Coated Sweets)
.

(cookies I made for a friend's bachelorette party- I made these in a friend's apt in Philly and didn't have all of my tools.. I spared you the p*nis cookies from another b-party)

Danes983 · June 2010

Wow. The ones you made look awesome! I kind of like No 3. but thats bc Im a chubber and I like more cookie less hole.

lynzandgreg · June 2010

um those look amazing! I like number 1... goodluck!!

hcer0708 · June 2010

#1 Those are exactly what i had for our e-party.

gymchick05 · June 2010

Im making engagement ring cookies for my party too! Im so excited- I found colored sugar that looks like silver and another that looks like crystal/diamond so I am going to use that make make them like sugar cookies. I hope they turn out looking 1/2 as nice as these!

Faith2730 · June 2010

Cute cookies! I like #1 the best.

raangoli · June 2010

I like #1 the best. I would totally be cheesey and wear it as a ring...before they disappeared into my belly!

Laurms15 · June 2010

I like #1 or #2

smw42 · June 2010

I like #3 but that's because I like more cookie

Reilly626 · June 2010

1!!!!

kristen8040 · June 2010

#1

DandT1206 · June 2010

I like the looks of #1 and #2 best, but I see everyone's point about #3 (more cookie!)

kasabby · June 2010

I like #3.

bheartsb · June 2010

#3

jchristel · June 2010

I like #3, the others are cute, but 3 is the only one I would want to eat.

Shand18 · June 2010

I like # 1.

ecg129 · June 2010

I'm gonna say - the other ones look cute but # 3 looks yummmmmy

TuffysMommie · June 2010

#1 or #2

cvl105 · June 2010

I like #2 best...I like the way the "setting" looks better than #1. And #3 doesn't necessarily look like an engagement ring to me...just more of a circle with a random thing on the top.