this is the code for the render ad
Moms and Maids

Having trouble with my parents - What would you do?

Hello everyone! I'm relatively new to these boards, but I've been reading along and was hoping for a little input on what is turning into a pretty awful situation for my wedding. 

I've been engaged a few months and the plan from the beginning (before I was engaged even!) was a simple, family only wedding at the cottage. No more than 25 people - cheap and cheerful style.  My parents were initially thrilled and offered to pay for the wedding (giving me a very generous budget).  I started planning my August 25th 2012 wedding almost immediately. 

A few weeks into planning, my parents decided that they didn't want us at the cottage for the wedding. They decided it was too many people to host for the day and they'd prefer we go somewhere else - they contacted a few of the resorts in the area for us and pointed us toward a few places with great wedding packages.  I wasn't thrilled since I'd had my heart set on the cottage, but it's their property and they're footing the bill - so I went with it and started planning again.

I selected the venue, started shopping for vendors and decorations with my parents blessing. I was starting to feel like everything was coming together (Again). This saturday, they pulled the rug out from under me (again!) and decided that my vision didn't match what they had wanted and they want me to change the plans ... and they're going to revise the budget because they feel that the type of wedding I was planning doesn't justify the cost and they want to be more involved in the planning process (after they spent about 4 hours berating me for my decisions while I cried, and basically told me that I had no idea what the hell I'm doing).

Obviously, the plan moving forward is to thank them for their very generous offer, let them know I'll be paying for the wedding myself and I'll let em know where and when I'm having it but it's not up for discussion anymore and start planning again - for the third (and final) time.

The only problem with this is that with all the false starts and upset, the thought of having my small cottage style wedding (with my parents sighing, judging and fighting the whole way) is making me sick to my stomach. It's been so incredibly stressful that I'm done with it. I want a stress free, destination wedding and if I'm prefectly honest - that's all I can afford on my own anyway.  Unfortunately, if I have a destination wedding it's pretty likely that my parents won't be able to attend. My dad has some health issues that might prevent him from being able to aqcuire travellers health insurance. I hate the idea of them not being there.

This is completely out of character for them. They're usually very supportive and helpful. I would have never imagined that a wedding would make them become completely unglued like this. It's kind of devestating.

So, I guess this is the long way of asking what you would do in my shoes:
*I would be paying for options 1, 2 or 3 myself.  Option 4 would make them very happy, but it's not my style and I don't want it at all.

1) Have the wedding you want with the risk that your family might not be able to make it?

2) Find a way to have a very small, close to home wedding knowing that your family will be there... even if they're grumbling and fighting the whole way?

3) Say to hell with the whole thing and elope?

4) Say to hell with the whole thing and let them throw the 200 person, huge venue wedding that they want and can brag to all of their friends about?

Would you do something else entirely?

Sorry for the novel. I guess it's a longer story than I though.


Re: Having trouble with my parents - What would you do?

  • I'm sorry they're causing you such stress. 

    Only you can decide if you're ok with any option that doesn't have your family there...  What about your FI's family?  Would they be able to travel to a DW?
    image
  • Thanks for responding Girlie1030 - I should have mentioned that my FI's family is happy with whatever makes us happy. 

    My FI is a little shell shocked by the encounter with my parents (as I mentioned, this is truly out of character for them - he was not expecting an ambush) and is leaving the decision entirely up to me.  I know he'd definitely prefer the destination wedding, but couldn't live with asking me to have a wedding that my parents might not be a part of.
  • edited February 2012
    I feel like there's a fifth option you haven't considered yet, like your 2nd option with some revisions:

    Do the small wedding that you wanted originally in your home town and then DO NOT (I can't stress that enough), do not tell them any of the plans. They can find out the date/ time/ place at the same point as everyone else; when they get the invite and the rest of details at the wedding.

    If they try to talk to you about it, change the subject. If they push it firmly tell them you don't want to discuss it. If they get mean calmly tell them you won't be talked to like that and if they continue you will hang up the phone/ leave. The hang up/ leave if they keep on. They'll get the hint eventually and stop trying to talk about it with you.

    As an aside, is there a chance something else is going down? I remember reading a post on here a while back about a girl whose parents started acting really out of character while she was planning her wedding. Turns out her parents were planning to get a divorce and didn't want to tell her until after the wedding. Not that I'm saying your parents are getting divorced or anything, but maybe there's something else behind all this.
  • I am sorry that they are being so wishy washy with you. I can't imagine how bad it would feel to have to start for a third time. I think that you are making the right decision to decline their offers. If they are planning a wedding that you do not want to have, then by all means plan what you feel is right in your heart.

    I do not understand why they couldn't go to the DW-- why do they need insurance to travel? Can they not leave without it?

    I agree with pp that only you can decide what is right. Deep inside would you regret them not being at your wedding?
    Photobucket
  • Can you rent a cottage and have the original wedding you wanted?
  • If this is really out of character for them, do you think you can take a week or two to sit on it, and then have a discussion with them about why they insist on the changes, and that you really want your small wedding, and asking for so many changes this close isn't an option. 

    Then let them know you are going to start planning (again!) the wedding the way you & FI want it, and if they want to be involved, you expect their full support, or else you just won't involve them. I would just stress to them that while you appreciate their financial support, you would much rather plan the day as the two of you had always dreamed, not the way your parents did, so you will go ahead and plan on paying for it yourself.

    I guess my hope is that they might need some cool down time to realize they lost sight of what the day is truly about!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I would sit them down and have a major talk with them about why this is making you so unhappy.  Something like:

    "Mom, Dad, I was so thankful that you were excited about our original plans and offered to pay, believe me, we appreciate it more than I can say.  But this is becoming the wedding that you want, not the wedding that FI and I want, and I feel we'd regret going forward with your plans as it's not true to ourselves.  It also hurts that you are completely disregarding our wishes for OUR wedding and planning something that you'd be happy showing off to your friends, this is not something I would have ever expected you to do as you've always been supportive of our decisions in the past. 

    So if having the wedding WE want means giving up your generous offer, we are prepared to do that.  But the wedding we can afford would most likely be in a destination that you can't attend, which I don't want to do.  We are considering other options as well, but the one thing we absolutely are not comfortable with is having this lavish affair that you are currently planning, so either way, I wanted to let you know that we will not be doing that and that you might as well give up on those plans now.  It would be great if you could just be happy with what we want, but if you can't, then we will let you know the location of where we ultimately decide to get married and hope that you can attend and be happy for us."

    Maybe they'll realize that they've uncharacteristically taken over your wedding and might reign in their plans and at the very least, compromise on something while still paying for it.  If not, at least they'd know why you are turning down their money and planning whatever you can that makes you happy.

    Good luck, I'm really sorry you are having to deal with this.
    Anniversary
  • Don't go for the wedding they want. If their behaviour is really as much out of character, they probably will come around and they won't spoil your day by fighting and making drama, even if you make it a 25-person cottage style wedding. If that is what you wanted all along, I'd go for that.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • 1) Have the wedding you want with the risk that your family might not be able to make it? does "the wedding you want" include your parents being there?  For me it did; if my parents or grandparents or brother wouldn't have been able to attend for some reason I would have changed my plans to accomodate them, because them BEING there was a huge part of what I wanted.  You need to think about whether it's important to you or not.  Also, you could do a DW without leaving the country (FL, CA, etc) so your father wouldn't need travel health insurance.

    2) Find a way to have a very small, close to home wedding knowing that your family will be there... even if they're grumbling and fighting the whole way? if they're grumbling and fighting you just don't talk wedding with them. 

    3) Say to hell with the whole thing and elope? this again is completely dependent on what you really want.  Do you want your family and friends there? if so this isn't really an option.  If not, go for it.

    4) Say to hell with the whole thing and let them throw the 200 person, huge venue wedding that they want and can brag to all of their friends about? I wouldn't do this - you'll still end up responsible for a lot of the planning and planning a wedding you don't want will be nothing but stress.


    I just have to add, I'm always a little confused when people say they can afford a DW more than they could afford something local - you still have to host any/all guests at a DW.  In fact, the thought regarding the appropriate level of hosting usually increases from "cake and punch is okay" to two or three meals since they're going to such trouble for you.  I assume the 'cost savings' is because very few people actually attend, but you only want to have 25 people in the first place - I just can't see it being cheaper to travel...
  • Thank you all for responding, you've all given me a lot to think about moving forward.  I haven't spoken to my parents about this yet, I'm waiting until I can have the conversation as kindly as Jemmini6 posted. I just want to be able to have this coversation once, do it properly and then stop talking about the wedding with them all together.

    To answer a few of the questions - a DW doesn't mean they absolutely can't come. It's just a strong possibility that I need to consider. The health insurance is important because my dad's health problems stem from accute pancreatitis attacks that can come on without warning (and have caused some other problems).  One attack nearly killed him and put him in the hospital for about 4 months in serious condition (a LONG time ago - he's healthy now). The odds of it happening again are almost nothing, but he certainly wouldn't travel without insurance in case it did.


    Chrryblndchk - There's a lot going on with them (not a divorce but we've all had a bad year), that's part of the reason I'm trying not to completely lose my cool over this.  Unfortuantely, I don't see their attitudes changing any time soon.

    A destination wedding is more affordable for us because it eliminates most of the cost of the honeymoon. Tacking an extra week onto a week onto a resort we're already staying at is not expensive and leaves a lot more in the budget to host a proper wedding.

    A destination wedding without leaving the country is an idea that I hadn't really considered. I'm a Canadian in Toronto so there are fewer interesting domestic cities, but I know that Montreal would be a huge hit with my French Canadian future in laws!

    Thanks again everyone. I'll pop in and give an update if I get the nerve to sort this out with my parents before this thread falls off the first page. For those of you that think this might blow over if I give it some time, I hope you're right.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards