this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Etiquette Forum

VERY small wedding - is it wrong not to invite family members?

Hi, I've been dealing with some SERIOUS family drama recently. My fiancé and I have decided we want a VERY small, intimate, and sentimental wedding.

We are getting married in a spot where my grandfather's ashes are spread (he passed away and last year and it means a lot to me for him to "be there"). This was his favorite spot in the world and also happens to be at the golf course he owned with my father.

We are inviting only 20-25 people. We don't really like attention and just want this to be a special moment shared with the people we are closest to.

The "reception", if you can call it that will be in the same location. By reception, I just mean dinner. We aren't having dancing or anything else that traditionally comes with weddings. But because we are having an intimate wedding, we want to splurge a little. We want nice decor and a nice 3 or 4 course meal delivered to our guests at their table.

It's very important to us to be able to do this for the people we love the most, and it's very important to us to share this bond with only them.

Now here's where the drama comes into play. My mother is extremely hurt that her siblings are not invited. First of all, she has 4 of them
and 3 have spouses. So that's 7 people...if we add them that's increasing our guest list by almost 30%. And with the dinner we want to have, that's almost $500 extra. My parents can't afford to pay for that. We're paying for most of the wedding ourselves. Second of all, I'm not particularly close with them. I see them about once a year at Christmas and that's it. It's not that I don't like them and don't want them there, it's simply just that we can't afford to have the wedding we want to have if we invite them, and it kinda takes away from the super sentimal value of ONLY inviting people we are VERY close to and see and speak to regularly.

I'm inviting ONE of my uncles (and his family) on my dad's side because I am extremely close with them. Whenever I am home visiting, I spend nearly every day with them. I don't spend any time with my mom's side of the family unless it's Christmas Eve.

I should probably also mention that the grandfather who passed is on my Dad's side, so the ceremony site is not a factor in the argument for my mom's side of the family.

I'm having to deal with my parents threatening to not let me have the wedding, backing out of financial contributions they promised (which is fine...if we have to pay for everything ourselves to have the wedding we want to have, we will), and just saying downright hurtful things.

I'm not sure they really understand what this wedding is...that it's not really a wedding in the traditional sense. I agree it would be wrong not to invite them if we were having a normal wedding, but that's just not the case.

My mom's original solution was to have an informal BBQ the day after the wedding for the people not invited. I agreed, but now it's not enough. We go back and forth every day. I tell her how hurt I am and she says she understands and tells me to have the wedding I want to have, then the next day she's upset again and she's telling me I'm not allowed to have the wedding I want. It's incredibly exhausting. And I've spent every single day since our engagement depressed and crying.

I'm not sure what to do. I don't really want to budge on this because it's just SO important to me to ONLY share this experience with certain people.

My fiancé is upset because this is really important to him as well...and he's the one paying for most of it.

My parents are also upset because my fiancé has ONE of his uncles coming and a couple of his friends. He doesn't have grandparents like I do, so he inviting his childhood neighbors (the closest thing he ever had to grandparents), and he went to boarding school for high school, so he's always compensated his friends as family. He lived with them during the most impressionable period of his life.

My parents are being dramatic and saying that his WHOLE side is coming, which isn't true.

We purposely invited an even amount of guests. I don't see how they can have a problem with him inviting the people closest to him. This is his wedding too, and his guests are just as important as mine.

I don't know what to. I really hate this, and I really have tried to add the people they want to the list...I even tried to have a 60 person wedding with cheap buffet catering to try to please them...but both options put us way too far over our budget. I've decided that I need to stay strong and have the wedding that both my fiancé and I want to have and hope they come around and understand. It's the only way I can actually look forward to my wedding because right now I just don't. :(

Re: VERY small wedding - is it wrong not to invite family members?

  • It does seem a bit unfair to pick and choose family members like that (unless, of course, you are fine with distancing yourself from them forever and cutting them out of your life).

    Fi and I are planning a very intimate wedding for the same reason (not wanting to be fawned over with attention all day), but we are inviting immediate family only (me, fi, moms, dads, fail+fbil). and that's IT.

    Commonly it's suggested to invite in circles (as in, you invite all grandparents, all aunts, all uncles, all best friends, all coworker friends, etc.).

    I know from personal experience how stressful it can be to feel your wedding growing beyond your control, but I think this is just where you need to make a decision: is it more important for you to have a small wedding or is it more important for you to have certain family members in attendence?

  • It does seem a bit unfair to pick and choose family members like that (unless, of course, you are fine with distancing yourself from them forever and cutting them out of your life).
    Wow, that seems really dramatic. I know weddings are a big deal but I can't imagine never speaking to anyone again because they decided to have a small wedding and I wasn't invited.

    OP - it really sucks that your parents can't be adults about this. At this point I would decline their offer to help and refuse to discuss the matter anymore.


  • JennyColadaJennyColada member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its Third Anniversary First Answer
    edited March 2014

    It does seem a bit unfair to pick and choose family members like that (unless, of course, you are fine with distancing yourself from them forever and cutting them out of your life).
    Wow, that seems really dramatic. I know weddings are a big deal but I can't imagine never speaking to anyone again because they decided to have a small wedding and I wasn't invited.
    Well for an aunt who may think they're close to someone, and then to not be invited when other aunts/uncles are, that can be a rather dramatic situation.

    I mean, you really don't have to justify your invitations (or lack of) to anyone, but I do think that it becomes very hairy territory when you need to explain "sorry uncle Joe, but you're just not that close to me, but Aunt Sally is!".
    ETA: But I kind of meant it in terms of that if you're already on rocky ground with someone that isn't a good influence on your life, that it's silly to feel like you "should" invite them just because they fall into a "circle".
  • Heck, I'm having a 150 person wedding and didn't invite any of my aunts/uncles/cousins, etc.. You invite who you are close to, bottom line. You're not required to invite one person just because you invited another within a similar circle. All relationships are different and can be treated as such.
  • Ditto Phira. Present a united front and don't allow anyone to continue to try to guilt you.
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • My mother is 1 of 9. If I invited all of her side there would legit be no room for any other guests. So the aunts and uncles I'm close with, the cousin's I'm close with are the one's that I'm inviting.

    However, I know I'm also prepared to tell them that "with the venue WE have chosen, all the guests we would love to invite are just not an option. I'm sorry" Nice but firm.

    If you are paying, you're not in the wrong. So, I agree with others: Decline money and appologize for upset but stand your ground. Good luck.
  • Hi, I've been dealing with some SERIOUS family drama recently. My fiancé and I have decided we want a VERY small, intimate, and sentimental wedding. We are getting married in a spot where my grandfather's ashes are spread (he passed away and last year and it means a lot to me for him to "be there"). This was his favorite spot in the world and also happens to be at the golf course he owned with my father. We are inviting only 20-25 people. We don't really like attention and just want this to be a special moment shared with the people we are closest to. The "reception", if you can call it that will be in the same location. By reception, I just mean dinner. We aren't having dancing or anything else that traditionally comes with weddings. But because we are having an intimate wedding, we want to splurge a little. We want nice decor and a nice 3 or 4 course meal delivered to our guests at their table. It's very important to us to be able to do this for the people we love the most, and it's very important to us to share this bond with only them. Now here's where the drama comes into play. My mother is extremely hurt that her siblings are not invited. First of all, she has 4 of them and 3 have spouses. So that's 7 people...if we add them that's increasing our guest list by almost 30%. And with the dinner we want to have, that's almost $500 extra. My parents can't afford to pay for that. We're paying for most of the wedding ourselves. Second of all, I'm not particularly close with them. I see them about once a year at Christmas and that's it. It's not that I don't like them and don't want them there, it's simply just that we can't afford to have the wedding we want to have if we invite them, and it kinda takes away from the super sentimal value of ONLY inviting people we are VERY close to and see and speak to regularly. I'm inviting ONE of my uncles (and his family) on my dad's side because I am extremely close with them. Whenever I am home visiting, I spend nearly every day with them. I don't spend any time with my mom's side of the family unless it's Christmas Eve. I should probably also mention that the grandfather who passed is on my Dad's side, so the ceremony site is not a factor in the argument for my mom's side of the family. I'm having to deal with my parents threatening to not let me have the wedding, backing out of financial contributions they promised (which is fine...if we have to pay for everything ourselves to have the wedding we want to have, we will), and just saying downright hurtful things. I'm not sure they really understand what this wedding is...that it's not really a wedding in the traditional sense. I agree it would be wrong not to invite them if we were having a normal wedding, but that's just not the case. My mom's original solution was to have an informal BBQ the day after the wedding for the people not invited. I agreed, but now it's not enough. We go back and forth every day. I tell her how hurt I am and she says she understands and tells me to have the wedding I want to have, then the next day she's upset again and she's telling me I'm not allowed to have the wedding I want. It's incredibly exhausting. And I've spent every single day since our engagement depressed and crying. I'm not sure what to do. I don't really want to budge on this because it's just SO important to me to ONLY share this experience with certain people. My fiancé is upset because this is really important to him as well...and he's the one paying for most of it. My parents are also upset because my fiancé has ONE of his uncles coming and a couple of his friends. He doesn't have grandparents like I do, so he inviting his childhood neighbors (the closest thing he ever had to grandparents), and he went to boarding school for high school, so he's always compensated his friends as family. He lived with them during the most impressionable period of his life. My parents are being dramatic and saying that his WHOLE side is coming, which isn't true. We purposely invited an even amount of guests. I don't see how they can have a problem with him inviting the people closest to him. This is his wedding too, and his guests are just as important as mine. I don't know what to. I really hate this, and I really have tried to add the people they want to the list...I even tried to have a 60 person wedding with cheap buffet catering to try to please them...but both options put us way too far over our budget. I've decided that I need to stay strong and have the wedding that both my fiancé and I want to have and hope they come around and understand. It's the only way I can actually look forward to my wedding because right now I just don't. :(
    If you can afford to pay for the wedding you are planning without your parent's money, then decline it entirely.  Then keep planning the wedding you want and stop discussing the plans with your parents.  Just send the invite to them with the time comes.  It will do wonderfully for your emotional health as well, since you said yourself you have not been enjoying this process and are crying frequently.
  • I just want to add, OP, that your wedding is definitely a real wedding. It's normal, it's an actual wedding, it's really a wedding. Also, your reception is a real reception. Just because it doesn't fit the "mold" of a big, huge party that most weddings tend to be, that doesn't make it any less real or normal. 

    I also agree with PPs that you and FI need to present a united front to your parents, and definitely be prepared to pay for everything on your own. Cease talking to your parents about your wedding plans after that conversation, and if they ask any questions, just say "We want everything to be a surprise! You'll have to wait until the day of!"
  • FI and I are having 35 people at our wedding. My grandma has been trying to guilt me into inviting all her children since we got engaged. Since we are having such a small wedding we decided to invite a few friends rather than extended relatives we see once a year. This has caused some drama between me and my grandma, but FI and I have stood firm.. If you want a small wedding then have a small wedding, but if either of you give in even a little bit be prepared for them to keep doing this to you about everyone. 
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards