Wedding Etiquette Forum

2 weddings for cultural reasons...

BS: One of my besties has been seriously dating her boyfriend for about 2 years now and they're starting to discuss marriage. He's Indian, and is in the country (Canada) going to school. She said that it's very important to him to have a full Indian wedding back home, but she still wants to have one back home for her family who won't be able to go all the way to India. 

So, she knows I lurk on here quite a bit, so she wanted me to ask this question. Would it be considered a PPD if she went to India to have the big 5 day shabang there (apparantly it's really elaborate, quite excited to see it if it goes down!), and then came back to Canada and had a very small, like 25 people or less, wedding in her parents back yard? She has no idea if she would be considered legally married in Canada if the first ceremony/wedding is in India, so that's a factor obviously. I said I had no idea either, but she should at the very least let people know that they had a ceremony/celebration and what not in India, and that THEY consider themselves married even if it might not be legal in our country. That way people know that this isn't the first time down the isle so to speak for either of them. She said that made sense, because she wouldn't want people to feel obligated to spend money on her if it wasn't the real deal (God I love that girl...). Just wanted to know what you guys think.

On a side note, our other friend who was in the car with us, who is also me and FI's roommate, said that was ridiculous and they shouldn't have to tell anyone what they've done, and that it doesn't change anything. I explained the etiquette behind PPD and why they're rude, and she thought it was the married couples perogative to not tell anyone and still reap the benefits. She proceeded to go on about when she gets married (she's not dating anyone), that she will probably do something super private with like 4 people, and then have a PPD after, and she doesn't care what people think. I told her if I found out she was already married and then had a 2nd "wedding", I probably wouldn't come. Why she asks... well because it's fake! You're already  married!! And you lied to everyone saying you weren't, and expected them to still shell out possibly hundreds of dollars to come see your fake wedding. She was very quiet on the way there. But whatever, ain't gonna let that shit slide for nobody. She conceeded later that she understood where I was coming from. 
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: 2 weddings for cultural reasons...

  • kipnuskipnus member
    Knottie Warrior 1000 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    CMGr said:
    A legal marriage in India is recognized by the Canadian government.  Here is a website with information:  http://travel.gc.ca/travelling/documents/marriage-overseas

    Weddings are a super big deal in India, and also in Canada/USA with immigrant families.  I do not think that you should have another wedding ceremony, but she can certainly have a party to celebrate their marriage in Canada with all your family and friends.  Dancing, open bar, toasts to the married couple, all are fine.  No wedding dress, bouquet tossing, bridesmaids, cake cutting ceremony.  This will not be her wedding day.  Etiquette is no different than any other destination wedding.
    This sounds ideal. Wedding in India, party in Canada.
  • I agree with the previous posts!
  • Another vote for CMGr's plan.  I'm actually going to an a similar event in a few months for a couple that had a very small (immediate family only) destination wedding.  I'm super excited to celebrate with them.  I would not be excited to sit through a second ceremony.
    Don't worry guys, I have the Wedding Police AND the Whambulance on speed dial!
  • As long as there is no trickery behind this (as in, the Candian guests know that there was already an Indian wedding) I don't see a problem. I also don't see a problem with a second ceremony, I'm guess the Bride will want to say her vows in her own language (if that is not an option in India) and would maybe want to have someone from her own culture/religion officiate.
  • I wouldn't have a problem with her wearing a western-style wedding gown in Canada if she wanted, or having a wedding cake. I like wedding gowns and cake :)
  • Thanks ladies. She said she understands both sides, but she's on the fence. She said if she were to do another wedding in Canada, it would be because the majority of her family (she has a HUGE family) would not be able to come all the way to India and they really want to see her get married. She said she would tell everyone that they had already had a wedding in India, and it was legal in Canada, so the ceremony/reception she'd have here wouldn't be the real deal, and she would in no way expect people to shell out money for her since it's a second wedding. And she wouldn't consider it her wedding day, she says, just a great way for her family who wouldn't be able to come to India to still get to experience her wedding. 

    Girls got a good head on her shoulders, and I can see where she's coming from. From what she's explained to me, you don't have bridesmaids or almost any of what we see as traditional aspects in an Indian wedding, and she still wants that. In my case, as long as she was upfront with telling me it was a second wedding, I would be more than happy to participate and go to it. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Thanks ladies. She said she understands both sides, but she's on the fence. She said if she were to do another wedding in Canada, it would be because the majority of her family (she has a HUGE family) would not be able to come all the way to India and they really want to see her get married. She said she would tell everyone that they had already had a wedding in India, and it was legal in Canada, so the ceremony/reception she'd have here wouldn't be the real deal, and she would in no way expect people to shell out money for her since it's a second wedding. And she wouldn't consider it her wedding day, she says, just a great way for her family who wouldn't be able to come to India to still get to experience her wedding. 

    Girls got a good head on her shoulders, and I can see where she's coming from. From what she's explained to me, you don't have bridesmaids or almost any of what we see as traditional aspects in an Indian wedding, and she still wants that. In my case, as long as she was upfront with telling me it was a second wedding, I would be more than happy to participate and go to it. 

    My H is Indian.  We got married in the U.S. (though I incorporated the Seven Steps (Indian wedding ritual) into our American wedding to make H's mother happy) and we will have a reception in India in a few months but everyone knows we are married and we will not be doing the 5 day wedding. 

    That said, I wouldn't be mad at someone who was upfront about being married already who wanted to do both cultural weddings. 

  • As far as I'm concerned, there's no need for her to stay small in celebrating her marriage with people who weren't able to travel to India. Personally, I and my fiance live in the UK but will get married in the US, where most of my family live. We don't have the cultural distinction (we're both Jewish), but intend to have a party celebrating our marriage back in the UK. Most of his family will be able to come to the US, but we're expecting most friends (his, mine, and his parents') to attend the party in the UK instead. (We're more than a year out so it's just guesswork for now.)

    We're not doing anything like a ceremony there, but like I said, we don't have cultural differences. I think there would be great ways to make it a renewing ceremony that echoes the white Western wedding so her familly feel they're seeing her married.

    Some thoughts (definitely not proscriptive):

    - "Giving her away" might be odd since they're already married. She and her husband could walk to the ceremony site together - or perhaps come towards each other from opposite directions (flanked by parents to honor them?)?

    - The ceremony could involve a "Jane and John, you have already committed your lives to each other by [insert the appropriate symbolic moment here]. Today we ask you to reaffirm your commitment for all who could not attend." and launch into their vows/ceremony/symbolism of choice.

    - Have photos of the Indian ceremony for everyone to ooh and ahh over (definitely among our plans!)

    Good luck to them both!

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards