this is the code for the render ad
African American Weddings

Taboo??

     Had a few questions and I'd love to get your opinions on them. I plan on writing a blog post on this subject but I was curious to get others take on this.


It's a beautiful thing when your man surprises you with a ring and a proposal. He painstakingly selects a ring for you (or even asks for you to select it yourself). He purchases the ring on his own time and goes through the anxiety filled task of constructing the perfect mood to pop the big question- but what if that doesn't happen?

Say you and your man have been together for years, and it is more of a declaration of love, wrapped within a meaningful conversation. If you get to the point of discussing marriage and agree upon it my first question is: Would you feel a bit upset that, even though you're marrying the love of your life, you didn't get an "official" proposal?

Next up is, what if you're going through hard times- say your man is inbetween work when this conversation occurs. Say you can get past not having an actual proposal if you could just have an engagement ring- but he doesn't have the funds. Could you see yourself giving him the money to purchase the ring for you, as long as, you didn't know when, and allowed him to have full control over selecting the ring and presenting it to you?

My last question is- If you were to get this engagement ring after putting your own money into it (but his thoughtfulness on selecting the ring for you) would you expect a "formal" proposal (or at the very least, him pouring out his soul as he presented the ring to you?)

I'm asking because there was an article on The Shine asking if women would accept a proposal without a ring. There were alot of interesting answers, so I decided to put a slight spin on the question to see what you would do in such a situation. So I guess THAT is the last question lol, WOULD YOU ACCEPT A PROPOSAL WITHOUT A RING?

Re: Taboo??

  • edited December 2011
    I would like to say that I would accept a proposal without a ring and honestly, I think I really would. However, I do think that I would always have a longing for what could have been. Human nature maybe? Also, to answer your other questions...I could have done without the public profession of love that makes up many proposals (my own, included although I loved every minute of it) because I always pictured a private proposal. I don't think I would buy the ring...if money was that tight for him, I'd do without the ring and just prepare for wedding bands. The ring is at the end of the day, just material.
    AAW June Siggy Challenge
    My Daddy and Me Image and video hosting by TinyPic Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • 7venAfricano7venAfricano member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/cultural-wedding-boards_african-american-weddings_taboo?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Cultural Wedding BoardsForum:400Discussion:88f23bfc-4be9-4237-862d-96ddb794cda5Post:f863b39d-9a72-44f6-9344-13b90b75535e">Re: Taboo??</a>:
    [QUOTE]I would like to say that I would accept a proposal without a ring and honestly, I think I really would. However, I do think that I would always have a longing for what could have been. Human nature maybe? Also, to answer your other questions...I could have done without the public profession of love that makes up many proposals (my own, included although I loved every minute of it) because I always pictured a private proposal. <strong>I don't think I would buy the ring...if money was that tight for him, I'd do without the ring and just prepare for wedding bands. <u>The ring is at the end of the day, just material.</u></strong>
    Posted by eagles347[/QUOTE]


    I like that.
  • edited December 2011
    Wow deep topic tonight! Well lemme clear some stuff off my chest.. *ladies go and get a chair, a drank and a blanket*

    When FI proposed to me, I was recovering from surgery. He didnt have my ring and I could have cared less because I knew that what his heart was telling me... so a few weeks later, we go to the greek picnic in philly (ol skool only) and he tells everyone that i said yes to his proposal. Well his one snake faced frat brother kept asking about the ring since he didnt see i had one on. So this lazy baby daddy goes and tells everyone that its a freakin lie... Girl do you know that i tore his a$$ up like it was paper.... Fi and his pop (who is in the same frathouse) knew not to say a word or jump in the fight. After taking his manhood from him in front of his flavor of the week chick, i let him know that i didnt care about the freaking ring cuz i got something better, my man's heart and to kiss your sorry butt...

    Fi felt bad because he was waiting for my ring to come since it was ordered and i didnt know about it. From that day my baby knows i got him and vice versa.  Hell i told my dad that he could go go  hades in a handbasket....

    yeah some women see it as a way to show that he can take care of you but damn love dont buy happiness... I knew he could take care of me when he was at every surgery and was holding my hair back while i threw up my food.. $hit he even put my pad in my undies... Now when you find a man like that, he's a keeper...
    Anniversary
  • edited December 2011
    @ Rodeo - That's deep girl. You do have a good one...and so does he. Love it.
    AAW June Siggy Challenge
    My Daddy and Me Image and video hosting by TinyPic Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • tyboydtyboyd member
    Eighth Anniversary 2500 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/cultural-wedding-boards_african-american-weddings_taboo?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Cultural%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:400Discussion:88f23bfc-4be9-4237-862d-96ddb794cda5Post:5ad5cb98-637f-449c-80a2-3baec4c9a425">Re: Taboo??</a>:
    [QUOTE]@ Rodeo - That's deep girl. You do have a good one...and so does he. Love it.
    Posted by eagles347[/QUOTE]

    <div>THIS!!!

    I can also say that FI and I were "engaged" without me having my ring and I was okay with that. It didn't make us any less engaged or love each other any less. But I can say I was hella happy when I did get my "official" proposal. {Now, I need to go back so I can see the rest of the questions.}
    </div>
  • sheshedukeshesheduke member
    2500 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    @ Rodeo that is too funny. Love that kind of love you guys rock!
  • sheshedukeshesheduke member
    2500 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    I agree that it is material. FI said that he wanted to propose several times but he did not want to do it without a ring. He said after everything that we have been through I deserved it and so much more. He said by no means is it the best ring but it is just a token of what I mean to him and the start of many great things to come.

    I love this man more than words can ever say. LOVE HIM
  • tyboydtyboyd member
    Eighth Anniversary 2500 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
    Would you feel a bit upset that, even though you're marrying the love of your life, you didn't get an "official" proposal?
    I wouldn't be mad at that... as long as I get an official wedding.

    Could you see yourself giving him the money to purchase the ring for you, as long as, you didn't know when, and allowed him to have full control over selecting the ring and presenting it to you?
    Nope, couldn't see myself doing that. Why give him the money to go buy my ring? Why couldn't I just go pick it up myself... that's pretty much the same to me. Like... do I get my money back or am I paying for both my ring and his? Nah!

    If you were to get this engagement ring after putting your own money into it (but his thoughtfulness on selecting the ring for you) would you expect a "formal" proposal (or at the very least, him pouring out his soul as he presented the ring to you?) 
    Hell yes. If I gotta by a ring the least he can do is drop to one knee or something.

    WOULD YOU ACCEPT A PROPOSAL WITHOUT A RING?
    Been there, done that.

  • 7venAfricano7venAfricano member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/cultural-wedding-boards_african-american-weddings_taboo?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Cultural Wedding BoardsForum:400Discussion:88f23bfc-4be9-4237-862d-96ddb794cda5Post:9aaa1ac4-06b2-4f4e-8136-d3d5a4266c8d">Re: Taboo??</a>:
    [QUOTE]Would you feel a bit upset that, even though you're marrying the love of your life, you didn't get an "official" proposal? I wouldn't be mad at that... as long as I get an official wedding. Could you see yourself giving him the money to purchase the ring for you, as long as, you didn't know when, and allowed him to have full control over selecting the ring and presenting it to you? Nope, couldn't see myself doing that. <strong>Why give him the money to go buy my ring? Why couldn't I just go pick it up myself... that's pretty much the same to me. Like... do I get my money back</strong> or am I paying for both my ring and his? Nah! If you were to get this engagement ring after putting your own money into it (but his thoughtfulness on selecting the ring for you) would you expect a "formal" proposal (or at the very least, him pouring out his soul as he presented the ring to you?)   <strong>Hell yes. If I gotta by a ring the least he can do is drop to one knee or something.</strong> WOULD YOU ACCEPT A PROPOSAL WITHOUT A RING? Been there, done that.
    Posted by tyboyd[/QUOTE]

    LMBO!! Oh my gosh, girl you had me over here crackin up!


    @rodeo- girl, you had me rollin but that's some deep stuff. "Shorty, he a 10!" lol
  • tyboydtyboyd member
    Eighth Anniversary 2500 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited December 2011
  • edited December 2011
    I really REALLY think some women/girls get all caught up on the whole ring deal.... what good is it if he hits you and treats you like dirt? A proposal is only an official proposal if he is asking from the heart. Now if your man is on hard times, then skip the ring.. My mom didnt get one because my dad had two children to raise and she could understand that but best believe on their 5th anniversary he popped a big rock on her hand to show that she was worth it. That thing w(j/k)

    SN- ever since that throwdown, that little boy has shown me mad respect and love since he knows i'll knock him out again then let FI tear him a new one..
    Anniversary
  • edited December 2011
    I can also say that me and my FI were engaged without a ring as well and I was perfectly fine with that because I know the love we share is genuine and real. Just because I didn't have a ring did not change the way we feel for each other. I've had a few "friends" have their little smart comments about me not having a ring but I put them in their place quick and many of them aren't in my current circle of friends. What's a ring if you are in a unhealthy relationship in which a have a friend that is in that situation now and she was one of the ones with so much to say about me and my FI. But, all in all at the end of the day I have his heart and he has mine, and the price tag for that is PRICELESS!!
    Graphics Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • 7venAfricano7venAfricano member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/cultural-wedding-boards_african-american-weddings_taboo?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Cultural Wedding BoardsForum:400Discussion:88f23bfc-4be9-4237-862d-96ddb794cda5Post:9c5edb74-36c8-4ff8-a8aa-e7b43e7143ce">Re: Taboo??</a>:
    [QUOTE]I can also say that me and my FI were engaged without a ring as well and I was perfectly fine with that because I know the love we share is genuine and real. Just because I didn't have a ring did not change the way we feel for each other. I've had a few "friends" have their little smart comments about me not having a ring but I put them in their place quick and many of them aren't in my current circle of friends. <strong>What's a ring if you are in a unhealthy relationship</strong> in which a have a friend that is in that situation now and she was one of the ones with so much to say about me and my FI. But, all in all at the end of the day <strong>I have his heart and he has mine, and the price tag for that is PRICELESS!!
    </strong>Posted by meeko84[/QUOTE]


    This is some truth right here. I now a chick who had her man put her in ICU, always putting his hands on her, yet when he proposed, she said yes. Craziest thing in the world to me, and what's worst is they have 3 or 4 kids together.

    I agree, if you know what you have is real, it doesn't matter if you have that ring or not- what you have with your man shouldn't need to be measured with the material (but let's not get it twisted, the ring is still nice to have if you can get it <img src="http://cdn.cl9.vanillaforums.com/downloaded/ver1.0/content/scripts/tinymce/plugins/emotions/images/smiley-cool.gif" border="0" alt="Cool" title="Cool" />) But yea, love will keep on truckin regardless.. Love all the replies
  • sadou02sadou02 member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Would you feel a bit upset that, even though you're marrying the love of your life, you didn't get an "official" proposal? I didnt get one of those special formal proposals.  FI and I were crying because it was the day before he left and he was telling me how much he loved my family and me and the proposal just came out at that time.

     Could you see yourself giving him the money to purchase the ring for you, as long as, you didn't know when, and allowed him to have full control over selecting the ring and presenting it to you? This is somewhat me.  I put in a portion for my ring but he paid for a majority of it.  A long story behind it but I don't feel bad about it at all.  I was still just as happy to have my simple ring and I consider it as him buying it regardless. 

     If you were to get this engagement ring after putting your own money into it (but his thoughtfulness on selecting the ring for you) would you expect a "formal" proposal (or at the very least, him pouring out his soul as he presented the ring to you?)  I wouldn't expect it but he did it when he officially put the ring on my finger. 

    WOULD YOU ACCEPT A PROPOSAL WITHOUT A RING? DId it and just as happy. 
    image139 Made the list!
    image 107 Are ready to party!
    image 32 Will be missing out!
    image 0 Are getting on my nerves!
  • edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/cultural-wedding-boards_african-american-weddings_taboo?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Cultural%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:400Discussion:88f23bfc-4be9-4237-862d-96ddb794cda5Post:6ffa803a-7bc9-42bd-9f07-faf002f45d93">Re: Taboo??</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re: Taboo?? : This is some truth right here. I now a chick who had her man put her in ICU, always putting his hands on her, yet when he proposed, she said yes. Craziest thing in the world to me, and what's worst is they have 3 or 4 kids together. I agree, if you know what you have is real, it doesn't matter if you have that ring or not- what you have with your man shouldn't need to be measured with the material (but let's not get it twisted, the ring is still nice to have if you can get it ) But yea, love will keep on truckin regardless.. Love all the replies
    Posted by 7venAfricano[/QUOTE]
    WTH is wrong with these woman that put up with that nonsense and then to make it worse they bring children into the picture. Girl, I could talk about my friend and her unhealthy relationship all day. It just makes me so sad about the things she goes through and when I voice my opinion her first response is that I'm being her counselor and not her friend, it's gotten to the point I don't even want to talk to her sometimes. She has a child with him as well and he has  threated to take her child if she ever leaves him....where's the love in that? He is dictating every detail of their wedding and she has not input at all. And to top it off she tells me she's still in love with her ex. Craziness!!! It's just one big sad case. And yes the ring was very very nice once I got it <img src="http://cdn.cl9.vanillaforums.com/downloaded/ver1.0/content/scripts/tinymce/plugins/emotions/images/smiley-smile.gif" border="0" alt="Smile" title="Smile" />
    Graphics Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    Would you feel a bit upset that, even though you're marrying the love of your life, you didn't get an "official" proposal?

    nope.  this is how DH and I  became engaged.  lying in bed, we both woke up.  he asked me would i marry him.  i said yes.  no fancy stuff, no frills.  so we got engaged in our drawls!  LOL

    Could you see yourself giving him the money to purchase the ring for you, as long as, you didn't know when, and allowed him to have full control over selecting the ring and presenting it to you?

    no. 

    If you were to get this engagement ring after putting your own money into it (but his thoughtfulness on selecting the ring for you) would you expect a "formal" proposal (or at the very least, him pouring out his soul as he presented the ring to you?

    nope.  i didn't need anything formal.  i didn't need him getting down on one knee.  a proposal story wan't important to me.  DH showed me everyday before we got married how he felt about me.  and that was more important than a formal proposal.

    WOULD YOU ACCEPT A PROPOSAL WITHOUT A RING?

    yes.  i did.  we were engaged three years without a ring.  it didn't bother me. 

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards