this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

Setting the date issues- drama already :( help!

I just recently got engaged and we are trying to set a date for next summer, my fiance is a teacher and it only makes sense for us to have our special day during that time. My best friend and MOH is also my fiances sister. I have looked at several places and have found a reception place I absolutely love and a church near the venue (that is not $2,000 for the ceremony and that will allow us to marry there without being members). There are three saturdays that both the church and venue are available and only one of those days work with my fiance and my schedule. My moh/future sister in law has been dating her boyfriend for almost a year and they are pretty serious. Between the two of them, they have four weddings next summer- one that she is in and three that he is in. Unfortuantely, the date that works for our dream wedding falls on the same date as one of my MOH/future sister in law's boyfriends weddings that he is in. When I told her about the date we are probably going to book, she told me she would be really sad if he had to miss it, he'd be left out in the whole process and that she was pretty upset about it. She also told me that he was taking it personal because I was having my wedding when he can't be there & that if it was someone else in the family it would be a date change, mind you they have been dating for almost a year and I have been with my fiance for over 8 years. When we called him to tell him it wasn't personal and we felt bad about the situation he said he didn't understand why we couldn't change the date. My entire immeadiate family can make the date and so can my fiances. I have look for other churches that will marry us without a steep bill and have come up empty. I also have made a calender with the dates that are available with all of their date conflicts and of all the venues I have found I have one other possible date that does not cause them conflicts and a place that would just be okay to have the reception. Mind you I would have to find a new church as well and check with all my other immeadiate family members that they could make it. The reason why this is so difficult is because its my best friend and also my fiance's sister. I know she will be dissappointed if I pick this date and I feel like all the fun things that I was looking forward to doing with her are not going to be the same because I know she will be upset. I was so happy when I first got engaged and now I am completely miserable and so upset. I feel like our friendship is never going to be the same because there is going to be tension if we move forward with this date and all of the MOH duties will be more upseting for her. I feel so awkward and terrible if I book this date because I know it upsets her. I also feel like if I don't do what I want to do, I will be upset and miss out of having my dream wedding. I know she feels its very important for him to be there but every other family member that is involved has said that I need to book the date with his conflict- that its not fair to us to change for him & that if they feel its so important for him to be there that he will be there. I just don't know what to do and am soooo upset- this should be the best time of my life and I am miserable!

Re: Setting the date issues- drama already :( help!

  • You just have to decide which one you want more, this date/venue/church combination or this guy there.  All of that other stuff you wrote about how long they've been dating, etc., doesn't really matter.  And quite frankly, with the number of people you say CAN make this, I don't think this one person is worth it.
      
    Pick one of those options and make it happen.  You are always going to have someone unhappy about every decision you make in the planning process.  All you can do if make you and FI happy.

    Just say, I'm terribly sorry.  This is what is going to work for us, our schedules and our budget.  Your presence will be sorely missed.  If future SIL chooses to act like an asshat, that's on her, not you. 
  • When picking a date, usually the VIPs are talked to beforehand.  For me, this would be our parents and my sisters (FI is an only child).  If this guy is that important to you, then pick another date, if not, then just go through with it.
    image
  • my friend from high school is getting married one of those dates- I do not want my friends to have to choose which wedding to go to & not have half of my friends there. The other reason is my brother would not be able to make the wedding and he is a VIP and in the wedding. He has to be there and we would also not be able to go on a honeymoon (which is something we want to do) due to my FI being a teacher and working that Monday. 
  • Posters post true: Which is more important 1) your future sister-in-law's boyfriend or 2) the venue/wedding day.

    IMHO, I would book what made me happy (which may be option 2). The fact that the boyfriend won't be there will not change the fact of who I am going to marry. However, I get that venues can be really hard to book, especially if it is in your budget.

    My fiance couldn't attend a wedding I was standing up in, and I didn't yell at the bride for it....I think the boyfriend is taking this too personally.
    Daisypath Wedding tickers
  • Paragraphs please? I'm not even going to attempt to read that.

    image
  • Quite frankly, if I was your MOH, I'd tell my b/f to grow up, get over it, and that we don't need to be attached at the hip 24/7.  Then I'd encourage you to not worry about it and go on with the plans that work best for you all. BUT, it sounds like although she understands, she will be really disappointed.

    Unfortunately, it is very possible that any other date chosen will be a bad date for someone else important.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • My advice is go with the date that you feel the most happy with. The day is about you. I have heard that sentence sooo many times, and I can't tell you how much of my wedding is NOT about me because someone wanted it and I was a push over. PLEASE do what makes you happy and as long as the MOH can be there you have nothing to worry about. I don't think you should decide on a date because of that situation. My parent and my MIL/FIL both live in different states. I wanted to get married in the Fall. I decided the date with a little help from my parents to see when my mom was available because she is also in the teaching field. What ultimately decided the date for us is when our venue was available not when people were. If they love you they will be there.
  • Since you say that FSIL and this guy are serious, he could be your BIL one day. As a hypothetical, How would you feel if they picked a date for their wedding that meant you could not attend? 

    Wedding planning sucks when you have to work around peoples schedules, but if it were me I'd pick the date of the the HS friends wedding b/c 1) you don't know what her guest list is going to be (there might not be the overlap in the guest list you're worried about) and 2) I'd rather pick a date that 100% works for all members (or future members) of my family, and have some friends not be able to make it. The truth is, 10 years down the line you might not even be speaking to many of the HS friends you're accommodating, but FSIL's BF could be your BIL. 

    In the end you can't please everyone, but I would think long and hard about excluding someone who means so much to someone who mean so much to you...



    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • The only issue with that option is that my best friend since middle school is also in my hs friends wedding and will be in mine. I don't want her to have to choose between which wedding to go to and I really want her at my wedding and consider her a VIP. I completely agree with everything else you said though because besides her, I won't really have many other friend conflicts. I feel terrible that my possible FBIL may not be at my wedding when he will be a part of many things over our life time & that I am hurting someone so close to me. But I can't ask my other friend to choose because I know that I want her there & she is really special to me. I agree that I would be really upset if I couldn't make my MOHs wedding but I also know that I would not attend anyone else's wedding over hers- even all of my other close friends. Which would be so terrible if I had to back out of someone's wedding party & may cost me a friend but she is my family and like you said I know we will always be a part of each others lives forever.
  • He might be your FBIL but then again he might not be. It sounds like your best friend/FI's sister is the real VIP here, not the guy.

    You will never be able to pick a date that works for everyone. If being at your wedding is so important to him than he has the option to skip that wedding to come to yours or even cut the time in half so he can at least go to part of both.


  • Do you have to get married in a church?  If you're not members it seems like you could pick a different location.  If religion is important find a pastor/priest/reverend/whatever and explain your sticky situation and get him/her to marry you at your reception location.
  • Paragraphs please? I'm not even going to attempt to read that.

    When using an iPad, it won't let you put paragraphs in. Even if I were to enter a few times Like this.... It will come out mashed together.
  • Boyfriends and Girlfriends of family members are not usually VIP's. They might be invited to the wedding, but planning around their schedules is almost impossible. I went to my high school boyfriend's brother's wedding, but I was not at my FI's brother's wedding. People who are in the boyfriend/girlfriend position should realize that even if they are really serious and perhaps might be a BIL/SIL someday, they are not currently. 

    If he is your BIL someday, he will have to understand and move on. This animosity can't last forever. This too will pass. 
  • keep the same date that works for you. she is not obligated to go to the wedding that her bf is  nor is he. unless hes really close friends with this person then he should go to that wedding. but let your moh attend yours family comes first. r


    you cant let people dictate when your special day is you need to stand your ground and say i really want you at the wedding on this date. the moh should have no problem telling her bf hey its my brothers wedding i have to attend that but you can attend your friends wedding



  • IMO, I wouldn't care if my best friends bf of the year was there. My sister just dumped her bf of 1.5 years a few months ago. IMO, a year isn't a big deal. Book your dream wedding, and forget about the dude. 
    Married 10/09/11
    Miss Claire born 5/29/13
    Our Happy Little Family
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards