So, here are two of the ways we personalized our wedding.
Guest gift bags (everyone was from out-of-town)...we had the hotels put them in the rooms so they'd be waiting for our guests:
The bags are from Oriental Trading, and I ordered the stamp from Etsy (Sand Shooters was the store). We put chips, PB crackers, trail mix, lifesavers, 4th of July tootsie rolls, a welcome letter, and a map of Freeport in each bag.
Menus for our dinner stations and dessert buffet. (I don't have a photo of the finished product, but we touched up the paint a little and of course took off the masking tape.)