this is the code for the render ad
Second Weddings

Vow Renewal-It blew up in my face. Long

I don't know where to put this, its a destination/vow renewal and if this is in the wrong category please someone be kind and direct me the right one.


So, my husband and I have been together years before we married. We had a wedding set up before he had left to boot camp but before the wedding planning got to be in full swing many conflicts arose (not military related). I didn't care anymore about the wedding and just wanted to be married. He agreed and we both decided when the milestone came up we would celebrate the 8 years we have been together throughout. So, in the midst of him leaving, me going to school, graduating, packing everything by myself to leave to Hawaii in only three days (that was a rush!) the VR was in the back of our minds. Not a big blow out like my BIL and SIL's this year (it was HUUUUUGE) but a small intimate one with just our families and us. We both have big families and it will be more of them than our friends.

There are many conflicts in the way though.

1. Location: I was going to plan the VR in our homestate while living in Hawaii but that is almost next to impossible. It can be done but it will be harder, especially since we will be doing it on our own. Our families are busy and we don't want to ask them to do something like this if they are busy. So, naturally the next step was maybe having it here in this state. My husband loves the idea..me..not so much. I have nothing against doing the thing here and it would be a great idea but wouldn't it be selfish to ask people to fly here?

Our families (meaning our parents) think it is a great idea. They have been wanting to come up here for ages and if anything it is a great way to have a vacation for them. My mother, my stepfather and siblings would stay with us, I would pay for my father, his girlfriend and my paternal grandmother to stay at a hotel nearby that is five minutes away from here. So, that seemed to work but the discerning voice of a certain relative stated it would be selfish because other members (aunts, uncles,etc) would not be able to come. Which leads us to...

2. Guest List: That is not exactly true on her part. I understand that not everyone would be able to come to Hawaii for financial or other reasons. I totally get that and would not be upset in any way. Most of my relatives are once a year relatives so I'm not really close to them but I would still like them to come.

My fiance and I decided to find a hotel that does a discounted price and that way our guests wouldn't have to spend so much on a place to stay. In addition to this HIS parents have a timeshare on this island so some or most of his relatives will stay with them. We would be sending out the invites this October, 11 months away from the VR. I suppose that gives people time to figure out if they want to come or not and we were going to put a note stating that we will find discounted hotels and transportation. I don't really know when to put the RSVP date though so I will have to research it.

In addition to this, I thought for those who couldn't come I would send a DVD and maybe a little giftbox just so people would know we were thinking about them.

3. Finances. This is actually not a problem. Just how do I tell people (certain relatives) to stay out of it? I don't want people asking about how much money it is. Especially since I have found budgets and discounts that will help us save as well as smaller DIY things.

4. Ceremony. A rather *lovely* relative pushed her way into our courthouse ceremony and there was some unresolved drama. This same relative told us we should not have a ceremony but a reception. However, the one we had was rather impersonal and we  want to add religious and personal touches. I feel that a VR should have some meaning to it.  I asked my dad to say something and maybe play the guitar. My husband's dad will read  a poem in Spanish and there will be some religious aspects in there that is more personal.

.Despite calmly telling this to my relative, it still isn't good enough and I am at my wits end with her. With all the negativity she feels about everything, I almost want to tell her not to bother to come but it would be rude. Yet is she right?
 
I don't know what to do anymore. I almost feel pressured by some (not all, actually the majority have told me to do it in HI so they can come see the state-oops, I mean us) to give up and just do the VR in our homestate with it being big and with so many people and using some old ideas I had vs. having a small intimate one in Hawaii with much more scaled down things. I don't know how to plan it long distance and here I feel like I would get more help.

Sorry.

Re: Vow Renewal-It blew up in my face. Long

  • Lisa50Lisa50 member
    2500 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    How about you take a step back and consider what you and your husband really want?  The first step might be acceptance that the wedding ceremony you had accomplished what you wanted -- to be married.  That part is done. 

    Wouldn't the cash you'd spend on a vow renewal celebration (that seems to be angst-filled before it's begun) be better spent on a really nice vacation for just the two of you?  Then, when your 25th anniversary rolls around, if you're so inclined, have a big party to celebrate with family and friends.

    Just my $0.02.  I wish you the best.  Good luck!
  • edited December 2011
    You weren't kidding when you said "long" were ya?  ;)

    Anyway - I agree with Lisa on the take a few steps back. 

    You are already married so having a vow renewal is a "Nice to have" but isn't required - right?  So why would you stress yourself out and beyond to try and throw a party with this much drama? 

    My advice for a vow renewal - plan your ceremony.  Make it ABOUT the commitment to each other.  Re-commit, celebrate the years so far, whatever it is that you and your H are trying to accomplish with this. 

    THEN and ONLY THEN - invite your family.  You are not obligated to pay for anyone to come to Hawaii.  You could get a hotel block if you wanted to - but again you don't pay for those.  The guests do.   If you do have guests - be sure to plan a meal of some sort - bbq at the house?  a fave restaurant?  etc  (it does NOT have to be a traditional wedding venue)

    I just re-read your post - are you stationed in Hawaii?  Will you be coming back to the mainland/home state at some point?  Perhaps waiting until then for a vow renewal would be a better idea?

    Your families can come visit regardless of having a vow renewal too.  They could call it a "Vacation"!  Smile

    Oh and one last point - on your "Lovely" relative - tell 'em to Mind their own Business.  It is your (and Hubs) ceremony - and what is important to you may not be to him/her and therefore they should just butt out.  Stop talking about this stuff to them, and when 'ideas' are offered say "thanks, I'll take that into consideration."  then discard as you see fit.

    Good luck!
  • edited December 2011
    Hi, thanks for the advice on the post (it was written at night...problems seem to creep into the mind around that time, don't they?)
    We do want the ceremony, I love that we are married and even though the VR isn't a have to thing, it would still be nice. At this point, I am basically ready only to have our parents and siblings come. I think it would be too much of a worry to really invite everyone especially the "lovely" relative. Everything is still up in the air since it may be a year away so things may change.

    We are going to be living in Hawaii, probably visiting the families in every couple of months. 
    Taking steps back at the moment I DO want it but not with all the drama. I think if we do this VR, its best to keep it small and quiet.
  • edited December 2011
    Hi I am in the middle off planning a VR for May and I have to know or any ideas of doing it on a bugdet. I want to keep it small and just have close family and friends. But not sure how to fo this. Any ideas for me?
  • edited December 2011
    You've gotten some great advice.  Weddings/ vow renewals/ child rearing-- everybody is going to have lots of advice and critique, all in the name of being helpful.  Learn to nicely but firmly say, "thank you for your insight, we will consider that and then make our decision."   Then change the subject.  Just curious-  how long have you been married?  Because you referred to the man who I would call your husband as your fiance.  :)   ~Donna
  • edited December 2011

    Sorry, when I had typed the first paragraph it was kind of a rushed thing so I must have accidently referred to him as that ( I usually refer to him as my husband )We have been technically married for about one year but have spent seven years together and next year's anniversary will be our 8th.

    I really do appreciate the advice given and I think I am keeping the list as short as possible that way things are intimate and we can center our attention towards showing our family around the state as well as keeping things hassle free.

  • flwrchld65flwrchld65 member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011
    How about a simple vow renewal on a cruise ship??? That's what my husband and I are doing for our 25th! Just the two of us...no drama!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards