Just Engaged and Proposals

He's asked my dad, but not me.

At the beginning of December, my boyfriend of 3 years asked my father for my hand. How do I know this? Because my dad told my mother and she can't keep secrets. She told me the day after he asked. We've talked about marriage for a long time, but he's a bit skiddish about the whole idea because he was married before and it didn't work out. I haven't told him that I know he asked my father, because I don't want to ruin this moment. However, it does sting a bit that he hasn't asked yet (and as you can see, I'm on here, ready to get to planning!). It doesn't help that my mother calls me about every other day to see if he's asked yet, and when I tell her no, she tells me how it's my fault and I'm giving him second thoughts: I'm not nice enough to him, I'm not a good enough housekeeper, I'm too close to a friend of mine and maybe he's worried I'm actually a lesbian... just to sound off a bit of the nicer things she's had to say. It's gotten to the point that I don't answer when she calls, and when I do tell her off about it, she says she's "just trying to help". UGH!

I want to talk to him about these things because I'm really starting to feel just horrible about it. But at the same time, I don't want to ruin that moment when he does ask. I shouldn't even know that he's talked to my dad but, thanks to my mother, the cat's out of the bag. Every day I kind of feel let down that it's not the day. Yesterday was hard because I thought for sure it would happen that day, but we never wound up going out or doing anything. It just... bugs me.

So I guess I'm asking, how would you deal with this if you were in my shoes? I feel a little dumb for asking, but I just want to talk to someone about it who won't accuse me of being a horrible person! Smile

Re: He's asked my dad, but not me.

  • If he's asked your father, unless he's playing some sick and twisted kind of mind game, that took guts and I'm sure your boyfriend has the intention to propose.  Perhaps he wanted to get your father's blessing before he went through the trouble of shopping for a ring and setting up a romantic moment for you?  In any case I wouldn't let your boyfriend know you were on to him or even say anything to your friends because if he's like my fiance he wants it to be a surprise and he would be hurt if he thought you knew it was coming.
    Whoever said it was supposed to be happily ever after is a big fat liar.
  • You are absolutely NOT a horrible person... so please stop thinking that. I understand that you may be feeling confused and anxious because you know he's thinking about asking but hasn't yet, just rest assured that everything happens in it's own way. 

    The real question you should be asking yourself is not "why isn't he asking?" or "why did he ask my Dad and not me?" That isn't your issue at all. This has nothing to do with you or your FI... this is really about how to deal with your Mother. In all honesty, I don't have a mother like yours so I can't understand why anyone would say such things to their own daughter, or why harping on an impending issue is such a priority. But I think that you need to spend some time, face to face, with your Mom and ask her to put herself in your shoes... Just ask her to hear you out, and tell her how much she's ruining this for you... because essentially SHE is the one ruining this for you. Tell her that you love her and that you want to share all your excitement with her once it happens but that it's hurting you to be bombarded and berated in the meantime. Tell her flat out that she is not helping you... but rather she is hurting you. Show her some emotion and if she can't see past her own nose and understand that you need her to be supportive and loving then maybe you should shut her out a little... but I don't think it will be necessary. Usually once a Mother sees her child hurting or upset they realize that it's not about themselves but rather about the well being and feelings of that child they love so much. Sometimes overbearing smothering is the only way they know how to act, thinking they are helping or loving... when really they are creating the dynamic they fear most. 

    Is this making sense? I hope so... And please understand that I am in no way telling you to be rude to her or cut her off. What I'm saying is that my best advice is to communicate fully, even if you've never this before... do it. Communication is always worth it and usually not as painful as you may think. This could also lead to a better understanding between you two that could be really beneficial in the future. Best of luck... Love & Light :)

    Anniversary
  • Just let him do it in his time. Do not tell him , it will possibly put pressure on him. Did you see Bride wars when Kate hudson's character found the ring ? It was terrible for her ! I understand I really do, my MOH accidentally told me the my FI had the ring and it was just plaine torture until last week.

    I had finally broken down in November and told him that I knew, and that just made it worse for him becaue he felt under pressure to do something special to begin with. He finally wound up doing it in his own way and it was really kinda funny how it happend ... So just let him do it on his own time...

    As for your mother I'd ask her in the nicest possible way to stop asking you about it because you will obviously let her know when it happens. Tell her you are going crazy enough waiting and that having her give you doubts is not helping.

    Be patient  !
    Love is All You Need
  • Thanks Ladies! I haven't talked to anyone about this except my mother and, as you can see, that hasn't been the most helpful situation at calming my worries! Thank you for the reality check! HAHA!
  • It seems he wouldn't ask your father if he wasn't serious. Don't listen to your mom. There could be any number of reasons he hasn't asked you yet: maybe he has something planned on a specific date to ask, maybe he wants to save up some more money before purchasing the ring, maybe the ring isn't complete yet. Just try to relax.

    imageDaisypath Anniversary tickers
  • Don't be the girl who pushes him in to it when it's not on his own terms.  Maybe he's trying to think of a good way to do it.  Maybe he asked your dad, then went to pick out a ring and hasn't found one, or has ordered one and it's on layaway or something.  To be completely honest with you, if you were engaged yesterday (which I think is one of the cheesiest things, next to Christmas and NYE) you would be in a rush to plan for this year anyway, so let him do it when he's ready and maybe look forward to planning a 2013 wedding. 
    Photobucket
    Follow Me on Pinterest
    Just because you saw it on Four Weddings, doesn't mean it's a good idea.
  • I was never wanting to push him into anything he's not ready for yet. I was just looking for a way to calm my nerves and I didn't want to talk to someone we both know. Being able to say it "out loud" has been very helpful. And I agree, holidays are super cheesy- but it's the only "obvious" day I could think of. You know what I mean? I want to just put it out of my mind completely and part of that is being more firm with my mother to drop it.
  • If it helps, my fiance asked my dad many months before he proposed. He had a certain date in mind and wanted to wait to take me on a weekend trip when we both had time to take off work.

    Try talking to your mom about how the things she has said made you feel down.

    Cheer up!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • When we did get engaged i found out he had bought a ring back in july (we got engaged in december) but i mentioned my all time favorite look & he took it back (i did not know he bought it). I only wear real gold, i am allergic to everything else, i can't handle metals & he bought a white gold ring. 

    When the time came i was expecting it because we went to the jewelry store the week before & i showed him a ring & he picked one out that was almost the same but even nicer. 

    Let him do it on his own time, it is a lot of pressure to be done just right. 
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Dream Honeymoon/Actual Honeymoon Disneyworld Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • There is no way a man is going to ask his girlfriend's father with no intention of actually doing it. That's a scary thing to do for a guy.
    Just chill out and more importantly, tell your mother to chill out.
    And shame on her for ruining what was supposed to be his surprise for you. Now she has spoiled what he is probably planning to do and thinks it is a complete surprise.
    Whatever you do, NEVER tell him that you knew ahead of time.
  • Danny&Mel2003Danny&Mel2003 member
    1000 Comments First Anniversary
    edited February 2012
    I found out Fi asked my dad Aug 2010 but he waited until our vacation in May 2011 to actually propose .... I had no idea my dad kept it a great secret I never thought he would be able to but I had no idea a proposal was coming. You already know its coming my only suggestion not to expect let him do it when he feels the time is right.
  • I waited 1.5 years for my FI to ask me..Just wait for him to ask.. I agree with PPs that he may have a specific date in mind, and he wants to surprise you so let him!! :)
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Like PP said, just wait. My FI had a ring for 2 months before he proposed. It almost killed me. I was such a miserable person because I was paranoid that there was something wrong in our relationship, he didn't love me anymore, he lied & doesn't really have a ring, he changed his mind...I was a mess. 

    Turns out it was none of those things. Try your best to not think about it, even though it is wicked hard. You will be better off in the end.
  • I think that after the glow of the question popping wears off that your BF should know what happened just so he gets some insight into his future in-laws and how they behave so that he can avoid a similar torture session on your behalf in the future. I'm also in similar shoes (waiting for the ring), but we have more dialog about it. I know it's coming (before Easter) and we have even started some wedding planning. Hang in there.
    image
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_just-engaged-proposals_hes-asked-my-dad-but-not-me?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:683Discussion:afa0dd3f-67eb-48fc-8fc4-7dca574ec82ePost:c851e485-405e-4091-8f88-7cebcef0a7c9">Re: He's asked my dad, but not me.</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re: He's asked my dad, but not me. : DO NOT tell him. That is the worst advice possible. Why would you want to ruin it for him *and* pit him against his FMIL? He would be crushed if he found out you'd known all this time.
    Posted by burntofferings[/QUOTE]

    Because you are starting a life together with someone and they need to know the truth instead of being coddled like babies.  If he is going to be crushed about something like this then he shouldn't have waited SO LONG to pop the question in the first place.  It's not about pitting him against his FMIL, it's about him learning about how she opperates so that he can learn to manage his interactions with the FMIL to help his future wife. 
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards