this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Etiquette Forum

Could Use Stranger friendships right now.

Hi everyone,

Having an exceptionally emotional day.  Please, I know its long, dont hate me. Back story: My biological father "disappeared" from our lives when I was 9 yrs old. My mother had told my siblings that we had passed away but I knew the truth (so I thought). When I was in my thirties my step father passed away and my father emailed giving him his condolences. As a result, we had a phone "relationship" for about a year before he came to visit and meet with all of my siblings. He explained the REAL reason he was not in our lives. They all eventually understood. Me...I understood his truths but was devastated. I had lived all those years thinking he was gone because he molested me but that wasnt the truth. In time, I fell in love with him. Actually, it may be hard to understand but I never stopped loving him.

After he returned home about a yr later, the communication just stopped! I had managed to forgive him for molesting me and he just threw me away. Again.

9 years passed before I heard from him again, last May. He told me that he thought he was sick and had more tests to take. I eventually asked him if he was afraid, anticipating he would say no (he was a tough guy) he said yes. Explained he wasnt ready to die because he needed to make things right with his children. My heart cracked open. I was so mad and confused! He was dying! Son of a bitch called me just to leave me again, but for good! I pushed through my selfish feelings. We maintained phone contact and I planned on visiting in July. As I was packing my car up (Saturday) to go see him, I received a surprising call that he was admitted to hospice. (the Wednesday prior he was given 3-6 months). He couldnt speak and was in a "coma." The phone was put up to his ear and I told him I was on my way and to hang on. When I told him that I loved him and that he was a good man, he let out a very loud, high pitched moan. It scared the hell out of me. He did this 2 more times as I told him that I loved him. I was later told that he opened his eyes and tears streamed down his face.

My father passed an hour later. I will never know what he was trying to say to me. Nobody could make it out (room full of relatives). Apparently everyone was shocked that he responded. That fact that he did respond to me, I hold so tight. I have to believe that he responded because he loved me. There was no funeral for him and his ashes remain unclaimed. To think of my father brings such heartache. Pain I cant describe, other then to say its very physical...my heart hurts.

Now, here I am planning my wedding. I cried thinking about my dad (nobody knows this) during my 1st wedding dance 28 yrs ago. All I ever wanted was that dance with my dad...not money, clothes, shoes etc. just a dance. I told him this and I thought we would have our dance but now hes gone. Ive asked my Uncle to dance with me because he has been a constant in my life...my whole life. Needless to say, it has been extremely difficult trying to find a song and not think of my dad during the process.

I found the song. First let me say, that I really want to do this dance, deep down, but I am so afraid. I don't want to feel feelings about my father. Im thinking about avoiding it all together. It seems its the only way but Im struggling because I do want to honor my Uncle in this way. The song by Heartland called "I loved her first."  There is a lyric in there that I am caught up on and dont know what to do. I can leave it or my FI can sing the song with a changed lyric and record it. The verse goes:

"But I loved her first and I held her first
And a place in my heart will always be hers
From the first breath she breathed
When she first smiled at me
I knew the love of a father runs deep
And I prayed that she'd find you someday
But it still hard to give her away
I loved her first"

Do you think people will get caught up on "father?" Should we change it to "Uncle?" Does anyone have any advice on how I could process all of this? I wont talk to anyone (friends/family) about it because I dont want all eyes on me (if I do the dance) thinking "poor her." I tend to avoid hurtful situation and end up regretting in the end. Like I said, deep down I want to dance with my Uncle. Besides the one word, the song is absolutely true and perfect. His loved fills me in ways that a healthy fathers love would.










tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif

Re: Could Use Stranger friendships right now.

  • It seems like your uncle was a strong father figure in your life. I don't think anyone would say a thing.  Even if they did, it doesn't matter what anyone thinks. If that song means something to you about your relationship with your uncle, then by all means dance with your uncle and dance to that song.
  • I think it matters how you feel about the lyrics.  Would you and your uncle feel comfortable leaving it as "Father?"  If so, that's all that matters.  Honestly, if anyone at your wedding gets caught up on a single word during what I'm sure will be a beautiful moment, doesn't matter.  Best of luck to you! 
  • If that's the song you want, use it. This is one of the few wedding things that you get 100% say in. I personally wouldn't pick that one for a lot of reasons, but what I think has nothing to do with what's right for you.
  • I personally wouldn't choose that song for several reasons, but if you DO go to change the lyrics?  Do it through your DJ - he should have the electronic expertise to do such a thing.  Have you talked to your uncle?  He may have some ideas too (my dad in particular thinks his sole JOB is to pick out the father/daughter dance song so eh, I'm letting him haha)
    I guess, to tell you the truth, I've never had much of a desire to grow facial hair. I think I've managed to play quarterback just fine without a mustache. - Peyton
  • LAM524LAM524 member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    Thanks everyone. Im better today. Had a good cry last night. Its horrible how emotions just sneak up and take us hostage!
    I personally wouldn't choose that song for several reasons, but if you DO go to change the lyrics?  Do it through your DJ - he should have the electronic expertise to do such a thing.  Have you talked to your uncle?  He may have some ideas too (my dad in particular thinks his sole JOB is to pick out the father/daughter dance song so eh, I'm letting him haha)
    Blue...I had a great experience with my Uncle about the song. When I asked my Uncle to dance with me he was so very moved and proud. Being he has 3 sons, this is his first "dance." :) He grabbed his ipod right away for me to listen to some great oldies. He joked him my FL saying "I loved her first" and I got the chills. He hadnt heard my choice yet! :) I played it for him immediately, and without doubt he said this was the song! Do you think my FI recording the song with changed lyric would be inappropriate?
    Cold hard truth? Most guests really don't care that much about spotlight dances and don't usually pay much attention to them in general. Do what feels right to you in regards to the lyrics.
    Thank you Stage. I love the cold hard truth and was thinking the same thing. My hesitation is that if people do hear "father" (knowing our past) they will be disgusted. Which, honestly, would be their problem. I just dont want a bunch of whispering but I do know that I have no control over. Right now Im not sure what feels right. I have some time to figure my feelings out. Still not sure if I will be brave enough to even have the dance.

    tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif
  • LAM524LAM524 member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    Thanks everyone. Im better today. Had a good cry last night. Its horrible how emotions just sneak up and take us hostage!
    I personally wouldn't choose that song for several reasons, but if you DO go to change the lyrics?  Do it through your DJ - he should have the electronic expertise to do such a thing.  Have you talked to your uncle?  He may have some ideas too (my dad in particular thinks his sole JOB is to pick out the father/daughter dance song so eh, I'm letting him haha)
    Blue...I had a great experience with my Uncle about the song. When I asked my Uncle to dance with me he was so very moved and proud. Being he has 3 sons, this is his first "dance." :) He grabbed his ipod right away for me to listen to some great oldies. He joked him my FL saying "I loved her first" and I got the chills. He hadnt heard my choice yet! :) I played it for him immediately, and without doubt he said this was the song! Do you think my FI recording the song with changed lyric would be inappropriate?
    Cold hard truth? Most guests really don't care that much about spotlight dances and don't usually pay much attention to them in general. Do what feels right to you in regards to the lyrics.
    Thank you Stage. I love the cold hard truth and was thinking the same thing. My hesitation is that if people do hear "father" (knowing our past) they will be disgusted. Which, honestly, would be their problem. I just dont want a bunch of whispering but I do know that I have no control over. Right now Im not sure what feels right. I have some time to figure my feelings out. Still not sure if I will be brave enough to even have the dance.

    tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif
  • LAM524LAM524 member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    I am so sorry your relationship with your father had to have this sad arc. If this song has special meaning to you and you want to use it, by all means do so. I hope you heal in time. The death of a parent is hard enough to deal with even without the complicated and tragic history you and your dad had.
    Thank you cooper...it really was a tragic end. He had a very troubled life. In his career, he infiltrated a family and had to be a sworn witness but ran. Left his job, his family and his life. He was eventually caught, jailed in protective custody and set for the trial. He was never called as witness. The trial was all but 3 seconds (suspicious) and the criminal went free. Later, said criminal big huge "friend" delivered a message thanking my father. My father didnt do it for the criminal, he did it to stay alive and protect his family. My mother divorced him during his time away and all of his children grew up. He never really recovered from his loses. Very sad.

    tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif
  • LAM2228 said:
    My hesitation is that if people do hear "father" (knowing our past) they will be disgusted.

    ???  "our past" with your father or "our past" with your uncle?  I'm totally confused why anyone would think that your uncle being a father-figure in your life would be "disgusted"?
  • LAM524LAM524 member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    @kate1487...Im sorry..my past with my father.

    tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif
  • LAM2228 said:
    @kate1487...Im sorry..my past with my father.

    Gotcha.  Still; clearly you're picking the song to be about your uncle, so I don't think anyone will judge it.  If anything they'll be happy for you that you have a better, more stable father figure in your life.

    Of course if you want to change the lyric go for it; I just don't think anyone will notice/judge.  Enjoy your dance with your uncle!

  • LAM524LAM524 member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    Harry87 said:
    Thanks everyone. Im better today. Had a good cry last night. Its horrible how emotions just sneak up and take us hostage!
    I personally wouldn't choose that song for several reasons, but if you DO go to change the lyrics?  Do it through your DJ - he should have the electronic expertise to do such a thing.  Have you talked to your uncle?  He may have some ideas too (my dad in particular thinks his sole JOB is to pick out the father/daughter dance song so eh, I'm letting him haha)
    Blue...I had a great experience with my Uncle about the song. When I asked my Uncle to dance with me he was so very moved and proud. Being he has 3 sons, this is his first "dance." :) He grabbed his ipod right away for me to listen to some great oldies. He joked him my FL saying "I loved her first" and I got the chills. He hadnt heard my choice yet! :) I played it for him immediately, and without doubt he said this was the song! Do you think my FI recording the song with changed lyric would be inappropriate?
    Cold hard truth? Most guests really don't care that much about spotlight dances and don't usually pay much attention to them in general. Do what feels right to you in regards to the lyrics.
    Thank you Stage. I love the cold hard truth and was thinking the same thing. My hesitation is that if people do hear "father" (knowing our past) they will be disgusted. Which, honestly, would be their problem. I just dont want a bunch of whispering but I do know that I have no control over. Right now Im not sure what feels right. I have some time to figure my feelings out. Still not sure if I will be brave enough to even have the dance.
    If any guests are "disgusted" by the father part, they have a hair trigger response for being upset. Probably have to pull over and have a meltdown on the side of the road if someone cuts them off.
    LMAO!!! True! The funny of what you said is that most of the women in my family, alive or passed dont/didnt drive. There are 9 of us and only 2 of us get behind the wheel. Its one big phobia with the women! Of course, my mother taking out about a dozen mailboxes, or driving into a canal and my grandmother hitting a stopped bus (she thought was moving) may have something to do with their phobias! :)

    tinkerbell gif photo: Tinkerbell stuck in keyhole animated gif Peterpan2_coince9e.gif
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards