I teared up over some peoples stories. But I didn't cry when I was proposed to and I still don't when I think about it/reread it/tell someone about it. I love everything about my proposal story, but it doesn't matter to me that I don't tear up over it. Don't worry too much about it. As long as your happy with your proposal, that's all that matters.
I like how you talked about your old pajamas. I was wearing a winter hat that looks like moose head, with antlers sticking up off the top of it and everything. The first thing Rob said to me after I said yes was "I can't believe I just proposed to a girl in a moose hat". Really, just enjoy it for what it was. It was done out love and that's all that matter!
Re: Proposal Stories